OuroborosChoked said:Better examples might be more helpful.Marbas said:No, but you ARE NOT LISTENING. It takes talent and practice to make good Noise. That's why the comparison is moot.Let me ask you this, then: does it take talent to perform 4'33?
Reposted from edit as it's still relevant:
People who listen to the genre regularly are capable of distinguishing between songs and artists. It's quite easy to distinguish between say, a Noise Track and a crowded street. Noise, the genre I'm talking about, is not accidental art. Sure, it can be improvised, and several artists like C Spencer Yeh love improvised performances, but it can also be carefully composed and tailored. Maybe you'd be more comfortable if I called it Industrial?
In my experience, Noise is represented by groups like: Negativland, Nurse With Wound, Coil, Pancreatic Aardvarks, John Zorn, Einstürzende Neubauten, Current 93, NON, Throbbing Gristle, and Psychic TV. The only really "industrial" of those groups might be Einstürzende Neubauten or Nurse With Wound, and that's only on some tracks. Your understanding of noise is different maybe?
Dark Ambient... like Necrophorus?Marbas said:Noise and Industrial. Very.
Nurse With Wound, Throbbing Gristle, NON, Early Current 93 and Throbbing Gristle are all have examples of Noise. But they're also definitely all Industrial groups. Throbbing Gristle is generally considered the poster child for Industrial Music. Noise and Industrial are very closely intertwined. The modern European Noise subculture grew out of Industrial and Japanese Noise which was heavily influenced by Industrial. One of the biggest contributors being Whitehouse. So yes, to call it Industrial is probably a bit of a misnomer, but it's what it grew out of, so I thought I could point out that what I'm talking about didn't spring out John Cage's ass.
Modern Noise groups that I'm familiar with are bands like Prurient, Xome, Wolf Eyes, Brighter Death Now, Slogun, Double Leopards, Emeralds, Merzbow(duh), Sick Llama, Robedoor, Fennesz, Borbetomagus, I could go on forever really. Noise is also strongly intertwined with Dark Ambient in strange and inexplicable way.
Also, not all Noise is harsh, some is made out of soft fuzzy drones. Emeralds, Double Leopards, and Tusco Terror are good examples of this.OuroborosChoked said:Dark Ambient... like Necrophorus?Marbas said:Noise and Industrial. Very.
Nurse With Wound, Throbbing Gristle, NON, Early Current 93 and Throbbing Gristle are all have examples of Noise. But they're also definitely all Industrial groups. Throbbing Gristle is generally considered the poster child for Industrial Music. Noise and Industrial are very closely intertwined. The modern European Noise subculture grew out of Industrial and Japanese Noise which was heavily influenced by Industrial. One of the biggest contributors being Whitehouse. So yes, to call it Industrial is probably a bit of a misnomer, but it's what it grew out of, so I thought I could point out that what I'm talking about didn't spring out John Cage's ass.
Modern Noise groups that I'm familiar with are bands like Prurient, Xome, Wolf Eyes, Brighter Death Now, Slogun, Double Leopards, Emeralds, Merzbow(duh), Sick Llama, Robedoor, Fennesz, Borbetomagus, I could go on forever really. Noise is also strongly intertwined with Dark Ambient in strange and inexplicable way.
You listen to the radio and believe it stands for modern music? Someone has a lot to learn.JRCB said:Okay, I know we're living in messed up times right now, but what's up with music? Have you noticed how we have moved away from some genres only to replace them with dance, rap, pop, or any mix of them? What happened to good music? Modern music doesn't have that "feel" when I listen to it. The moment any Lady Gaga or Jonas brothers or any form of rap comes onto the radio, I immediately switch to another station. Older music, like Led Zepplin, or even some '90s music comes on, I turn up the volume. What happened?
Don't forget Boards of Canada. They effing rule.Marbas said:Also, not all Noise is harsh, some is made out of soft fuzzy drones. Emeralds, Double Leopards, and Tusco Terror are good examples of this.OuroborosChoked said:Dark Ambient... like Necrophorus?Marbas said:Noise and Industrial. Very.
Nurse With Wound, Throbbing Gristle, NON, Early Current 93 and Throbbing Gristle are all have examples of Noise. But they're also definitely all Industrial groups. Throbbing Gristle is generally considered the poster child for Industrial Music. Noise and Industrial are very closely intertwined. The modern European Noise subculture grew out of Industrial and Japanese Noise which was heavily influenced by Industrial. One of the biggest contributors being Whitehouse. So yes, to call it Industrial is probably a bit of a misnomer, but it's what it grew out of, so I thought I could point out that what I'm talking about didn't spring out John Cage's ass.
Modern Noise groups that I'm familiar with are bands like Prurient, Xome, Wolf Eyes, Brighter Death Now, Slogun, Double Leopards, Emeralds, Merzbow(duh), Sick Llama, Robedoor, Fennesz, Borbetomagus, I could go on forever really. Noise is also strongly intertwined with Dark Ambient in strange and inexplicable way.
The link mostly seems to be that fans of one type are fans of the other. The Helix Collective or whatever they're called now, Lustmord, Tereth, Atrium Carceri, Black Seas of Infinity, and probably Necrophorous but I've never listened to them, etc. A lot of people who are fans of one are fans of the other. Or they come from the Ambient Metal camp, however lots of people who like "Ambient Metal" also like Noise. There seems to be some cross pollination. Nyodene D and Solarkult are great examples of this.
To be honest I loved it, I know I'm not familiar with the genre at all, but it was different and from my point of view completely original. Have you ever heard of Mr. Bungle? They have that same kind of chaotic sound to them, especially on Disco Volante. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjjFl70CJEkMarbas said:Here is an artist I'm quite fond of. He is modern, and you're going to hate him. [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAw0-lx1gcU]
I completely disagree the internet opened up music, its now much easier to find bands that you would have never heard of otherwise.Bored Tomatoe said:The internet happened.
Actually I have heard of Mr. Bungle! He's damn good at what he does but I never really got into him. I would suggest you check out Prurient's album And Still, Wanting if you want to hear more. It's easy to find on blogs.To be honest I loved it, I know I'm not familiar with the genre at all, but it was different and from my point of view completely original. Have you ever heard of Mr. Bungle? They have that same kind of chaotic sound to them, especially on Disco Volante. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjjFl70CJEk
olaffub42 said:To be honest I loved it, I know I'm not familiar with the genre at all, but it was different and from my point of view completely original. Have you ever heard of Mr. Bungle? They have that same kind of chaotic sound to them, especially on Disco Volante. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjjFl70CJEkMarbas said:Here is an artist I'm quite fond of. He is modern, and you're going to hate him. [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAw0-lx1gcU]
Ah! you just haven't heard the good stuff. For just listening though I will admit that stuff like Boston and Pink Floyd is superior. But I like to party...Kriegsherr said:I beg to differsamsprinkle said:Techno pwns!