My name is Inigo Montaya. You killed my father. Prepare to die.Oliver Pink said:The Princess Bride.... oh for the love of all that is holy, NEVER remake the Princess Bride.
You can't top perfection.
Well it appears we've met an impasse, I both thought the old unofficial Casino Royale with David Niven was great and I believe Goldeneye is one of the best James Bond films ever made.tigermilk said:Well there have been three versions of Casino Royale, an American TV version, an 'unofficial' film version then most recently an 'official' film version. I think both the first and third versions are worth watching. I take your point though, in my opinion the Bond films either have a charm which couldn't be replicated (Goldfinger, Diamonds are Forever) or are just dire and should be forgotten (Goldeneye (i think) great game, film was a long boring advert for phones and cars with a plot tacked on).
Different strokes for different folks I suppose. Personally the Bond films made during my 'cinema viewing lifetime' with a reliance on technology didn't really appeal. Probably why I feel the most recent Casino Royale to be the third best Bond film I have seen (after Goldfinger and Diamonds are Forever).WolfThomas said:Well it appears we've met an impasse, I both thought the old unofficial Casino Royale with David Niven was great and I believe Goldeneye is one of the best James Bond films ever made.tigermilk said:Well there have been three versions of Casino Royale, an American TV version, an 'unofficial' film version then most recently an 'official' film version. I think both the first and third versions are worth watching. I take your point though, in my opinion the Bond films either have a charm which couldn't be replicated (Goldfinger, Diamonds are Forever) or are just dire and should be forgotten (Goldeneye (i think) great game, film was a long boring advert for phones and cars with a plot tacked on).
The remake of 'Get Carter' being a case in point. The original to my mind being the greatest British (and possibly overall) gangster/revenge film ever made. The Stallone remake on the other hand is one of the worst films ever made.deadman91 said:I can't think of anything to add... maybe just Guy Ritchie films (Lock Stock 'n Two Smoking Barrels would not work in New York)