letsnoobtehpwns said:
When I read the words RuneScape, I cringed. I didn't vote in the poll because nothing said "Worst piece of shit ever put on this planet".
But it isn't! There's so much that is worse! I never understand why people can call Runescape that when it is so easy to think of games that can be so much worse.
Runescape's system was great, and put a lot more thought into it than people give it credit for. Especially since the membership cost was one of the common bad things about it. You pay for most of your games, so a $5-per-month game wasn't that bad for a game that could be endlessly continued. You didn't need the membership until later levels anyhow, so before that, it was free. And for a free game, it's a lot of bang for your buck.
A person explained to me that one of the reasons Runescape had done so poorly was that it lacked in graphics, or what he called "Distracting Bias". When a game looks good, you are less likely to notice the bad qualities in a game; sort of like hiding the hole in a wall by putting up a pretty picture in front of it. When something doesn't look good, people don't think it IS good, whether they consiously agree or not.
I could name games that were so much worse than Runescape, and that actually required you to pay for it. Sure, Runescape was nowhere near the best game ever, but it certainly wasn't the worst game ever. And far from worst.
EDIT: And don't take this angrily, please. I'm no raging fanboy. I'm only trying to erase some of the floating hatred of the game.