I'll have small points here and there I disagree with, but there has been one review I've felt he was flat out wrong on and that is Portal. I've never been a fan of the game, and really, I don't even feel its a game. It feels like a physics demo that they strapped a subpar story onto and then added a character that is HAL 9000 meets HK-47. Its too short, the gameplay isn't nearly as challenging as people like to say, and the story isn't inspired beyond random "wtf" moments. I had the flu when I played it, wasn't challenged in the least bit by it, and finished it in one day, with enough time to sleep for 12 hours in the day and play two other games for hours. It just feels like an extended demo, not a full length game.