Caliban1972 said:
Jabberwock xeno said:
PaulH said:
Jabberwock xeno said:
Ouch.
Not for the bullied kid, but for the bully.
As much as he deserves to get hit back, he didn't deeserve to be fucking pile driven into concert, he could have been killed.
Thowrn into the wall, maybe, but not headfirst into the sidewalk.
He wasn't thrown headfirst in the concrete.... His left leg and arm connected with the ground before his head. Bah ... I've seen spear tackles worse than this.
Casey just threw the lad ... it would have hurt, and sure might have broken an arm or leg, but I think it's a bit sensationalist to say 'he could have been killed'.
Maybe, but do you know how hard it is to accuratly control a entire person so that a partgilar part of their body does not hit the ground first?
The fact of the matter is, he COULD have been seriously injured. Did he desrve to be beat up? maybe, but not a freaking concusiion.
Yes, the bully would have made sure to stop hitting Casey before he injured him, so we should be concerned about what injuries the bully COULD have received, rather than what actually happened.
Brilliant thinking there.
News flash: Attacking some one bigger than you (or anyone at all really) could end up with you being seriously injured.
So not only is this kid a bully, but stupid as well. He initiated the violence, gets to deal with the consequences of his actions. I have not one ounce of sympathy for any injuries he "might have" received.
I'm slightly concerned about what actually happened in the real world, the world where Casey was bullied and abused constantly until he stood up for himself, stopped the attack, and walked away once his attacker was no longer a threat. Some fictional injury that his attacker didn't actually receive? Meaningless.
Based on how casey maneged himself, to me it seemed he could have easily just punched back, slammed him into a wall, or whatever.
Hell, he didn't even look bother when he got hit.
Maybe i'm just playing devils advocdate, but to me, what he did seemed unessacrly forecful.
Legally, for self defense, you are allowd an apporate response of equal force. You can't shoot somoen in the head for egging your house, or chase after someone who puched you and ran off, then stalk them to their house and kill the attacker.
Here, casey seemed to go beyond "equal force".
EDIT:
Okay, after re-reading your post, I get what ytou are saying.
he didn't get his head cracked open, or his neck broken, so there's no use argueing over what "may" have happened, right?
I agree with you there, i'm just saying that that's not the best way to handle this situation, and if someone who is being buiiled were to wacth this and try the same thing, they COULD end up killing someone.