here comes a list:
Mass effect2: my heart pumped through the whole suicide mission and the feeling when blowing up the base, MAGNIFICENT!
Bioshock: a lot of moments but the beginning in particular *shivers the good way*.
Halo Series: also a lot of moments made me shiver.
The Beatles Rockband: feelings of joy and sadness I didn't expect from a music game.
gears of war 2: the big speech and when you find maria.
Assasin's Creed: a beautiful game, that says enough.
Dragon Age: The whole game was just WOW.
also the Elders Scrolls series, I had a reason that I almost cried of joy when I saw the trailer.
DrathLegion said:
But if I am to go for a recent game; Company of Myself [http://www.freewebarcade.com/game/the-company-of-myself/]
It'll take you 15 minutes tops, and is one of the biggest slaps to the face I've encountered.
I second this, Powerful stuff indeed