I tend to really not like anime, but I keep trying different ones out because a lot of them are so bizarre that it's nice to at least get something different once in a while, even if it's shit.
Not counting DBZ and pokemon because I watched those when I was a kid, really the only anime that I would acknowledge as really fucking good is Samurai Champloo. 90% of anime is filled with extremely unlikable characters who just fall into some archetype and have like, one character trait. Samurai Champloo had great character development and storytelling, and best of all, it was blended in with the action. There was little no "Here's 20 minutes of plot development in which nothing interesting happens, now here's a new pointless character that you have to keep track of." Also, when there's a fight to the death, you're supposed to try to kill the other person, not do something, then explain what you did, then taunt them about how they aren't going to win, then allow them 30 seconds to evaluate your ability.
So yeah, that seems to be the one exception. I've heard Cowboy Bebop is good too but I still haven't gotten around to watching it. Though if someone can recommend an anime that's similar to samurai champloo, or is at least good in the regular sense of the word rather than just the anime sense of the word, I'll definitely give it a shot.