Poll: scott pilgrim or piranha 3D?

[Geekosaurus]

242 vs 36. That's pretty conclusive.

 

[jp201]

its not even close, scott pilgram

 

[ProfessorLayton]

Scott Pilgrim... I've never seen Piranha and while it does look like a whole lot of fun, if the only reason you want to see it is because it's in 3D, skip it. 3D is not as fun as it sounds unless you think wearing uncomfortable glasses and the screen being super dark and having a hard time concentrating on what's going on a fun time.

 

[twaddle]

well i hope i wasn't ninja'd when i say this:

THE IS SOMETHING IN THE WAAATEERRRR!!!
....no wait someone just shat and left a huge piece of steaming boulvine excrement in the ocean that is modern cinema again

....go see scott pilgrim and read the comics folks

 

[Dense_Electric]

If you'd like to see Kelly Brook nude, there's a website you can go to called "Google" (http://www.google.com) that has the amazing ability of searching other websites for relevant content. And the best part is, you don't have to pay $15 to use it.

If you'd like to see a genuinely good movie that is essentially a complex study of human emotion in (to quote MovieBob) the rough context of a MegaMan movie, and has a shitton of humor, action, romance, music, and videogame references, go see Scott Pilgrim. It's currently tied with Toy Story 3 and Inception as being the best movie I've seen this year.

 

[Breaker deGodot]

Honestly, I think that's a pretty obvious answer. Although, I might see Piranha for the bewbs.

 

[Teh Ty]

Piranha is stupid and boring with blood. Scott Pilgrim is stupid, but funny, cool, and has a silly but great storyline.

 

[RowdyRodimus]

Here's a better idea (since I guess I'm Satan for not liking Scott Pilgrim), don't see either and buy the DC Showcase Presents Ambush Bug trade. You'll get more laughs and if it sells well enough maybe we'll get more of the Bug.

Cheeks the Toy Wonder > Scott Pilgrim. Fact.

 

[Brisingr]

Scott looks interesting. Piranha on the other hand looks pure awful. No competition ¬¬

 

[squid5580]

I just saw Piranha last night (my first 3D movie as well). And although they did butcher the story and really needed a douchebag to hate for longer than a scene it was a fun movie. Gory as hell, lots of boobies (in 3D). Then again I am a fan of the originals and enjoy cheesy horror flicks like it so I am a bit biased when I say Piranha for the win.

 

[squid5580]

If you've seen Jaws you've seen Piranha. See Scott Pilgrim.

You sir are misinformed. If you have seen the original Piranhas then it is fair to compare them to Jaws. The remake is nowhere near close other than it involves water and has a sheriff.

Oh almost forgot the ole sheriff's kid's trapped on a sinking boat in infested water scene.

 

[squid5580]

If you've seen Jaws you've seen Piranha. See Scott Pilgrim.

You sir are misinformed. If you have seen the original Piranhas then it is fair to compare them to Jaws. The remake is nowhere near close other than it involves water and has a sheriff.

Oh almost forgot the ole sheriff's kid's trapped on a sinking boat in infested water scene.

Haven't actually seen the film, but the trailer had:
A) Man Eating Water Monsters
B) Set at a highly popular holiday location with a large body of water
C) The Authorities are warned about the dangers, however they are too greedy to shut down the location in B
D) As a result of C loads of people get eaten

But maybe your right and they are totally different films after the halfway mark.

You are wrong about C. There is no mayor or any authority type person other than the sheriff and the deputy. The only time there is any mention of closing the lake is when they find the first body. And that is because the deputy mentions toxic waste. In Jaws you had Schneider fighting against the mayor trying to warn everyone. In this remake they find the body in the middle of the night the next day the movie is over. It was a bit disappointing they didn't really give us a mayor type to hate.

 

[crystalsnow]

Dude, piranhas and 3D?!?! How come I've never heard of this movie? I think the choice here is obvious.

Piranhas fucking rule.

 

[G-Force]

Fuck Scott Pilgrim, goddamn hipster shit, and fuck Michael Cera, fuck him and everything he stands for. He's the worst actor on this planet, and I've seen alot of terrible actors. Don't believe me? See Year One, that movie makes me want to kill kittens.

Nothing can be worse than a movie that has Michael Cera in it. Nothing.

This is my sentments, just not as aggressive. Michael Cera always plays the same exact charater, and nothing else and he doesn't even do it that well. If you want to see pretentious nerd art then scott pilgram. If you want to see mindless fun and laughable horror then piranha.

Question, what is your definition of pretentious?

Also Michal Cera is not playing the same character. Scott Pilgrim is a jackass (likeable) douchbag. Also name a Michael Cera movie where the actor had to play bass guitar songs, do wire-fu, engage in multi-man brawls, one-on-one duels and swordfights. If you can come up with another example then I'll agree that Cera is indeed playing the same role here.

 

[MajorKris]

Go see Scott Pilgrim, please.

I've already seen it twice and it shall forever have a spot in my heart...

Fan-made trailer anyone?

Spoiler

 

[Twad]

None. Add the third option.

 

[Sir-jackington]

Scott Pilgrim for sure, i don't think i would even see piranha 3D if it was the only choice

 

[lazinesslord]

Scott Pilgrim
That movie is an absolute masterpiece.
Funny, good action, and thought-provoking, it's brilliant.