Not a bad theory, but laying it on a little thick. No Russian was the singular place in the game that used innovative, nuanced storytelling, and while over the top works for the run and gun action, it would come across as saccharine if something so over the top is used for emotional impact. Tone it down and you might have something. Something to re-enforce the fact that what your doing in the level is a necessary evil. Perhaps if shooting certain civilians give you a brief flash of a picture of an implied friend or family member with similar features. That would probably be enough, but you could go farther. Perhaps if you rack up too many flashbacks, you have a moment of guilt, and Makarov forces you to take point and makes sure that you kill people, and if you don't kill anyone, you blow your cover and fail the mission. It would make it so the gameplay itself has emotional impact, and give a sense of feedback for the choices you make.
dragonslayer32 said:
why are ther no kids in the airport? not that i want to kill them but its just a bit wierd having all adults.
I know that in some places, even for a mature game, killing kids is a serious no no, sometimes outright banned.
Time Warp said:
Gee, a bunch of people speaking English with obvious accents shoot up a Russian airport!
IT MUST BE THEM DURN AMERICANS! GIT ME MY SWORD AND CHAAAARGE!
Yeah, right. Because a terrorist group pretending to be something else is such an impossible scenario, ever. Because there's no such thing as investigation, and because the country the terrorists claimed to represent are not going to do their best to clear their name and catch the damn bastards, no way.
As you can see, I do absolutely agree that the story of the game is absolutely awful... And not to speak of idiotic weapon choices for multiplayer... Hell, what's good about it, again?
You're certainly welcome to your opinion on games, but you're inventing flaws where there are none. The scenario is pretty wild and cinematic (That is, of course, Modern Warfare's bag), but it's not THAT unreasonable.
First, you said that they had obvious Russian accents. Of course, you could very well avoid that if people spoke...ahem..."No Russian" while they were there. If only, say, the name of the level and the first thing they said at the beginning of the level indicated that they planned on not speaking and giving away their nationality...
Secondly, sure, I would not be surprised if there was an investigation. Authorities would come and find a lot of dead people, and not a lot in terms of first hand witnesses. Naturally, you would assume that with all the bullets flying, that SOMEONE from the attacking side would be taken down. That 1 person happens to be an American with military training, willingly working with a group of other professional soldiers, with hard to track down foreign guns, and a bit of evidence showing that American Special Forces are following this operation closely, and making sure the Russians don't know about it. There's already some tension between the countries, and America isn't exactly universally loved for its foreign policy these days. Let's say that certain Americans get the chance to explain themselves. "Oh no, this is a complete misunderstanding...we didn't shoot up your Airport. We just put one of our agents into a terrorist group, and let him watch the terrorist group shoot up hundreds of your civilians and do nothing. Well not nothing, he shot up some of your civilians, but it probably would have happened anyways. Unless we prevented it. Which we could have. Or you could have, if we told you. But we didn't. Because we wanted to earn this terrorists trust by helping him out. Come on, after doing all that, why WOULDN'T you trust us?". Add onto the fact that we don't know what else Makarov did to make it look like an American operation, with all of his vast resources and connections, and its a very easy lie to sell. And lastly, it took little more then repetition to convince the American people that Iraq caused 9/11, and that they had WMDs. And look how America responded. Makarov did a much more thorough job of pinning blame on America. I'm sure that this plan, in all likelihood, wouldn't be that easy in reality, but it uses nothing more then acceptable breaks from reality. It's certainly a hell of a lot more realistic then even the best of James Bond villains.