joshthor said:
i try to play every genre, but there is one genre that has not produced a single game i like - JRPGs. the characters are always ludicrously designed androgynous children with the emotional depth of a jar of mayonnaise; the gameplay almost always annoys me; the stories always border on the absurd.
Okay, I'll bite, have you actually played any Japanese RPGs that aren't Final Fantasy? I don't mean to single you out (half the thread agrees with you), but if you only seek out and play the very weakest of the genre, don't be surprised to find mediocrity.
And since we're on the subject, 'JRPG' isn't a genre.
EDIT: Although, given the title of this thread, I guess it would make sense if you hadn't..
earloftaco said:
Though I'm sure lots of RPGs have great stories, the gameplay I've seen has never appealed to me. To be fair, the only "RPG" I've actually played is Borderlands, which I guess is technically an FPS RPG, but looking at hundreds of different weapons' stats to find the right ones for killing different variations of those stupid dog things bored the hell out of me.
If you were to recommend one RPG to get someone interested in the genre, what would it be?
That depends heavily on what consoles you own and what genres (fantasy, sci-fi, etc) you're interested in, as well as how far back you're willing to go. For some all-rounders, I'd suggest Mass Effect or Dragon Age. Or, if you want something slightly more shooty, New Vegas.
You could probably start a thread about it if you want some more suggestions, RPG fans tend to be more than willing to give some good examples.
[sub]Also welcome.[/sub]