Poll: Fallout New Vegas Factions

Recommended Videos

GrizzlerBorno

New member
Sep 2, 2010
2,295
0
0
Ultratwinkie said:
GrizzlerBorno said:
Ultratwinkie said:
....Do you really think his robots will last forever? Even if he did find a way to make more, unless he built a factory before the bombs it wont come in time. He may know how to build it, but the tribals sure as hell won't. The only people with tech like that are the NCR, and BOS. Those bots of his are battle drones, not construction workers. Then house has to deal with his own people. Those same tribals he "domesticated" will turn on him with big weaponry bought through gambling profits. That leaves New Vegas as New Reno Its false progress because he may dress up tribals in pretty clothes but they are still tribals. No better than putting a pig in a tuxedo.
You uhhh....realize that YOU'RE ancestors were once tribals too right? And so were mine. And everyone else's. You realize America (or any other country for that matter) didn't just pop out of the ground as a fully developed Democracy with intelligent, educated citizens right? Implying that Tribals can NEVER EVER become anything more than filth and "pigs" is Racist, Colonialist, and(most importantly) logically retarded, Asshole talk. Is that what you are? You should lay that out on the table right now.

I'm FROM the Third world you know? I suppose I can never help construct a factory, right? I can't ever be educated. If I put on a tux, I'll just be "a pig in a tuxedo". I should probably just go lie in the ditch I call a home, and DIE, right my powerful, educated American master? After all, my ancestors were just "tribals" whereas yours pooped out of the motherfucking ground as fully educated Democrats.....

Not cool, man. SO Not cool.
And where in history did they get led by a modern educated man? Where? They BUILT that progress with their HANDS. Never did it get handed to them. NCR built their reputation through centuries. They earned that, and were more mature. The legion? They popped up within 20 years, and haven't learned a single fucking thing. The same with House's tribals. Change only comes with time. Never in Human history was change an over night event. It took Rome centuries to build, as well as China. You can't built Rome in 20 years.
Dude, do you have Anterograde amnesia or something?

I'm not talking about 20 years, I'm talking about 800 years. Do I need me to make that bigger for you?

wait hang on......
[HEADING=2]800 Years[/HEADING]

The possibility of long term stability and progress is the ONE thing House can offer that no-one can. His "Plan" and "Security" and technology....all of that is just icing on the cake.
 

GrizzlerBorno

New member
Sep 2, 2010
2,295
0
0
Ultratwinkie said:
GrizzlerBorno said:
Ultratwinkie said:
And where in history did they get led by a modern educated man? Where? They BUILT that progress with their HANDS. Never did it get handed to them. NCR built their reputation through centuries. They earned that, and were more mature. The legion? They popped up within 20 years, and haven't learned a single fucking thing. The same with House's tribals. Change only comes with time. Never in Human history was change an over night event. It took Rome centuries to build, as well as China. You can't built Rome in 20 years.
Dude, do you have Anterograde amnesia or something?

I'm not talking about 20 years, I'm talking about 800 years. Do I need me to make that bigger for you?

wait hang on......
[HEADING=2]800 Years[/HEADING]

The possibility of long term stability and progress is the ONE thing House can offer that no-one can. His "Plan" and "Security" and technology....all of that is just icing on the cake.
Yet House is already mentally insane. He supports monarchy, and do you realize what we got when monarchy was around? Killings, genocide, repression. Repression is not progress. He just wants to keep his Vegas, not help humanity. Hell he out right lies to you to make you work for him and has no qualms with committing genocide. House has no security and no plan. Those tribes he recruited? They weren't even loyal. Hell some of them were in league with Caesar. His plan? He wouldn't be able to build a ship without help, or the parts. A damn pipe dream. Hell the only ones who HAVE the parts would be in either NCR or Legion territory. Hell, 800 years? Do you really believe his tube will survive that long? All it takes is ONE microbe and BAM House is dead.

House's questionable health and mental state.
No actual plan.
No actual security.
No actual ability to repair buildings.
No chance in hell.
Well atleast you proved you DO have anterograde amnesia when you kept bleating on about the issues I've Already addressed Several times (I never said House would live for 800 years).

No offense dude, but you're a fucking broken record, and this is NEVER going to go anywhere so...... run along now, with your mind-washed, Democracy worshiping, forgetful ways.

Stay true to your hypocritical and stubborn embrace of an imperfect system; and never even THINK to give any other governmental system a try Just becuase they might be Imperfect. We wouldn't want you to be open-minded now, would we?

Also, I realized that I never really agreed to your assertion that "House is mentally unstable" as that argument has no basis in canonical fact. This renders many of your arguments invalid. [broken record bleating incoming in 3...2....1....]
 

GrizzlerBorno

New member
Sep 2, 2010
2,295
0
0
Ultratwinkie said:
GrizzlerBorno said:
Ultratwinkie said:
GrizzlerBorno said:
Ultratwinkie said:
And where in history did they get led by a modern educated man? Where? They BUILT that progress with their HANDS. Never did it get handed to them. NCR built their reputation through centuries. They earned that, and were more mature. The legion? They popped up within 20 years, and haven't learned a single fucking thing. The same with House's tribals. Change only comes with time. Never in Human history was change an over night event. It took Rome centuries to build, as well as China. You can't built Rome in 20 years.
Dude, do you have Anterograde amnesia or something?

I'm not talking about 20 years, I'm talking about 800 years. Do I need me to make that bigger for you?

wait hang on......
[HEADING=2]800 Years[/HEADING]

The possibility of long term stability and progress is the ONE thing House can offer that no-one can. His "Plan" and "Security" and technology....all of that is just icing on the cake.
Yet House is already mentally insane. He supports monarchy, and do you realize what we got when monarchy was around? Killings, genocide, repression. Repression is not progress. He just wants to keep his Vegas, not help humanity. Hell he out right lies to you to make you work for him and has no qualms with committing genocide. House has no security and no plan. Those tribes he recruited? They weren't even loyal. Hell some of them were in league with Caesar. His plan? He wouldn't be able to build a ship without help, or the parts. A damn pipe dream. Hell the only ones who HAVE the parts would be in either NCR or Legion territory. Hell, 800 years? Do you really believe his tube will survive that long? All it takes is ONE microbe and BAM House is dead.

House's questionable health and mental state.
No actual plan.
No actual security.
No actual ability to repair buildings.
No chance in hell.
Well atleast you proved you DO have anterograde amnesia when you kept bleating on about the issues I've Already addressed Several times (I never said House would live for 800 years).

No offense dude, but you're a fucking broken record, and this is NEVER going to go anywhere so...... run along now, with your mind-washed, Democracy worshiping, forgetful ways.

Stay true to your hypocritical and stubborn embrace of an imperfect system; and never even THINK to give any other governmental system a try Just becuase they might be Imperfect. We wouldn't want you to be open-minded now, would we?

Also, I realized that I never really agreed to your assertion that "House is mentally unstable" as that argument has no basis in canonical fact. This renders many of your arguments invalid. [broken record bleating incoming in 3...2....1....]
and yet you repeat "well MY character..." when that isn't canon either. Is it? That is fan fiction, with no grounds in the story.
.....Okay......Now you're just trolling.
Playing the game in any way except the way YOU like it is "fan fiction"? Good to know XD
 

GrizzlerBorno

New member
Sep 2, 2010
2,295
0
0
Ultratwinkie said:
GrizzlerBorno said:
Ultratwinkie said:
GrizzlerBorno said:
Ultratwinkie said:
GrizzlerBorno said:
Ultratwinkie said:
And where in history did they get led by a modern educated man? Where? They BUILT that progress with their HANDS. Never did it get handed to them. NCR built their reputation through centuries. They earned that, and were more mature. The legion? They popped up within 20 years, and haven't learned a single fucking thing. The same with House's tribals. Change only comes with time. Never in Human history was change an over night event. It took Rome centuries to build, as well as China. You can't built Rome in 20 years.
Dude, do you have Anterograde amnesia or something?

I'm not talking about 20 years, I'm talking about 800 years. Do I need me to make that bigger for you?

wait hang on......
[HEADING=2]800 Years[/HEADING]

The possibility of long term stability and progress is the ONE thing House can offer that no-one can. His "Plan" and "Security" and technology....all of that is just icing on the cake.
Yet House is already mentally insane. He supports monarchy, and do you realize what we got when monarchy was around? Killings, genocide, repression. Repression is not progress. He just wants to keep his Vegas, not help humanity. Hell he out right lies to you to make you work for him and has no qualms with committing genocide. House has no security and no plan. Those tribes he recruited? They weren't even loyal. Hell some of them were in league with Caesar. His plan? He wouldn't be able to build a ship without help, or the parts. A damn pipe dream. Hell the only ones who HAVE the parts would be in either NCR or Legion territory. Hell, 800 years? Do you really believe his tube will survive that long? All it takes is ONE microbe and BAM House is dead.

House's questionable health and mental state.
No actual plan.
No actual security.
No actual ability to repair buildings.
No chance in hell.
Well atleast you proved you DO have anterograde amnesia when you kept bleating on about the issues I've Already addressed Several times (I never said House would live for 800 years).

No offense dude, but you're a fucking broken record, and this is NEVER going to go anywhere so...... run along now, with your mind-washed, Democracy worshiping, forgetful ways.

Stay true to your hypocritical and stubborn embrace of an imperfect system; and never even THINK to give any other governmental system a try Just becuase they might be Imperfect. We wouldn't want you to be open-minded now, would we?

Also, I realized that I never really agreed to your assertion that "House is mentally unstable" as that argument has no basis in canonical fact. This renders many of your arguments invalid. [broken record bleating incoming in 3...2....1....]
and yet you repeat "well MY character..." when that isn't canon either. Is it? That is fan fiction, with no grounds in the story.
.....Okay......Now you're just trolling.
Playing the game in any way except the way YOU like it is "fan fiction"? Good to know XD
No, just remember that by canon, there is no set courier. Saying "well my courier would" is no difference from saying "well my god would."

How is it like that? There is no set personality for God. The difference is the effects shown at the end of the game are known. We must base our arguments on the stuff we do know, not the stuff that could happen based on a persons view of the courier. My guess? NCR would win. It's too iconic to lose to a new comer like the Legion or House. Its the most fleshed out faction.
I will admit that the NCR is a good Allegory for America and democracy, in general.

Anyway, ^that up there is your opinion. Let's just agree to disagree and end this pointless bickering. I'm getting a bit bored.
 

Nedoras

New member
Jan 8, 2010
506
0
0
Each of the factions have their own flaws and benefits, but I can't find myself siding with any of them.

-The NCR is spreading itself too thin, and overall is just making foolish decisions. The corruption is also very obvious, and has a pretty flawed democracy. From what I can tell, the president has far too much power and there's no limit on how long a president can be in office. Plus I don't even think the people can vote on who becomes president. From what I've read, Tandi ruled the NCR for 52 years and was replaced after she died by the vice president. The former vice president was later kicked out of office and simply replaced by the current president. There was no mention of the people voting on it, it just happened. The only benefit I see with them is that they keep order, but they somewhat suck at it in the Mohave. That would change in time I guess.

-Caesar's Legion uses slaves and treats them quite cruelly from what I can tell. They're also pretty damn brutal towards their enemies and anyone who generally threatens them, they're not exactly the merciful type. The whole structure of the Legion relies of Caesar, seeing that the people see him as the son of Mars. They worship him and are utterly loyal to him, but his death may change the Legion forever. I think they may stick to the way he ran things for awhile out of respect for him, he literally is a god to them. But Caesar was a pretty damn intelligent dude, and when he dies his ideals go with him. It would be up to the Legion itself to either continue his vision out of respect to their beloved "Son of Mars" or just change into something else entirely. I guess the primary flaw with the Legion is that everything relies on one man, and it would be up to his Legion if they continue his ideals when he dies. The benefits I see with them is that they keep order really well, although pretty harshly. They protect their own and the areas they control extremely well, making Legion lands very safe to travel through.

-Mr House generally wants to rule forever and that's never a good thing. Eventually he will go completely insane and mentally unstable. Plus he's relying on an army of robots to do his bidding. Not only is this army limited, but it also has severe weaknesses such as pulse weaponry or limited ammo(I never understood how robots resupplied ammo unless there's special resupply stations for them or if a human "refills" them). He also seems to have an extremely high opinion of himself, and what with the impending insanity that could lead to a god complex which is never good. As for the benefits, well, I guess order and technological advancement? But even so it would all be under the rule of a conceited, insane, dictator for all eternity. I hardly see that as a benefit.

-As for an independent Mohave, it's really only postponing the inevitable. Eventually someone WILL take over. For example is you choose the independent ending and leave the Brotherhood alone, they leave the bunker and start spreading out taking over areas again. The only real benefit in an independent Mohave is that you're giving it a fresh start so to speak. But I don't think it would stay independent for long.

I got each of the endings at least once in the game, and didn't care too much for any of them. The NCR gave me some golden twig as a reward for destroying the Legion BY MYSELF. The Legion put me on one of their coins which I thought was pretty cool ^_^ Mr. House made me his right hand man and I lived a comfortable life. With an independent Mohave I was simply just there, nothing more nothing less.
 

hazabaza1

Want Skyrim. Want. Do want.
Nov 26, 2008
9,612
0
0
I was going for NCR, but then Yes-Man offered an army of invincible robots.
How could I say no?