Justify Yourself!

Recommended Videos

DarkenedWolfEye

New member
Jan 4, 2010
214
0
0
Hey, I like Red Dwarf too!
I am an intelligent student. I help out the people who sit next to me in Math. I plan to be a creative writer, become fluent in Latin and possibly German, and I'm also taking computer studies. I want to keep my options open, so that I'm not a starving storyteller.
Also, I can play the guitar.
Eat THAT, Inquisitor!
 

rutger5000

New member
Oct 19, 2010
1,052
0
0
thethingthatlurks said:
I laugh at your pitiful attempt to force me to justify an act over which I have no control. Who is this creature that dares to ask me to justify my existence? I am, I have been, and I will be. Why came to be was beyond my control, though what I make of my life shall not be constrained by pitiful minds, pitiful creatures, and pitiful challenges. But more to the point, who are you to ask me? Justify that act! How are you superior to me? Are you the immortal creator of all that is? No? Well, have you overcome the limitations of our species, have you transcended what it means to be human? No? Aw, such a shame...
/objectivist/nihilist reply
I'm with that guy.
Otherwise I would say that I'm smarter then that robot and rather a nice person. I think I would delete the robot.
 

rutger5000

New member
Oct 19, 2010
1,052
0
0
Mr.Mattress said:
I will be the next Teddy Roosevelt of America! Isn't that what you'd want?
Why Teddy? Franklin was much better. Seriously I think that was America's finest hour.
 

Aiden_the-Joker1

New member
Apr 21, 2010
436
0
0
Come on, who else is going to take over the world with SCIENCE!? Failing that I would reprogram the robot to do MY bidding muhahahahahahaha.
 

rutger5000

New member
Oct 19, 2010
1,052
0
0
Red Right Hand said:
Flamehero1 said:
Red Right Hand said:
I'll answer that question with another one.

Why do I not deserve life?
Because you are wasting it.
Oh? And who defines wasting it? You? Me?

The point is that nobody chooses to be born, so why is there this obligation that we have to live a meaningful life?

Note: I'm not saying that I want to waste my life because that would simply be untrue but rather why can't we have the choice?

Note 2: I know i'm reading far to much into the question but i've been doing a lot of philosophy of late and can't really help it.
You're partly right. No-one is obligated to live a meaningful life, but just like all creatures we must know our place in nature. Humans (except from some crazy hippies) simply can't do that. That however is something we have to justify.
 

heptonian

New member
Nov 23, 2009
7
0
0
Flamehero1 said:
A little backstory on this first. After watching an old British Sci-fi comdedy called Red Dwarf, there is one episode ...
Woo! Red Dwarf! I commend your good taste, fine education, and fashion sense.

Flamehero1 said:
Anyway this bring me to my question. Members of the Escapist, justify your existence. Why do you deserve life?
An interesting question! It's a question that in many ways says as much about the views of the person asking the question as it does the person answering it.

Given the situation presented I'd say that the question presupposes that life (assumed to be the subject's individual Human here on Earth) is a "good thing" (tm) ... something the person being judged would like to have and continue having. The assumption(s) that life is good (or even always, often, or mostly good ... or that even when the unique mix of good and bad of one's life isn't particularly favorable life can still somehow be made good by individual effort and perseverance ...) remain assumptions. Assumptions I personally believe to be as healthy and productive as it is illusory! Cling to those illusions! Embrace them! Believe them true and me wrong! They are good for you.

If put into this situation I believe my own response to the robot would be this: "I have done nothing to 'deserve' my life. I didn't ask for it. I didn't want it. I have no memory of being consulted before being brought into it against my will. If I had been consulted, and my memory of such pre-incarnation events is faulty, I heartily admit my mistake in agreeing to this life. While I've tried to make the best of my life - both by refraining from harming others, or myself, as much as I can and by striving to be a positive influence, where possible, in the lives of others - this has not always been easy. So if I am to be removed, I shall thank you, ser robot, kindly not to inflict my life on a currently non-existent someone who has committed no crime deserving of that punishment. Or, if such a substitution is entirely unavoidable, please restore the sense of personal belief in the fundamental goodness of being alive to that new me."
 

FalloutJack

Bah weep grah nah neep ninny bom
Nov 20, 2008
15,489
0
0
Flamehero1 said:
A little backstory on this first. After watching an old British Sci-fi comdedy called Red Dwarf, there is one episode where a robot makes people justify their existence and if they can't deletes them from time and space and replaces them with another life, one of the sperms that didn't make it to the egg(so to speak).

Anyway this bring me to my question. Members of the Escapist, justify your existence. Why do you deserve life?

EDIT: The robot takes on the persona of the accused, therefor you are judged by yourself. The robot also believes in no god or afterlife.
I remember that bit. "Oh smeg, indeed."

HIM: Well?

ME: You have to ask?

HIM: Yes, I do.

ME: Because you know an argument between us, that is 'me and me', will take hours.

HIM: Time has no meaning during this discussion.

ME: Convenient, but I can simplify this.

HIM: I hope so, because you tend to rant on a bit.

ME: Exactly. Besides, I've seen the episode, so I've given this some thought. The fact is that I am the center of my existence and it tends to work for me.

HIM: I forgot you'd taken Existentialism back then. So, you're basically saying that because things have gone your way, your current existence must be where it should be?

ME: You don't try to fix what isn't broken. And you know me, I'm an ungodly hell towards anyone or any THING that tries to disrupt my life. You're getting off easy because I figured arguing with myself still means that I'm right.

HIM: You know, I was suppose to take a contary position here.

ME: Yes, but if you're being me, you don't even believe I could be wrong about this. The you that's the time-traveling android chose this way of life, as did I. If a personal choice in lifestyle is wrong, then we'd both be wrong. You do what you feel must be done, and I feel that I am living well and deserving it.

HIM: *Sigh* Never argue with asshole who's taken philosophy courses. You may go.
 

BENZOOKA

This is the most wittiest title
Oct 26, 2009
3,920
0
0
Sassafrass said:
Because I could cure a fatal disease one day.

Do you really wanna take that chance? Do you really want to get rid of the only guy who might be able to get rid off boneitis?! WELL?! DO YOU?!
I'm quite sure you have interrobang syndrome. You should go have that checked.

OT: I don't deserve it, but I'm still holding on to it because I like it when I accidentally gain something.
 

PurplePlatypus

Duel shield wielder
Jul 8, 2010
592
0
0
There?s no reason to justify myself, I?m simply here.
Life, existence, it?s not a prize. It?s more something we deal with and try to make the best of, if we can. Some of more luck with that than others.
 

sansamour14

New member
Jul 16, 2010
299
0
0
i can make a pretty bad-ass turkey ham tomato and lettuce sandwich. and if i was gone would you really want to live in such a world absent of me and my sandwich greatness. No? i though so.
 

Sneeze

New member
Dec 4, 2010
415
0
0
Hmmmm... Without my contributions and custom many games companies, breweries and bar staff would be out of work? Maybe?
 

KiKiweaky

New member
Aug 29, 2008
972
0
0
I reckon I'd be screwed, well I've done well in my college exams but do I know much about information technology support? Honest ansewer no I dont think I do, I still have a shitload of training before me :/
 

Zaverexus

New member
Jul 5, 2010
934
0
0
Because I am an intelligent person with a variety of skills and the ability to learn quickly, giving potential for a number of services to society.
I aim to teach, and can therefor help other humans better themselves and live "justifiable" existences
 

Voxgizer

New member
Jan 12, 2011
255
0
0
HankMan said:
http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9tGO79BtWUI/0.jpg
"I have given pleasure to the world because I have such a beautiful ass."
I second this. Where would you guys be without our beautiful asses? Yea, that's right, you'd be sad and lonely!