SajuukKhar said:
The Heik said:
Only the thu'um requires that Dragons use shouts, but dragons have other magics beyond the thu'um. Dragon's fly using other magics, Dragons speak in the human speech, despite not having facial structure to support human speech, using magic, and some dragons even practiced necromancy. Dragons are not limited to Thu'um based magics.
Yes they are, or rather, they'd never NEED to use any other form of magic. Thu'um is a magic where any combination of words can form an immensely powerful spell. It is literally will made reality, and it completely outclasses any form of terrestrial magic by several orders of magnitude.
Let me mention just a few of the Shouts that exist in the world:
-A shout that can bend time
-A shout that can summon a meteoric storm onto the landscape
-A shout that can blast back the atmosphere of the planet
-A shout that can bend the will of creatures, dragons and even
the earth itself to do the user's bidding
-A shout that can summon dragons and dead heroes from the very Ether
-A shout that can force the concept of mortality to immortal beings
And all for effectively no cost to the user (considering how prolifically it is used by both the Dovah and the Greybeards), versus standard magic spells that drain magicka, a fairly finite resource that can be easily drained by the casting of just a few spells (although it does replenish slowly). The only reason why Thu'um isn't completely overpowered in the game is because otherwise the old magic system would be rendered completely obsolete by it, which would break the game. That's why the cool-downs for the shouts exist and why they are nowhere near as powerful as they should be (I mean come on, is a random fireball thrown by a dinky mage really going to do more damage that a meteor screaming down from the heavens? Not bloody likely).
Also, I feel the need to mention that Durnehviir, the only dragon in current lore that practiced necromancy, still used Shouts as the means to cast those spells (specifically RII VAAZ ZOL or "Soul Tear"), so even Necromancy is still covered under the Thu'um purview
SajuukKhar said:
As for why the dragons have wings despite using magic to fly, because that is the way their father Akatosh created them. Same reason why they dont reproduce despite that being massively detrimental in keeping their population stable.
http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:King_Edward,_Part_XII
Moraelyn asked with a smile, "All right then, I've always wanted to know this - considering the shape of your mouth and teeth, how do dragons manage to speak the humanoid languages so clearly?"
Akatosh paused, and then carefully responded, "Why, in much the same way that we can fly, even though our wings are not naturally strong enough to support such heavy torsos."
Ok, little bit of advice. You don't want to use 15 year old game documents to justify why things happen in the latest edition of a series as long and constantly changing as Elder Scrolls. For instance, any lore prior to Skyrim doesn't mention a single thing about the Thu'um, yet that is not only the preferred method of combat for dragons in Skyrim, but the
only non-physical attack that they use at all and is now a fairly significant part of Tamriel's history (both draconic and terrestrial, though skyrim in particular has most of that focus). It was quite literally shoe-horned in by the writers to add a new feature to the game (even though in truth it worked itself in quite smoothly)
Besides, just because that lore exists doesn't mean it matches the real world experiences. In Skyrim's gameplay if the dragon's flew via magic they'd rocket into the sky and zoom around like superman, hovering damn near perfectly exactly where they want to be or go. But that doesn't happen. They flap their wings to launch and hover in place, bobbing up and down with each wingbeat, and have to bank and angle themselves like real life. More importantly, when they're wounded enough they crash to the ground and can't fly again, yet they can still use Shouts (ie magic), supporting the case that their flight is at very least mostly dependent (read: 50% or more) on their wings to fly, else they could just fly up again with little difficulty. As much as old lore might say otherwise, in cases like these the scientific principle of "show don't tell" trumps any textual data.
SajuukKhar said:
Also, many people dont fast travel, its called RPing, something few people seem to do in RPGs anymore.
Dragon riding is fun for people who RP.
Yes, but they are a minority compared to the people who use fast travel. Also, you need to realize that RPing is the act of putting
constraints on your playstyle in order to create a semblance of personal narrative. That can often mean that people will overlook far more practical or convenient methods to get the job done. And that's the ultimate problem with dragon riding in Skyrim. Yes it would be cool, yes it may work well for certain RP situations, but it is not the go-to method for getting around or fighting because it is so clunky. It's a niche thing, and it's not going to be the main reason why people are playing the game.