I agree with you, mostly because people (like Yahtzee) call this one on basis of having a great story arc, and you not playing a super marine with expertise on all weapons ever build, but a regular (if somehow douchey) guy that gets thrown in an awful situation and initially freaks out like a regular guy. But then the first thing you do is climb a pretty big tower and fix a beacon, flawlessly and without training.
At that point, I realize there is no difference between the super marine and the douchey guy, but at least the marine has a justification for being a badass. Not that it ruined the game, but it made all the effort made to characterize Brody as disingenuous or just counterproductive.
Also, for all the effort Yahtzee makes on racist jokes out of Resident Evil and Uncharted, he fails to notice the big "Mighty Whitey" undertones of all Far Cry games.
At that point, I realize there is no difference between the super marine and the douchey guy, but at least the marine has a justification for being a badass. Not that it ruined the game, but it made all the effort made to characterize Brody as disingenuous or just counterproductive.
Also, for all the effort Yahtzee makes on racist jokes out of Resident Evil and Uncharted, he fails to notice the big "Mighty Whitey" undertones of all Far Cry games.