It's ok to be freaked out, that's what horror stories should do (personally I find the gore and similar has to be used just as a side dish not as the main course of horror). Anybody can give you a surprise scare or grose you out, but to creep you out and make you think about something - that takes skill.
I guess you might consider yourself lucky, if you can still be so disturbed by these stories, that means you still have more than enough imagination.
Btw the slenderman creeped me out as well, there was the story of a woman seeing him walking the hallway and then he/it spots her, but that's mostly cause we have a long hallway in our building that connects few apartments and there's a window in the kitchen which is about 20 inches high and it's placed just high enough so I can see somebody passing by but not enough to see what's happening...if I see a shadow passing on the ceiling, there's no going to sleep for more than a few hours.
First major fright period was after watching Snow white, was scared that the witch will come during the night and cut my head off, so I covered my head with a blanket. Hey, I was like 7, no logic in the world can counteract overactive imagination. Second was the Nightmare on Elm.
I guess you might consider yourself lucky, if you can still be so disturbed by these stories, that means you still have more than enough imagination.
Btw the slenderman creeped me out as well, there was the story of a woman seeing him walking the hallway and then he/it spots her, but that's mostly cause we have a long hallway in our building that connects few apartments and there's a window in the kitchen which is about 20 inches high and it's placed just high enough so I can see somebody passing by but not enough to see what's happening...if I see a shadow passing on the ceiling, there's no going to sleep for more than a few hours.
First major fright period was after watching Snow white, was scared that the witch will come during the night and cut my head off, so I covered my head with a blanket. Hey, I was like 7, no logic in the world can counteract overactive imagination. Second was the Nightmare on Elm.