If Halo had been a PC game...

Recommended Videos

Erana

New member
Feb 28, 2008
8,010
0
0
You either love it or hate it; Some gamers feel general indifference to it. But what if it had been developed for the PC? Lets rewind to the late 90's, and say Microsoft had passed up this moderately successful FPS developer.

As a result, the development of Halo proceeds down the path of the PC shooter. You know that inexplicable difference in how a console and PC game feels? Well, Halo is now all about that.
Also, the player can hold a complete arseonal of weapons (with the power of the weapons balanced to fit such gameplay)
Each level is more neatly packaged as an idividual event; the areas are more expansive but less linear.
Proceeding through the game is more complex than the actual Halo; there are more objectives in each level, and puzzles come into play.
Characters and dialogue is fleshed out, and there are many moments in the game in which no action is involved whatsoever. (Moreso than just suspense building before a battle against the flood)
Vehicles are still used, but vehicular combat is less so.
The most striking difference in this hypothetical PC game and the true Halo series is that as an independent developer, Bungie doesn't have Microsoft breathing down its neck. They take longer to make their games, but eventually they produce exactly the games that they set out to make from the start.
~~~
So what was that rant about, really? Its my vision of what Halo would be like if it had been for the PC. Am I trying to say, "It would have been a better game on the PC,"? No. Halo is a streamlined, all-action shooter. That's part of why the reception towards it is generally polarized. I'm just musing here on what I think the Halo series would have been like if it hadn't been for the Xbox; what I'm looking for here in this thread is not so much looking at my hypothetical game, but seeing what other 'Scapists think.

What would you imagine Halo to be if it had been developed with a more typical approach to a PC FPS and the according market? Would you play it?
If you wouldn't play a PC oriented Halo series, what would have to change to make you want to?

[small]Everyone has the right to their opinion, but I'd appreciate you refraining from making low-content posts. Also, I would like to point out the possibility that people may just not want to ever play a Halo game because the very things that define what Halo is is not appealing. If you feel this way, I ask that you either explain why, or refrain from posting altogether because I just posted your opinion, and therefore your post would be redundant. Conversely, if you're going to say, "I would play a halo game no matter what," still explain what you think a Halo PC game would be like, and possibly what you wouldn't like about it. Just please, remain on topic. It would be better for you to take anything not specifically about the idea of Halo as a PC game into one of the hundreds of other Halo related threads out there, even if this thread is dying. Thank you![/small]
 

jmd102993

New member
Mar 6, 2009
127
0
0
Frankly i think halo might have been a better game had it been developed on the PC, most likely it would have gotten more development on its story, not that its story is bad as is but in comparison to how it could have been just off of Halo 1, but because of that its multiplayer aspect would have fallen, and weather you liek it or not the halo franchise, along with the Call of Duty franchise, has set a pace for a lot of the newer first person shooters in terms of online play, so yea it may have been better on the PC, but think of the ripple effects on other games
 

jmd102993

New member
Mar 6, 2009
127
0
0
Hashime said:
Halo 1 and 2 are avalible for the PC.
just another note, i got halo 1 on the PC before i ever even played it on the Xbox and still liked it fine, online aspects and single player, but what the guy is aqsking is if it had been designed and made as a PC exclusive
 

Delusibeta

Reachin' out...
Mar 7, 2010
2,594
0
0
Hashime said:
Halo 1 and 2 are avalible for the PC.
I was just about to raise that point. That said, both were external ports, and so isn't really relevent to this thread.

I would imagine there would be a few minor changes (such as the "only hold 2 weapons" rule being dropped), but to be honest, I can't see Halo being too different if it was developed primarily for PC.
 

Erana

New member
Feb 28, 2008
8,010
0
0
Hashime said:
Halo 1 and 2 are avalible for the PC.
Erana said:
What would you imagine Halo to be if it had been developed with a more typical approach to a PC FPS and the according market? Would you play it?
If you wouldn't play a PC oriented Halo series, what would have to change to make you want to?
NightShadeNes said:
Halo should be on pc,every FPS should be on pc
Erana said:
[small]Everyone has the right to their opinion, but I'd appreciate you refraining from making low-content posts. Also, I would like to point out the possibility that people may just not want to ever play a Halo game because the very things that define what Halo is is not appealing. If you feel this way, I ask that you either explain why, or refrain from posting altogether because I just posted your opinion, and therefore your post would be redundant. Conversely, if you're going to say, "I would play a halo game no matter what," still explain what you think a Halo PC game would be like, and possibly what you wouldn't like about it. Just please, remain on topic. It would be better for you to take anything not specifically about the idea of Halo as a PC game into one of the hundreds of other Halo related threads out there, even if this thread is dying. Thank you![/small]
Please read the OP.
jmd102993 said:
Frankly i think halo might have been a better game had it been developed on the PC, most likely it would have gotten more development on its story, not that its story is bad as is but in comparison to how it could have been just off of Halo 1, but because of that its multiplayer aspect would have fallen, and weather you liek it or not the halo franchise, along with the Call of Duty franchise, has set a pace for a lot of the newer first person shooters in terms of online play, so yea it may have been better on the PC, but think of the ripple effects on other games
Hrm... I don't factor in enough the "ripple effects" of Halo. It did change things for better or worse, and it would be interesting how the reactions to Halo effected the development of Halo 2 and 3...
The problem with that though is that if the regenerating health, limited weaponspace and general Halo-ness had never come around, the FPS market would have prolly gone in a different direction entirely, with Halo marching along with it.
 

tzimize

New member
Mar 1, 2010
2,391
0
0
If halo was on pc the gameplay would be better, because it would be tailored to pcgamers better/faster aiming and movement.

This would make halo better, but I probably still wouldnt play it. I've tried it on pc, and it was so dull I couldnt even complete it. Master Chief does absolutely NOTHING for me. He's about as interesting as a brick, and the overall story is extremely uninteresting.

In short the only thing that could make me play halo was if it was a different game.
 

carpathic

New member
Oct 5, 2009
1,287
0
0
I enjoy halo as well. Not sure how different it would be except for the crazy rig you would need to really rock that game with an acceptable FPS rating.
 

jmd102993

New member
Mar 6, 2009
127
0
0
Delusibeta said:
Hashime said:
Halo 1 and 2 are avalible for the PC.
I was just about to raise that point. That said, both were external ports, and so isn't really relevent to this thread.

I would imagine there would be a few minor changes (such as the "only hold 2 weapons" rule being dropped), but to be honest, I can't see Halo being too different if it was developed primarily for PC.
Why exactly would the 2 weapon only system have been dropped? i don't play many FPS on the PC but it seems like it makes sense and is more realistic, though i suppose realism isn't a huge part of the halo series, regardless is it that uncommon of a aspect in PC FPS's?
 

rockingnic

New member
May 6, 2009
1,470
0
0
I think it wouldn't fit as a PC game because it's made for a console and who knows how it would have been like if on PC. I don't like carrying every weapon in the game anyways.
 

Onyx Oblivion

Borderlands Addict. Again.
Sep 9, 2008
17,032
0
0
Hmm...I'd likely hate it. It'd have likely stuck to the tradition of "find the keycard/lever/switch" and all that bullshit. Or still been linear, like Halflife 1.

Card key hunting has not aged well.
 

FactualSquirrel

New member
Dec 10, 2009
2,316
0
0
Well, I think it would be exactly the same.

Also, I doubt everyone would say it was crap, in fact, if the exact same game had been released for pc exclusively, I think it would be known very differently on the forums round here.
 

thenumberthirteen

Unlucky for some
Dec 19, 2007
4,794
0
0
What basis do you have to predict these changes? Did they include 2 weapon only simply for consoles? Why would the level design be fundimentaly different?
 

James Cassidy

New member
Dec 4, 2008
400
0
0
If the Halo game was made JUST for the PC it would be no different than it is now. The story would stay the same.

I don't know why PC fanboys say this crap.
THE STORY HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH WHAT SYSTEM IT IS ON. THE STORY WOULD REMAIN THE SAME REGARDLESS IF IT WAS ON THE PC OR CONSOLE.

Did gamers get stupid all of a sudden? Really? Are guys really THAT stupid to believe that the story would be so much better if it was just PC game?

The story is the first thing to be written. They don't just say "Alright we are going to make a game and develop the story as they go." They may improve the story, but the don't just write it as they go.

The graphics might have improved a bit, maybe. The gameplay would be different yes, but the story is written even before the game is in development. I mean really? Do you know how stupid this sounds? "The story would be better if it was developed for the PC." That is by far the dumbest statement I have ever heard.

Of course look who I am talking to...apparently people are confusing "weather" with "whether." I know this is the internet, but it is no excuse to be THAT stupid.

I don't even care if you like Halo or hate it.
 

Plurralbles

New member
Jan 12, 2010
4,611
0
0
Uh... um... The pC only didn't get Halo 3.

So yeah, I get what you're trying to get at but frankly, it was on PC so... uh... I'm kind of not giving a crap about what kind of point you're making

Frankly I believe it would be the same damn game. I mean, you develop a game using a PC, probably did the original play test(creating the fundementals) with a mouse and so on. It would have been teh exact same.