I actually didn't beg for character development. But not all change is development. Character development typically means seeing the change justified over time. We went from a dispassionate, experienced, focused professional in Halo: CE - Halo 3 to Mr. Lovey-Dovey in Halo 4. If he has feelings for Cortana, the question is when did he become interested in romance? And when did he start displaying emotions so outwardly? Halo: CE Chief wouldn't have done that. So what caused the change? You might argue that some character's death caused it, or the stress of combat caused it, or being in love caused it, or losing his inheritance on the stock market caused it. But the fact is it's never presented to the audience that way. That explanation is indistinguishable from an ass-pull. At best, we're glossing over his change of character and the causes behind it. But that's the interesting stuff! The answer is nothing caused the change, at least nothing we ever see. He just went into that cryotube with one personality and came out with another. Showing Chief's face would have ruined the old Master Chief. But that doesn't really apply to the new Master Chief, because he's a completely different character.Spartan16 said:My problem is though, with Master Chief we have constantly had the vessel for the player vs. a character of his own argument. Personally I am more of a ?character of his own? supporter and you can?t have It both ways, beg for character development then complain when it is done?.. Conversely the Chief that you desire/describe is the one that I described as to why the resentment to a new Cortana model would not work?..
In short, displaying feelings for Cortana is a change, but it's hardly 'character development' as the term is typically used.
Also, I think your memory of Johnson's death is a little rusty:
I don't exactly imagine Chief getting misty-eyed under that helmet. He respects life. He may even grieve under that helmet. But we don't see it, because his character is such that he does not show it. If you were to actually show me, in-game how we went from that Chief to the new one, then you could call it character development.