Poll: Female babysitter charged for having sex with 14-year old boy.

Recommended Videos

fundayz

New member
Feb 22, 2010
488
0
0
I don't get how this is a hard case to solve:

1. Is the boy over the age of consent?
2. Did he clear-mindedly consent?
3. ???
4. Profit.
 

orangeban

New member
Nov 27, 2009
1,442
0
0
twiceworn said:
orangeban said:
twiceworn said:
Snip, this argument is getting lengthy.
sadly most people bow to social pressure (highschool) so leap at any chance to advance themselves and that is without even considering lust into it so socity puts men into the position that if a woman openly asked for sex ( a social no no for females) he would for so many resons say yes most of the time while there are some people who ignore such things and would act acording to their own jugments without social presure
Yes, but in a theoretical world where there were no social pressures (science conditions effectively), would most men say yes to a random attractive woman asking for sex? Purely from a biological standpoint we're are talking here.
it such a world it would be personal to that person, if he felt like having sex, if the thought he may catch somthing if he fears babys if he thinks about any of that at all if he trusts her. at this point it would simply be mating like animals but with the possibility of doing it for simple fun, in such a world it would be far less clear cut
Yes! Agreement! Oh thank the maker, what a glorius sight. Thank you sir, for together we have strode through strife and came out victorious! You know what, I'm gonna take my winnings and skedaddle, I think this is good enough for me. Thank you for this, this has been entertaining.
 

Sentox6

New member
Jun 30, 2008
686
0
0
I'm sure this has been expressed innumerable times in the last twenty pages, but reverse the genders and I suspect the sentiment would be a lot harsher on average.

Go to jail.
 

GLo Jones

Activate the Swagger
Feb 13, 2010
1,192
0
0
So a 14 year old boy managed to have a prolonged sexual relationship with his hot 20 year sitter?

 

twiceworn

New member
Sep 11, 2010
136
0
0
orangeban said:
twiceworn said:
orangeban said:
twiceworn said:
Snip, this argument is getting lengthy.
sadly most people bow to social pressure (highschool) so leap at any chance to advance themselves and that is without even considering lust into it so socity puts men into the position that if a woman openly asked for sex ( a social no no for females) he would for so many resons say yes most of the time while there are some people who ignore such things and would act acording to their own jugments without social presure
Yes, but in a theoretical world where there were no social pressures (science conditions effectively), would most men say yes to a random attractive woman asking for sex? Purely from a biological standpoint we're are talking here.
it such a world it would be personal to that person, if he felt like having sex, if the thought he may catch somthing if he fears babys if he thinks about any of that at all if he trusts her. at this point it would simply be mating like animals but with the possibility of doing it for simple fun, in such a world it would be far less clear cut
Yes! Agreement! Oh thank the maker, what a glorius sight. Thank you sir, for together we have strode through strife and came out victorious! You know what, I'm gonna take my winnings and skedaddle, I think this is good enough for me. Thank you for this, this has been entertaining.
Thank you, this was in depth clear and we emerge enlightned i salute you sir and good luck, may others benifit from what we have done today, i bid you farewell
 

Paragon Fury

The Loud Shadow
Jan 23, 2009
5,161
0
0
If thats a picture of her, I think the cops need to go find the 14 year old boy and give him his "Luckiest Little Boy in the World" medal.

/badsouthparkjoke

Considering that it seems they were consenting I can't blame for the sex too much.

However, I think that a semi-heavy fine, some community service and maybe a week or two stint in a jail/prison to see what life will really be like it she makes that big a mistake again would be more than enough. Mainly for providing alcohol to a minor though.


EDIT:

Also, am I justified in being irate at the fact that a 14 year old kid can get some from his hot babysitter, but I'm lucky if I can get the time of day from a woman?
 

Ruedyn

New member
Jun 29, 2011
2,982
0
0
I feel like this was his revenge for his mom making him still have a sitter. Also if the genders were reversed, I still wouldn't care too much, because all it sounds like is 2 consenting people having sex. Also, was his face revealed, because I'm just curious if she was into him superficialy or not and I'm too lazy to look over 20 pages of 'if teh roles were reversed herpa derp'...I am so going to get a warning but I don't even care.
 

Smurf McSmurfington

New member
Jun 24, 2010
235
0
0
Ugh, only in America.
First of all, why would a 14 year old require a babysitter? Or anyone over say... 5 or 6 for that matter. I guess I'll never understand americans and their fixation on babysitters for kids who don't need 'em.
Second, how can this even be considered a crime? People certainly seem to overreact on things such as this, especially in the US, for some reason. Let's face it, even considering throwing the 20 year old in jail because of it is unbelievably stupid. Theres no logical reason why this should be considered a crime, save for laws that have no real purpose, because they weren't made keeping reality in mind, thing is they're both young (though her taste in boys/men seems questionable, but that's hardly something one should be thrown in jail for), and both consenting, I imagine. It's not like getting someone slightly drunk instantly equals a date-rape, it just doesn't, not in reality anyway... then again I don't really understand what sort of reality americans live in.
Also, the age of consent is significantly lower in Europe, and guess what? There's nothing wrong with our societies here, in fact we're a hell of a lot less squeamish about sex than americans seem to be, and that's a GOOD thing, believe it or not.

P.S. I don't hate americans or the US itself as a country, I just find a lot of things about them/it incredibly silly and/or stupid.

TL;DR
This shouldn't be a crime at all.
 

Slayer_2

New member
Jul 28, 2008
2,475
0
0
Everyone saying "if the roles were reversed..." stop it. There is a double standard in our society, and there is still lots of sexism. Like it or not, it's true. You can say that they should treat her like a male sex offender, but at the end of the day, it's not going down like that. Be realistic, there are tons of differences between how males and females are treated in our society. It's not as bad as it was 50 or 100 years ago, but the fact is that these differences exist, so you must take them into consideration.

In this case, here is the view: males all want sex 24/7, provided the girl is hot, STD free, and not going to get pregnant. Females rarely want sex, except with someone they are in a serious relationship with, excepting sluts who drunkenly hook up with people at clubs/bars. Yes it's not true, but that is the view that 90% of the people are gonna accept regarding this case.
 

Lissa-QUON

New member
Jun 22, 2009
206
0
0
Send her to jail. Honestly I don't care how "lucky" you all think the kid is or how hot she is.


She broke the law, got a child inebriated (and she herself is 20, if this is in the US she technically shouldn't have any either, but I digress) and had sex with him.

Hell, even by the "half your age plus 7" scale she hits Damn Creepy for going at a 14 year old.

Plus he is a kid - he may THINK he knows what he's doing but he probably doesn't. The fact that he apparently was needing a baby sitter at the age of 14 means apparently his folks didn't trust his decision making abilities in a normal situation much less intoxicated with a grown woman going at him.
 

devilkingx

New member
Aug 3, 2011
38
0
0
ive always thought the laws of the subject were stupid, it should obviously be strictly consent FUCK AGE OF CONSENT its a stupid bullshit law that servers to say if your not our arbitrary age you arent smart enough to know what you want

im sure if any of you know anything about being a teen you'd know that you can perfectly decide what you want, and dont need to be told

DID THE BOY CONSENT? not legally PHYSICALLY did HE agree? if yes fuck the law she goes free if no THEN she goes to trial BUT ONLY IF HE DOESNT AGREE

what kind of fucked up world do we live in where WE decide what THE VICTIM feels FOR HIM!?!?!


Lissa-QUON said:
Send her to jail. Honestly I don't care how "lucky" you all think the kid is or how hot she is.


She broke the law, got a child inebriated (and she herself is 20, if this is in the US she technically shouldn't have any either, but I digress) and had sex with him.

Hell, even by the "half your age plus 7" scale she hits Damn Creepy for going at a 14 year old.

Plus he is a kid - he may THINK he knows what he's doing but he probably doesn't. The fact that he apparently was needing a baby sitter at the age of 14 means apparently his folks didn't trust his decision making abilities in a normal situation much less intoxicated with a grown woman going at him.
because what your parents think is an accurate representation of you right?

you know its very likely that his parents were just overprotective as shit, which is why they are crying foul that their baby was molested(when its quite likely that he wasnt exactly a helpless victim)

you sound like the kind of person who would gladly go on a rampage and murder all homeless people if it was deemed illegal just because the law knows better than common sense and the victims
 

karamazovnew

New member
Apr 4, 2011
263
0
0
What's with all this "what if he was 20 and she was 14" crap? That girl will go to jail because there's a law that she broke. Case closed. The whole point of this topic is that the law itself is flawed. Why? 20 year old girl just fulfills the dream of any 14 year old boy and she goes to jail for that. That's what we're discussing here. We don't decide if she goes to jail or not, and if you were in a jury you'd still say "damn... wish I hired her, oh well, guilty, sorry miss." But a lot of people just can't accept that "fulfills the dream of any 14 year old boy" part. I'm gonna take the road that Twiceworn took and point out that:

1. most 14 years old have already seen "2 girls one cup"
2. most 14 years old dread the "whaa, you're still a virgin? Douche!" talk in school
3. most 14 years old, if they're alone with a pretty 20 year old girl in the house WILL think about sex with that girl

So all the girl needs to say is "well..." and he's THERE! Now for this to be a sexual assault, I mean cmmoon.

But ok, let's reverse the genders. I personally know a girl who got together at age 13 with a 19 year old guy and they're married now. Neither of them has ever been with anyone else, and they loved each other at first sight. And yeah, I thought she was a whore too, and the guy a douche, took some time to change my mind about that. 200 hundred years ago women became mothers (and most died at childbirth) at age 14. Ok, so we changed the law, no sex before 16, ok (it's 18 in my country, not that it matters to kids these days). But it's absurd to put "20 year old guy has sex with 14 year old girl that likes him" in the same cell with "crazy uncle which tricks 6 year old niece into sucking his dick". Ok she's young at 14, she's most probably already seen "2 girls one cup", she knows what sex is, but ok, fine maybe she's easier to fool. And again, as Twiceworn said, she might not dream about having sex with her babysitter. If the 14 year old guy goes to schoool the next day, he's the envy of every classmate. If the 14 year old girl goes to school the next day, she's a slut. She has more reason to refuse the sex so ok, throw the dude in jail because he must've done something weird there to convince her. But in THIS case, it just feels wrong for that 19 year old babysitter to go to prison.
 

Magicman10893

New member
Aug 3, 2009
455
0
0
I voted against the jail time because of the age gap being so small. Sure the kid is 14, but that is literally a high school freshman and she was, what, 19 at the time? I didn't read the whole story, but a 19 year old could easily be a high school senior. There was this guy in my high school that was a senior and 19 years old (he may have been held back a year) and his girlfriend was a 14/15 year old freshman and he got caught having sex with her and he is now a registered sex offender for literally dating someone in his school.
 

Xman490

Doctorate in Danger
May 29, 2010
1,186
0
0
Well, considering that the pregnancy (if any) would be the older girl's problem, I say no jail. Jails are already overpopulated as is.
And this is not a question of gender equality; it's about who takes dire consequences. A 14-year-old girl can't handle pregnancy.

I'm guessing that pregnancy is the primary problem of this sort of debate, right?