Poll: She's seeing someone else....

Recommended Videos

Kevlar Eater

New member
Sep 27, 2009
1,933
0
0
From my observation of other people, I think it's best to move on. More than likely, she will only see you as a friend, and such a question can ruin a friendship. She may rather chew off a limb at an attempt at freedom than think anything can work between you two.
 

Ryuk2

New member
Sep 27, 2009
766
0
0
You can combine ''move on'' with ''wait''. You can be just friends if you like her so much.
 

Keepitclean

New member
Sep 16, 2009
1,564
0
0
Well I cant really say to much as I dont know exactly the "seeing someone else is".
But if she likes him more than she likes you its too late.
 

Cortheya

Elite Member
Jan 10, 2009
1,200
0
41
Keepitclean said:
Well I cant really say to much as I dont know exactly the "seeing someone else is".
But if she likes him more than she likes you its to late.
The thing is, I seldom see them together and while I'm sure they spend more time than that together, I'm around her more than he is.
 

Keepitclean

New member
Sep 16, 2009
1,564
0
0
Cortheya said:
Keepitclean said:
Well I cant really say to much as I dont know exactly the "seeing someone else is".
But if she likes him more than she likes you its to late.
The thing is, I seldom see them together and while I'm sure they spend more time than that together, I'm around her more than he is.
Well if you have fallen into her "just friends" catagory you probably had no chance. But does she know you like her? 'Coz if she doesnt you gotta get moving before she gets into him too much.
I can understand your dilemma but i say go for it because waiting is the killer. You wait, you lose.

Just think, is your pride worth more than her?
 

Cortheya

Elite Member
Jan 10, 2009
1,200
0
41
Keepitclean said:
Cortheya said:
Keepitclean said:
Well I cant really say to much as I dont know exactly the "seeing someone else is".
But if she likes him more than she likes you its to late.
The thing is, I seldom see them together and while I'm sure they spend more time than that together, I'm around her more than he is.
Well if you have fallen into her "just friends" catagory you probably had no chance. But does she know you like her? 'Coz if she doesnt you gotta get moving before she gets into him too much.
She and he have been going out since spring though so "before she gets into him" isn't an option... I have hinted so much that I have and she never gets the hint despite her being the smartest person I have ever met....
 

Keepitclean

New member
Sep 16, 2009
1,564
0
0
Cortheya said:
Keepitclean said:
Cortheya said:
Keepitclean said:
Well I cant really say to much as I dont know exactly the "seeing someone else is".
But if she likes him more than she likes you its to late.
The thing is, I seldom see them together and while I'm sure they spend more time than that together, I'm around her more than he is.
Well if you have fallen into her "just friends" catagory you probably had no chance. But does she know you like her? 'Coz if she doesnt you gotta get moving before she gets into him too much.
She and he have been going out since spring though so "before she gets into him" isn't an option... I have hinted so much that I have and she never gets the hint despite her being the smartest person I have ever met....
It's possible that she doesn't know what to make of your hint so she pretends that she never saw it.

Edit: Sorry about the last post, I edited it after you quoted it
 

JanatUrlich

New member
Apr 24, 2009
1,963
0
0
Dude, if she's with someone else, you're fucked. Face facts. Move on in the meantime and if she becomes single again, just have a go then.
 

Aunel

New member
May 9, 2008
1,927
0
0
at least you said Perfect Strangers
(Deep Purple)

tell her, if it fails move on,
[small]now I should do the same[/small]
 

OmegaXIII

New member
Jun 26, 2009
811
0
0
clairedelune said:
I laughed, hard.

Personally i would both wait and move on. Allow me explain, don't take yourself out of the game, if someone else comes along don't be afraid to go for it but do keep an eye open for this girl. Keep flirting, keep being friends etc etc and then that way if she does become available then you've lost nothing. If she becomes available and you happen to be with someone else, thats the hard bit but if you're sensible the person you would be with would be equally as right for you so no problem.

This is all from personal experience because my girlfriend was seeing another guy for nearly 8 months while i just sat in the background hoping. I had a couple of other relationships in that time but they just naturally didn't work out so it was win/win for me. The key thing is to not get with someone else and then think about the unrequited one all the time - thats just a signal you're in that relationship for the wrong reasons
 

Keepitclean

New member
Sep 16, 2009
1,564
0
0
Cortheya said:
Keepitclean said:
Just think, is your pride worth more than her?
No, I really don't think it is
Then go for it ASAP. But do realize that if she is "involved" with this guy your probably fucked before you begin.
I cant really make a proper judgement as I have no real idea what is going on.

But best of luck to ya and theres plenty more fish in the ocean.
 

AndyFromMonday

New member
Feb 5, 2009
3,921
0
0
Just. Fucking. Tell her. 'kay? Don't be has stupid has other people in your situation. If you don't tell her, you'll always wonder if she'd had say yes or no. If you do tell her, you won't have to stay up all night thinking of what she might have said.

If you're worried that it might damage your friendship then yes, those fears are founded. It MIGHT damage your friendship if she says no but by God a humans life is built on taking chances, you'll just have to take yours.
 

Asturiel

the God of Pants
Nov 24, 2009
3,940
0
0
This is a tough issue, on the one hand this is somebody that you have great personal feelings for and is probably a good match for you, but on the other hand you can be a complete douchebag if you say something.

It's a difficult dilemma, you should do what you think will make you happy, because that should be what we are here for right? To be happy and persue it. One good friend of mine when I asked him questions like this offered one answer "Do what makes you happy as long as it doesnt hurt another human being"

That doesnt help you considering the possibility that you may wreck the relationship she's currently in. Put yourself in her boyfriends shoes, how would you feel if your relationship was going great then all of a sudden your girlfriend acted strange and left you for her friend? Pissed, depressed, confused. You havent said much about her boyfriend so im assuming you dont hate him with a firey passion.

How about your friend to whom you want to have a relationship? What if she is truly trying to make this relationship work with this guy and you come along and shatter one of her key supports?

Im sorry for such a long post to not give you any anwers just that I want you to see how I see the situation, all of the possibilities and outcomes of which. However it all comes down to this,

Do you find it nobler to suffer or better to see yourself happier and somebody else potentially suffer?
 

Commissar Sae

New member
Nov 13, 2009
983
0
0
From personal experience, waiting is the worst thing you can do. Let a fantastic girl slip through my fingers that way so either decide to tell her and see what happens, or try to move on.
 

WhamBamSam

New member
Oct 29, 2009
211
0
0
Based on your description of her, if you really have been dropping regular hints, I'd imagine she already has a pretty good idea what your feelings are. If you suspect that is the case you've just got to analyze the situation as best you can and make a gut call. None of us can possibly know the answer better than you. No matter how clueless you may be, you will still have a better and more complete answer than even the most erudite forum-goer.

If she's unaware, then here's something to keep in mind. You're asking for advice on a gaming forum, and as such I personally doubt that you're particularly suited to the task of performing the necessary high-wire act required in waiting out their breakup. More likely, you're a good old fashioned romantic idiot (not a bad thing, mind you) and everything's going to come out one way or another. Do it on your own terms, and don't half-ass it. Put some serious thought into what you're going to say. Do it in writing, or song, or whatever if that feels more comfortable for you. You may want to consider posting whatever you come up with here, as I can almost guarantee that it'll sound either much better or much worse than it really is from your perspective. This is actually an area where the internets can help you, because we've got sufficient emotional distance from the issue at hand to tell what the actual quality of the thing is, and probably won't resent you for making us deal with your problems, as we'll get a nice laugh out of it if nothing else.
 

Rancid0ffspring

New member
Aug 23, 2009
703
0
0
TheNamlessGuy said:
Tell her.

She may even break up with that other person for you, for all you know
Never go out with a girl who dumps someone else for you! It means she has low values when it comes to loyalty & there's little to stop her from doing the same to you.

Move on dude. Loads of women out there. There never is just the ONE