Most over rated game?

Recommended Videos

Malfy

New member
Jul 16, 2010
108
0
0
Most recently, the Gears of War series. They're not bad games, I just find it very generic for all of the praise that it gets.

And I'll probably be called a troll for this, but honestly, Super Mario Bros 3. It is a great, legendary game, but I can't believe how many times I've heard it be called the greatest game of all time from a significant amount of people. It's like the Holy Grail of gaming, and that actually makes it too overrated for its own good, that it can't possibly live up to that hype nowadays.
 

romanator0

New member
Jun 3, 2011
183
0
0
Dragon Age: Origins. Generic story, ugly art style, illusion of choice, too many intrusive cutscenes, extremely slow and padded, piss poor character customization.

Mass Effect 2. Rather anemic gun play, extremely linear, once again only an illusion of choice, combat consisting of gluing yourself to Wally McChest-high and taking potshots at enemies, no character customization what-so-ever, dull planet scanning for resources for weapon upgrades. I don't understand why people think ME2 was a good game or even a good RPG.
 

kouriichi

New member
Sep 5, 2010
2,415
0
0
Halo.
I really have to say Halo.
I liked halo. I really did.

But thats the problem. I "did" like halo. Halo 1 was amazing. Halo 2 was Halo 1 with dual wielding. Halo 3 was Halo 2 with crappy duel wielding, and equipment. And now Halo Reach is Halo 3 with re-textured weapons, no duel wielding, and the ability to turn invisible, and fly around with jetpacks at will.

Im glad it didnt change. But i hate that it never evolved. Its done the opposite. Its devolved into everyone having jet packs and infinite grenades. ((Grenades were my death 90% of the time. Seriously! Theres piles of grenades everywhere, and when someone dies, they drop more grenades!))

Halo was Properly rated. Now its become a Halo clone of itself. Except with more grenades.
 

EGtodd09

New member
Oct 20, 2010
260
0
0
Half Life anything. That whole series is absolute crap in my opinion. It's just so incredibly boring, quiet, bland and dull.
 

mikespoff

New member
Oct 29, 2009
758
0
0
Bioshock.

No, really. Despite all the hype (and an admittedly great intro sequence), the game did nothing for me. I've played it about two hours and I just can't convince myself to put any more time into it.
 

TheTim

New member
Jan 23, 2010
1,739
0
0
Valve Games minus Left 4 Dead 1 and 2, and portal

never found any of the other ones fun or enjoyable at all.
 

Gindil

New member
Nov 28, 2009
1,621
0
0
Dragon Age and/or Final Fantasy.

Dragon Age because even though the story may be good, EA messes it up with their business decision of dividing the fan base.

FF has 15 games. It ain't final. Nuf said.
 

AssassinFisH

New member
Jun 12, 2011
130
0
0
For me, it has to be Oblivion. I have no idea how anyone can stomach the terrible combat, annoying personalitys of npc's and lack of class distinction.
 

Ranylyn

New member
Nov 5, 2010
136
0
0
Final Fantasy 7.

No exceptions. Ever.

Ten years of forums have taught me this.

Post contains spoilers

Have you EVER spent ONE day online without having at least 20 people taking the fanboyism, concentrating it into phallic shapes, and trying to violate you in ways that not even your spouse violates you with them? Their life mission is to "enlighten the masses" and there's no possible way I could possibly dislike it so clearly I've never even played it, right? Wrong! Hell, I regret to admit I actually OWN a digital PSN copy when I mistakenly spent some time offline and decided to give it another chance.



It is, hands down, the worst FF game ever made, and the FF series as a whole is largely just average anyways! So, what's so bad about it? Let's begin.



The game opens with a spiky haired jerk taking less damage from an attack called "Machine Gun" than he does from a normal kick. He twirls his 5 foot logn slab of iron around in one hand, too. So then a black guy with a guy with a gun (how stereotype-dodging original /sarcasm) for an arm (how the hell does he load the ammo?) whose attack strength nis modified by strength joins. Yes. Guns modified by strength. KILL IT WITH FIRE.



Anyways, "Cloud" as the spiky haired jerk is known is overpowered as it becomed quickly apparent. Even with magic materia (lowers his HP and strength) equipped, he still ha more HP and attack than ANYONE ELSE IN THE CAST. Even without any Magic materia (increases magic and MP) he's ALMOST the best mage in the cast. By the endgame, he's hitting 5-7k damage while no one else can break 1.5-2k damage. He's severely unbalanced to the point of utter morinity. "Oh, just remove him from your party!" Yeah, problem. FF7 has the stupid flaw of not allowing him to be removed from the party, much like how FF8 couldn't see Squall removed. It's a terrible flaw because what if you don't even like them?



And as for Cloud as a person? He "had the physical build" he needed for a military group (called "SOLDIER" in all caps for NO APPARENT REASON) but lacked the mental strength. While this has the POTENTIAL to lead to a deep and immersive character, he falls more flat than his attempts to not get conveniently mind controlled by his nemesis (which conveniently is really only used to screw the party over once, when they could have all been killed in their sleep. Sephiroth is an utter failure of a villain in every way, shape, and form.) The rest of the cast? Get like 5 minutes in the spot light and that's it. They focus on the single worst character in every way, shape, and form.

And the fans just don;'t care, as made apparent by the two "love interests." Tifa is a slightly shy girl who's known Cloud since childhood. Her personality is somewhat girly and even innocent, with one exception being to infiltrate a brothel to get information (nothing happens.) On the flip side, "Aeris" whose real name is apparently "Aerith" and who has sparked fights worldwide, is bluntly forward and honest.The difference is how they dress. As a martial artist, Tifa wears a sleeveless shirt that shows her bellybutton, and shorts. Aerith wears a long dress. Because of this, fans clain Tifa to be the "slut" of the two. What? That's right, folks, the game is so bad, fans have to do this to derrive any enjoyment, and they're so blind, they don't care.

To give you an example of how badly designed this game is, let me use an early game example. The "Materia" command is locked until returning to the slums after the start of the game. Cloud has 2 spells, Barret has 0. Cloud only needs 1 and his physical attacks are stronger than Barret's. Finally, it gives you a heal materia right before the first boss AND YOU'RE NOT EVEN ALLOWED TO USE IT. That;s right. You cannot use a healing spell a game gives you right before a boss while you fight that boss, simply due to the fact that the menu category for it is still locked.

Honestly, the whole thing degrades into "omg big swords cloud and sephiroth fangasm" and quite frankly, I blame this for SO MUCH. Too many games have absolutely nothing outside of hype and flash, and FF7 was the game to start that trend ofm failure.

If you're a Final fantasy 7 fan, fine. Hell, maybe we could even get along. But for the love of god, learn to contain your fangasm ssince quite honestly, your game is the worst RPG I've ever played, and I've played over 100 of them!
 

Stammer

New member
Apr 16, 2008
1,726
0
0
World of Warcrap.

It's definitely the Wii of MMORPG's. It's absolute garbage, but everyone seems to play it anyway. And not only that but all of its competition seems to just copy it because of its success.

In fact, I think Blizzard in general is overrated. It's one of those companies that just needs to come out with one game every ten years, and even though it's a piece of crap all of their fans hop on the bandwagon and consider it the greatest thing ever.
 

thom_cat_

New member
Nov 30, 2008
1,286
0
0
ZiggyE said:
Portal. Or any Valve game in general. And Valve themselves. Valve fanboys are horrible.
I tend to find the people who bash VALVe for the fact that they are VALVe worse.
Just the two some people say are the most overrated:
Portal, fantastic dialogue, new gameplay, great learning curve and pacing.
Half-life 2, varying level design, amazing tech (facial animation still looks fairly good) - first proper physics- etc, engaging storyline and characters, great pacing.
The only negative I'd give HL2 is that the weapons and fighting in general is very bland.
Good thing they put in the gravity gun to spice it up a bit...

I'd have to say halo. Coming from a level design background this game pisses me off so much.
I mean they have good base design, but they suffer from a shocking amount of repetition. Painful amounts of it.