For those who dislike cosplay...

Recommended Videos

Joe Matsuda

New member
Aug 24, 2009
693
0
0
hey, if people want to dress up, thats cool...just don't a fat guy dressed as a japanese school girl

...while not really cosplay since it was halloween, I've dressed up as the Question before

but I can see where cosplayers are comming from; its just fun to dress up as you favorite whatever......anyone even know who the Question is?
 

Marik2

Phone Poster
Nov 10, 2009
5,462
0
0
captainaweshum said:
Marik2 said:
I only like it when people take the time to cosplay right. Like these people.



By right do mean you only like it if you think the girls are cute?
No if the person cosplaying actually looks like the character there suppose to represent. Even hot girls can put on a costume and not look like the character, sure they may look pretty but they don't look like them is what I'm saying. And I would have posted guy cosplayers, but I've never seen a guy really look like the character they're suppose to look like.
 

CK76

New member
Sep 25, 2009
1,620
0
0
Theodore Sturgeon is right about most things, including cosplay.
 

zana bonanza

New member
Oct 22, 2009
110
0
0
Done right, it's awesome. Done wrong, it's funny. It's a win-win situation either way for me.

And I love the ones that are done right. I guess it just appeals that inner, geeky kid inside me that always wished my favorite characters were real. And yeah, I know they're not, don't jump my shit. I'm just saying, it makes me go wow.

Like, there's this girl who does a spot-on cosplay of Link. I mean, it's exactly what he would look like if he were real. She even goes to official Nintendo events as him, it's that good. I also saw a video (it might have even been on here, I think) of a guy who made an Iron-man suit that was just epic. Who wouldn't want their own Iron-man suit? And if you watch College Humor, they had a vid on this guy who made a Big Daddy and a Big Sister costume that looked like they were ripped straight from the game. That stuff amazes me.
 

ScruffyTheJanitor

New member
Jul 17, 2009
256
0
0
Cosplay I can understand from some angles. As long as you don't try to make me look like a fool in public, I'm ok with it. However, it's relation to LARP is dangerously scary and seeing some LARP at play had made me sorry about some corners of the human species.
 

SimuLord

Whom Gods Annoy
Aug 20, 2008
10,077
0
0
Most of us outgrow playing dress-up when we get our first pubic hair. I just find cosplay infantile.
 

A random person

New member
Apr 20, 2009
4,732
0
0
I fully, totally support good cosplay, examples of which are in this thread. I still acknowledge, however, that a lot of it's amateurish, and some is outright eye-destroying (like the guy who dresses up as Sailor Moon).
 

fanklok

Legendary Table User
Jul 17, 2009
2,355
0
0
When the costumes look atrociously fake then it grates on me but but when you post a picture online and I say to myself "Wait a fucking minute thar that ain't no CG that's some cosplayer." then it's legit awesomeness.



 

Blights

New member
Feb 16, 2009
899
0
0


It's great when done correctly.
 

DuX1112

New member
Mar 18, 2010
200
0
0
So why is everyone commenting on the physical appearance of cosplay? I'd think more people would actually ask (themselves and others) how psychologically healthy the whole thing is? I mean, doing a cosplay once just for the fun of it, and doing it all the time while pretending to assume a fictional character's "personality" are two very different things.

The second one borders with schizophrenia. Or obsession. Or fetishism. Neither of which are healthy patterns of mind and reek of (pathological) escapism.

Could be the actor talent too, but usually people who do acting - do acting primarily, while maybe dipping their toes into cosplay once in a while. Not that I know of an actor who actually does cosplay... Anyways, I wouldn't say actors do it to escape their shitty reality (or when they do, they use drugs and die). Actors don't get a fixation on fictional characters, they just play roles, or sth.

So yeah, be angry at me for not understanding the obsessive need to be someone else (often times, much COOLER) than self.

On a similar topic, I find it hard to understand people's swift fascinations with bands, brands, books (Twilight, oh the f...), products, movies or games. There's people who become totally crazy after a game/product after a week or a day of experiencing it (and proceed worshiping the product, living the fantasy, etc.), and there's me (or the likes of me) who would think twice before indulging deeper into the fantasy. Take Star Wars for example. I love the thing, grew up with it, but still, the idea of buying a Darth Vader costume still looks kinda silly to me. I mean, hell YES I WOULD want to buy it, but when I've had the chance, I was always quick to give up on it. Kinda, felt... too much. Maybe I experience fascination more fully, internally, so I don't need much paraphernalia, I don't know.
 

ShadowsofHope

Outsider
Nov 1, 2009
2,623
0
0
God said:

What isn't to love? When done right, it is awesome. When done wrong, it is funny as hell.
..Dear god, that's hot. And I agree. Done right (+), done wrong (EYE BLEACH, EYE BLEACH! $%^$#!).

Oh, and.. @Captain Blackout: ..Where do you have conventions? I want in!
 

Erja_Perttu

New member
May 6, 2009
1,847
0
0
Natty DL said:
Holy crap! That's incredible!

I've been to a few expos, and I've seen the really good, the really bad and the really bad ass. I think Cosplay is a good thing, because people who find other dressed as a character from the same series or thing they've done have a talking point, so you can make friends, compare ideas and techniques, and generally have fun.

Some of the crossovers and mismash costumes are great as well, and photo ops can be fantastic. Somewhere, I've got a picture of some stormtroopers taking out The Doctor and taking some potshots at a giant inflatable staypuft Marshmallow man.

There are some people who've had bad experiences, and damn, have I seen some piss poor costumes, we're all well aware that no one is happy with the fat sailor moon guy, but the good stuff is worth ignoring the bad for in my opinion.
 

Dr. wonderful

New member
Dec 31, 2009
3,260
0
0
Chancie said:
I have a serious question to ask you.

Why?
What is it about cosplay you dislike?

I'm not trying to be a jerk or anything like that; I'm honestly curious. I've heard a lot of people say that they think it's creepy and I've also heard people mention that it's only "retarded fangirls" that do it.
So, I'm not asking about the people that cosplay and why you dislike them. I'm asking what you don't like about cosplay itself, if there's anything.

In case you don't know, cosplay is basically dressing up as an anime or video game character.
I don't hate cosplay per se , I love the creativty, the fun, seeing who did it, and who didn't.

Also fangirls mess up everything with fan pairings...then again, a skilled writer could turn those fan pairings into better then canon.

What I hate about cosplay though, is when it dosen't frecking match! I mean, if you going dress up, match the damn character in physical make up (If the character is buff but slim, please be buff and slim)

Or otherwise you get this:


but then you come get something so crazy awesome, you gotta see it:

.
Well that's all I got to say on the subject
 

Zykon TheLich

Extra Heretical!
Legacy
Jun 6, 2008
3,506
850
118
Country
UK
Meh, whatever, certainly wouldn't do it myself.

Some of the cosplayers posted at the start do look very attractive, but that's all to do with the person, not the costume. Those girls would look good in an old potato sack, let alone skimpy anime costumes.
 

Ghostkai

New member
Jun 14, 2008
1,170
0
0
Done well, it looks fantastic. Sadly, a good 90%+ is horrid, and those people should be shot.