AgentNein said:
I think you're missing the point. These really are comments based simply on the character design, which is boring as shit, taken from the three or four character design archetypes for male leads flying around these days. No one's saying Fisher came first, just that he's probably the most recognizable of this particular design right now. I'm more than familiar with Max Payne, and I was excited at the prospect of playing an older Payne that gives us maybe something new as far as main character designs. What can I say? I'm sick of playing young-to-middle aged white guys with short hair lean bodies and just enough stubble.
To be fair that was the character design to begin with. The beer belly baldy in a wife beater was a bit of a departure. Do I wish there was more variety in general? Yes. Hell, I'd even take that version of Max Payne, but not with an established character.
If anything Sam Fisher's been made more generic from his original design. I swear he's gotten younger and more generic with every passing iteration of the franchise.
That said, there's a pretty heavy bent on this site that if something even looks vaguely like anything else, clearly it's a ripoff with no value whatsoever. Which is more than a little irritating, to say the least.