I'm absolutely loving it. Frankly, I think anyone who doubts that it has improved on DAO in 8/10 ways doesn't know what they are talking about, but, to each their own. The new "Action-oriented approach" is not nearly as bad as everyone claims. I'm thoroughly enjoying the strategy, the character depth and the more personal feel. I don't dislike being confined to Kirkwall at all. Before I only spent as much time in the various areas as I had to, anyway, so I get all the same scenery I need in this game.
A problem is that my version is pretty buggy. Lots of stuttering, glitchy textures, pop-up and getting stuck in the environment. Still I suppose that's what I get for being a console gamer. Currently though, I love playing as a Rogue and utilizing all these cool agile powers. The new leveling trees are great and all the companions have great depth. Navigating the city of Kirkwall's many upper class areas, dirty slums, and abandoned mines during the day or night is just as interesting as venturing into the outlying regions. Being unable to swap out my companions armour is not remotely missed. It means they keep their identity, can still be upgraded and there's less tediousness to it all. Crafting has been refined to the point where the obsessive crafters can enjoy it and the dabblers don't need to wade through boring resource finding.
The game's a beauty and one of the few I deemed a definite release-day buy (well, European release day) and then totally worth it in retrospect.