George Lucas fucking with Star wars again.
- Thread starter Thumper17
- Start date
Recommended Videos
Good god, I have no problem with these themselves, but the second one I've just had a bit of a problem with over the years. I mean, it's Lucas' own canon. He's changed that sound a million goddamn times. Shouldn't he of all people know wtf a Krayt Dragon sounds like?
For reference:
For reference:
I always thought the sound in that scene sounded more like the landspeeder suddenly starting up or something. The new sound definitely sounds more like some sort of creature I wouldn't wanna fuck with even if I was a sandperson with friends.Asita said:
The extra dialogue in the first clip not only doesn't sound like Vader, in my opinion it really ruins the moment. I managed to figure out what was going on just fine the first time I watched it, I don't see any need for Lucas to hold our hands.
That argument would have more weight if Lucas would release the remastered, but un-enhanced, original trilogy. Unfortunately the options he has given us are a VHS rip on DVD or all of his fiddling. I wouldn't care a lick about his adjustments as long as I could get a decent copy of the original version.Karthak said:
Well... maybe there IS something in that theory Iron Liz had: George Lucas is crazy, and he wants to destroy what he created- but not by throwing it away. Instead, ha makes the franchise rot from the inside, creates crappy sequels and adds in unnecesary changes to the original trilogy until it shatters to pieces.
...okay, I made up most of that theory right now, but I'm pretty sure that's what she meant.
...okay, I made up most of that theory right now, but I'm pretty sure that's what she meant.
Ah, it'll do. The main point is to distract him before he starts CGI replacing Lando Calrissian with Jar Jar Binks.shogunblade said:
Now we need to find someone to tell him it's about a cute Duck that runs around with normal people and has plenty of merchandising to the kids potential.
Vader Scene: Vader was completely silent. See here for comparison.Daniel Forman said:
Sandpeople scene: Listen for yourself
Maybe we can just give him some paper and some crayons and have him sit in the corner.Hero in a half shell said:
EDIT: Oh and I forgot to say that Ben's new cry sounds like he accidentally swallowed a didgeridoo when he saw something shiny.
Lucas didn't make Star Wars Lucas made the prequels.
Everyone involved with the first Star Wars movies contributed a lot to the films but in the prequels everyone involved had no spine and agreed with everything he said even though you can see on there faces they know Lucas is a **** with no good ideas.
Can you see the difference, its pretty clear.
I'm probably wrong though I'm just loosely quoting Plinkett's reviews on the three prequels I seen last year.
Everyone involved with the first Star Wars movies contributed a lot to the films but in the prequels everyone involved had no spine and agreed with everything he said even though you can see on there faces they know Lucas is a **** with no good ideas.
Can you see the difference, its pretty clear.
I'm probably wrong though I'm just loosely quoting Plinkett's reviews on the three prequels I seen last year.
Why is it that such little changes matter so much to star wars fans? The original copies are out there.
someone needs to give him a firm pat on the back and say "this cow has been milked for all shes worth...time to move on to greener pastures."
Ok...Obi-wan's little "woooo" made me laugh hysterically...and it sounds like the soundtrack to a haunted house after that...and I agree with the others on Vader...his body language was enough to show conflict and his decision to save Luke...even if you can't see his face...you could tell it really bothered him and he was conflicted in his loyalties...it was one of the biggest character arcs for Vader