So this is how I stand. I want to play Star Wars Battlefront 3. SWB 1 and 2 were some of my favourite all time games and I'd love to play more of them.
But I really don't think it's likely that Star Wars Battlefront will be SWB3. I can't see that happening at all, I suspect the orders from EA were 'Make Battlefield with Star Wars' and that's what we're going to get.
It doesn't mean it's going to be bad! But it does mean it's going to be Battlefield. You've got to think really hard about what you want when you say 'I want Star Wars Battlefront' do you want the gameplay? Do you want the tone? Do you want the names? Because we're not going to get the gameplay, that's just not going to happen. If you care most of all about the gameplay, then this announcement should be most exciting to the people who are asking to play Battlefield 3.5, because thats what the gameplay will be. If you want the setting it could go either way, personally I think The Old Republic and The Force Unleashed were pretty bad at conveying setting, because they hadn't been designed from the ground up to make the gameplay reflect Star Wars, and I think that will happen here. It's going to be an enjoyable Battlefield with Star Wars names and most of you will enjoy that. But that's not what I want, I want Star Wars Battlefront 3.
Now I could be wrong, DICE are talented developer and maybe they'll buck the EA trend and not go for the safe easy option. But I would rather be surprised by having the game turn out to be good when I didn't believe it would be, than to go in expecting SWB3 and be disappointed again.
EDIT:
chadachada123 said:
On the one hand, FINALLY, Battlefront 3! I am fucking excited.
On the other...EA is publishing it. Worse, the developers of Medal of Honor: Warfighter are the ones developing it, after their studio was re-branded as DICE's LA branch.
We'll have to see. It could go in several very separate directions.
Whoops it turns out I was actually being way too optimstic. Guys destroy your expectations, EA isn't even feeling energetic enough to give us a Star Wars branded Battlefield clone