Minecraft is better than any game/series ever?

Recommended Videos

Romblen

New member
Oct 10, 2009
871
0
0
For the most part, we are not voting on "Best developer ever" We are voting on "Best developer this year."

I imagine a year or two from now after the Minecraft craze has dulled somewhat, Mojang won't get close to winning.
 

Small Waves

New member
Nov 14, 2009
596
0
0
Gralian said:
I see, and is it unrealistic to expect episodic content to be released with any slight degree of frequency? They never said "we dropped the episodes in favour of a full blown sequel in the next five years". We are still waiting on episode 3 here, not half life 3. Episodic content should not take this long.
ToMAYto, toMAHto. He referred to HF2 ep. 1-2 as HL3 interchangeably. They can put out an announcement about how Half-Life is done if they damn well pleased. Unless Gabe has a gun put to his head, he is under no obligation to release installments every X years, or even release them at all.

I would have thought it was important to actually listen to fans in order to give them what they want, especially if they are in the millions. I thought that was considered good business management. Ignoring them and following your own designs seems a little egotistical and questionable in my humble opinion.
People are going to buy any old thing Valve throws out by the millions, whether it's immaculate or shit. They have plenty sources of income.
 

mexicola

New member
Feb 10, 2010
924
0
0
/facepalm

Just stop whining OP. I voted for Valve and now I'm voting for Bioware and they seem like they are about to be swept away but so what? It's just a insignificant popularity contest with no pretense of objectivity (if objectivity can even go anywhere near discussions about what game is better). This year it is Mojang, last year it was Zynga and year before that it was Turbine - people always throw hissy fits when their pet developer loses but it but it only serves to make them look ridiculous to an outside viewer.
 

Imat

New member
Feb 21, 2009
519
0
0
Enslave_All_Elves said:
Well I did make a skull mountain with lava pouring out of its face holes. I did build canals for farms and transport. I did build water elevators to my floating sky fortress (to the ladders anyways). I did blow up cows while dressed as Frank Castle. Speaking of which I should make a floating lava spewing skull fortres... as Frank Castle. I am free to build whatever I want instead of being merely satisfied with a game environment.

Is it fun? Only if you don't expect entertainment forced into your brain with a drill.

Is it the best game evarrrr? NO.

Are they good developers? Hell yeah. I pity the future of games if they keep striving to emulate the moronic movie industry. At least Mojang did something original and provided good support for players. Bashing them would be like complaining about a kickass employee at work. Hell, some companies don't even beta test before they shovel glitchy bug infested turds on the shelf so fans can spend a few weeks doing their jobs for them. I refuse to pick bugs out your poo that I paid for.
You had to pay for Minecraft's Beta...And many companies don't Beta test because they have hundred man teams which simply test the game for hours on end. Alpha testing is important, and no company would release a game without any testing. The problem is the variety of systems in existence and the complexity of the programs: Catching a bug that happens every single time you do a series of common events is simple. Catching a bug which never appears in the same place twice, or comes about from an incredibly specific and ultimately improbable series of events is extremely difficult. The reason many games seem to be bug ridden nowadays is a combination of several factors: Devs trying to push out more games in shorter time-frames, much more complex coding, the sheer number of players playing the game and reporting the bugs, and the lack of players reporting a lack of bugs. Very few people are going to post in forums telling folks they never encountered a bug. It would also be impossible for a dev to hire enough folks to test their product as thoroughly as a Beta would. Betas bring their own problems, however.

Kinda digressed there, but you get the point...Not even sure why I was making that point, mostly just defending the devs I guess.

For the record, Minecraft isn't really all that original...But people enjoy it, so I'm not gonna argue with the votes.
 

Plurralbles

New member
Jan 12, 2010
4,611
0
0
eh, people only value what they are playing at the moment, but a little recognition of a successful indie dev kinda' is awesome. THough I of course wish my pick, Blizzard, won.
 

dmase

New member
Mar 12, 2009
2,117
0
0
Ugh there are a lot of people not from here voting minecraft. Yeah mojang deserves a lot of respect an indie developer with only a few employees makes that large of an impact on the market. Not to mention the game apparently appeals a LOT to the old farts. Of course there are a lot of good indie developers that succeed to an extent but units sold I don't think many of them could beat mojang.
 

Trolldor

New member
Jan 20, 2011
1,849
0
0
Romblen said:
For the most part, we are not voting on "Best developer ever" We are voting on "Best developer this year."

I imagine a year or two from now after the Minecraft craze has dulled somewhat, Mojang won't get close to winning.
Mojang aren't the best developer this year. Their game was released in 2009. Their only game. It doesn't count for this year at all. Or last year.
 

DustyDrB

Made of ticky tacky
Jan 19, 2010
8,365
3
43
I just was surprised (and maybe a little perturbed for them heavily [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/global/tournaments/mybracket/5/DustyDrB] screwing up my bracket) because I hadn't been hearing much about Minecraft on this site for months. I'm not trying to put the game down by saying this, but Mojang was just an afterthought when I filled out my bracket. I knew the game was somewhat popular, but I didn't think it was that popular here.

Oh well. I don't really need a new laptop...
 

Snotnarok

New member
Nov 17, 2008
6,310
0
0
I'm tired of these threads where people get so upset that something is popular or more popular than what they like.

This just happened to me when I called Darksiders "Darksiders: Zelda Evolved" I got "You can't be serious Zelda is better" and I disagree, I personally hate Zelda. I've played most of them and I've yet to like one to play through.

But how dare I find a game more appealing than Zelda or Mario! It's an opinion.
 

thelonewolf266

New member
Nov 18, 2010
708
0
0
Can we please stop with these threads Mojang getting so far doesn't mean its better and even the people that voted for it may not think its better.The march mayhem thing is just a glorified poll to show which game is most popular at this exact moment in time that doesn't mean its better than valve or Bioware please stop acting like its the end of the world.
 

Trolldor

New member
Jan 20, 2011
1,849
0
0
Snotnarok said:
I'm tired of these threads where people get so upset that something is popular or more popular than what they like.

This just happened to me when I called Darksiders "Darksiders: Zelda Evolved" I got "You can't be serious Zelda is better" and I disagree, I personally hate Zelda. I've played most of them and I've yet to like one to play through.

But how dare I find a game more appealing than Zelda or Mario! It's an opinion.
There's a difference between liking a game more and considering Mojang the best developer ever for a single game released in 2009.
 

C.S.Strowbridge

New member
Jul 22, 2010
330
0
0
Eri said:
Apparently that's what most people here seem to think if the voting is any indication.

Minecraft is better than Mario
Yes. It's better than any Mario game of the past few years.

Eri said:
Yes.

Eri said:
Mass Effect
Mass Effect came out in 2007 and was ME2 that much better?

Eri said:
Dragon Age
2009. The sequel is considered a step down.

Eri said:
Half Life, Portal, Left 4 Dead, Fallout 3/NV, Resident Evil, Team Fortress, Elder Scrolls, Borderlands, The witcher, and oh god I could just go on and on.
So could I.


Eri said:
Sure you could almost apply this to any dev that's winning or won March Mayhem, but the point here is that they had games.
No. They had sequels. (Except for Borderlands.)

Minecraft is new.

I admit, I think Blizzard deserves to win, even though their biggest game they made last year was an expansion. However, they also practically own a genre to themselves. That's huge.

Given their competition, Mojang deserved to be in the top four.
 

Naeberius

New member
Aug 13, 2008
95
0
0
Oh god no. Ive been playing minecraft since it was on vinyl (Joke), Its fun but not as fun as Mass Effect or Gears of War. It is certainly new and innovative, but not great as triple A titles.
 

Sovreign

New member
Apr 25, 2009
74
0
0
I wouldn't say the best game ever, better than any other game, but what it has going for it and why it's so popular, is because of it's originality and it appeals to everyone's imagination and it's replayability is beyond any other game that comes to mind.
 

Romblen

New member
Oct 10, 2009
871
0
0
Trolldor said:
Romblen said:
For the most part, we are not voting on "Best developer ever" We are voting on "Best developer this year."

I imagine a year or two from now after the Minecraft craze has dulled somewhat, Mojang won't get close to winning.
Mojang aren't the best developer this year. Their game was released in 2009. Their only game. It doesn't count for this year at all. Or last year.
That is true, but Minecraft is at what I'm guessing to be the height of its popularity. Not to mention it gets a lot of updates. My point is that Mojang is winning to due the popularity of its recent game. Bioware on the other hand has not realeased anything that is as popular as it is now. For the record, I love both developers, I can just see why Mojang is winning right now.
 

Sinisterair

New member
Oct 15, 2008
353
0
0
Gralian said:
March Mayhem is more of an innovation award than anything else. People are fickle and always cry foul when something is labeled as generic - oh look a military FPS, Call of Duty clone. Chest high walls? Gears of War clone. Third person combat? God of War clone. Platformer? Mario clone. Everything is a clone of something else.

But not Minecraft. It's a clone of nothing (and don't say Infiniminer, it was never completed and abandoned. Minecraft isn't complete, but it's not going to be abandoned is it?) and the way it succeeded purely through word of mouth is nothing short of phenomenal when you look at all the money put into heavy ad campaigns that feel cheap and fall flat on their face. Looking at you, EA. It's not hard to see why people love Mojang.
Just because the game isn't going to be abandoned doesn't mean its not a clone You cant compare games based on development stages........if that were the case then literally everything is a clone like you said, in some aspects it takes a lot from Infiniminer.....so you could consider it a clone because most things are the same......the only differences being Infiniminer being team based most of the game, and in Minecraft its hey! go do what ever you want........In all fairness the game is great, original and its really fun. But This March Madness is about the Best Delveloper.......And in that regard Valve has a great history of games and catering to there fan base. Of course this is my opinion