epsilon246 said:
There are plenty of superfluous letters in words.
Watch.
Colour.
Color.
Both mean exactly the same thing, no? You read the same meaning from both, correct? The U was not necessary to convey the meaning, because the word is just as valid without as it is with. You say we see the shape of every word, and that is true. But if one is taught that Colour is spelt Color, then it means Color to that reader. Adding the U in this case seems superfluous from that reader's viewpoint, just as we would consider Magick to be a strange spelling of Magic. There is no universal "right" spelling of a word, only the most commonly accepted spelling, which varies across time and space.
Who is the "us" you refer to? Some guys who happened to be born and brought up in the UK? Do Americans somehow have a less profound link to their mother tongue by virtue of being geographically isolated from its place of origin? They grew up with it, they learnt it and lived it and spoke it and breathed it just as much as anyone from the UK did. The fact that their spelling has evolved slightly differently - and you can't say the spelling differences are anything but slight, not when you compare Modern English to Old or even Middle English (hint: Shakespearean English is by no means Middle English. Try Chaucer.), does not diminish the fact that it is no less, or more, their language than it is yours. For that matter, how can any body, be that body an individual, an organisation or a nation, hold exclusive rights to something as ubiquitous - and as arbitrary - as a language?
On a second note, I've not once seen Governour spelt with a U outside of direct references to its old spelling.
Incidentally, the American dropping of letters was anything but pointless. The movement had a very definite goal: standardised, phonetic spelling of English, for ease of use. You can argue that it was unnecessary (I certainly would, considering that phonetic spelling in a language with accents as diverse as English is just begging for disaster), but to call it pointless is to show profound ignorance of the movement, its vision and its goals.
I agree that Americans forcing their spelling on others is annoying, but I don't think that is actually relevant to this discussion, considering that you're doing the exact same thing. The justifications used are different (tradition/cultural elitism rather than simplicity/cultural elitism), but the end result is the same, and no less obnoxious.