Hopeless Bastard said:
MelasZepheos said:
In the book, the comedian discovering the plan was an accident. In the movie, there was nothing for the comedian to accidentally discover.
The unreality of the squid, it's functionality, the island, the teleporter, and how everything would come together is what drove the comedian over the edge.
Except... in the movie, there was no island. There was no central staging point for Ozymandias' plan. There was just Manhattan and Ozy working on solving the energy crisis by duplicating manhattan's abilities. The only way the comedian could've known the plan is if ozy told him. Then why did he tell him? If ozy told the comedian, why did he wait to kill him?
Thus, gaping plot hole.
Quoted and paraphrased from the book:
'that wasn't what Blake found on the island. He found a collection of missing scientists, working upon a monstrous new life form. upon learning the creature's intended purpose, Blake's practiced cynicism cracked.'
Expressly stated in book that Blake did not know about the teleporter, just the plan to:
'Frighten governments into cooperation, I (ozy) would convince them that Earth faced imminent attack by beings from another world.'
So in the book, Blake discovers a group of scientists working on an unknown creature, somehow (this is never explained) learns what it's going to be used for (so a plot hole in the original novel) and gets upset because he understands it is an end to war. That part is also expressly stated, its only the goal of it which makes him upset, the rest of it he understands to be a practical joke, the largest ever conceived, which is stated to be professional envy.
Movie: Rorsarch and Nite Owl break into Ozy's penthouse, open up his computer with a ridiculously easy password, find all of his files on Manhatten, and the Pyramid Project, and though they don't know the full extent of the plan, they know Veidt's behind it, and they go to investigate.
Comedian is a sanctioned government official, so he would clearly be able to do all of this and discover Veidt's involvement, and Manhatten's role. So basically all that we have to accept is that the Comedian was able to draw a link between the energy work of Manhatten and Ozymandias, which he would also know about, and he's got the entire plot. The only plot hole is why Ozymandias was keeping all of this information in one room, on file.
So upon reflection, the plothole is in fact bigger in the book, and was largely plugged by the movie, since it doesn't rely upon the Comedian managing to spot, from several thousand miles up in the air, an island which he knows for a fact isn't on any maps, and then once he's found what would appear to be a bunch of special effects people for a movie, somehow managing to discover the extent of the plan. The book makes even less sense in retrospect.
I didn't think I would ever have to type that.