Poll: Suicide - Your opinion

Recommended Videos

Insanum

The Basement Caretaker.
May 26, 2009
4,452
0
0
Kurokami said:
ThreeWords said:
In my opinion, it doesn't matter. It's their life, and if they want to leave, that's their choice. It's not for me to decide that they are brave or cowardly, right or wrong
You got it all wrong, its ONLY yours to decide whether they're brave or cowardly, right or wrong. In the end You've only got your point of view
I disagree. Yes, your entitled to your own opinion, But judging someone without knowing what was on their plate is just ignorant (in my opinion)
 

AvsJoe

Elite Member
May 28, 2009
9,055
0
41
Housebroken Lunatic said:
AvsJoe said:
My religion tells me that suicides go to hell, but my personal opinion is that if you can't hack it, go home. I don't hate people who commit suicide. Actually, as purely a pragmatic standpoint, people who commit suicide are a good thing because it helps out the global overpopulation crisis.
So do gay people... Do you and your religion like them as well? :)
The fact that my religion is against homosexuals has always bugged me. I'm not against it; hell I'm all for it. Again, purely pragmatic, that means that there is less competition for the women out there .
 

headshotcatcher

New member
Feb 27, 2009
1,687
0
0
Maraveno said:
First of all, you'd still have friends left.. And as you choose them yourself they are unlikely to backstab you (unless you are messed up)

As for the rest, no I haven't had any actual rock bottom situations eventhough I do kinda hate my current life but the only way to change it is to graduate and move away from here ASAP...
 

Kurokami

New member
Feb 23, 2009
2,352
0
0
Insanum said:
Kurokami said:
ThreeWords said:
In my opinion, it doesn't matter. It's their life, and if they want to leave, that's their choice. It's not for me to decide that they are brave or cowardly, right or wrong
You got it all wrong, its ONLY yours to decide whether they're brave or cowardly, right or wrong. In the end You've only got your point of view
I disagree. Yes, your entitled to your own opinion, But judging someone without knowing what was on their plate is just ignorant (in my opinion)
You misunderstood what I meant. (and I really can't be bothered explaining right now, sorry. fair mistake though)

Anyway, here's the simplest way for me to portray my opinion.

You have only so long to live, you have an eternity to be dead, why not make the most of what you got? (shallow argument, but works for me) I condone the suicide of those who can't improve their lifestyle (in other words are physically impaired, or something similar), or honestly can't find a single thing to live for (which basically means to me that if so much as a single person gives a shit that you're dead you shouldn't do it)
 

Housebroken Lunatic

New member
Sep 12, 2009
2,544
0
0
AvsJoe said:
The fact that my religion is against homosexuals has always bugged me. I'm not against it; hell I'm all for it. Again, purely pragmatic, that means that there is less competition for the women out there .
... Well not really, I mean there's still the lesbians to consider. That's not only ONE woman "wasted" (in the eyes of the prowling heterosexual male) but TWO! :)

But can't you distance yourself from the established religion? I mean, your worship of your god is a business between you and your god, not the people you go to church with. Nor is it the preacher's business.

Or could you simply be content in the fact that your god hates homosexuals and want's to throw them to hell simply for being different?
 

Housebroken Lunatic

New member
Sep 12, 2009
2,544
0
0
Kurokami said:
You have only so long to live, you have an eternity to be dead, why not make the most of what you got? (shallow argument, but works for me)
I don't know if you'd like to hear this but that argument can be reversed. If we're all going to be dead for eternity anyway, what's the point in living at all? Why cling to something and actually learn to enjoy it when you know that it will all be taken away forever pretty soon? (I say "soon" because in comparison to be dead for eternity, a lifetime is pretty short) Why not just end it all immediately and be done with it?
 

AvsJoe

Elite Member
May 28, 2009
9,055
0
41
Housebroken Lunatic said:
But can't you distance yourself from the established religion? I mean, your worship of your god is a business between you and your god, not the people you go to church with. Nor is it the preacher's business.
Way ahead of you. I believe in the basics of my religion, the foundations if you will. But I don't care for the specifics. I just stick to: If it benefits society or doesn't harm anyone besides yourself, go nuts!
 

Kurokami

New member
Feb 23, 2009
2,352
0
0
Housebroken Lunatic said:
Kurokami said:
You have only so long to live, you have an eternity to be dead, why not make the most of what you got? (shallow argument, but works for me)
I don't know if you'd like to hear this but that argument can be reversed. If we're all going to be dead for eternity anyway, what's the point in living at all? Why cling to something and actually learn to enjoy it when you know that it will all be taken away forever pretty soon? (I say "soon" because in comparison to be dead for eternity, a lifetime is pretty short) Why not just end it all immediately and be done with it?
Dunno if you believe in an afterlife, but to me my life is the longest thing in the world, I'll never experience something longer, will I? you can say that a tree is older then me, but what do I know, to me it only exists so long as I know it.

Now suppose I know you, and with that view you kill yourself, you would have ended, your existence meaningless (as is everyone's) but in my mind is all that matters, if we were close you'd be a prick who didn't care enough about me or anyone else who cared about him/her to go on living, in my perception you'll be worse then non existent and my perception is everything. (as is yours for you, etcetc)
 

ChromeAlchemist

New member
Aug 21, 2008
5,865
0
0
Kukul said:
I don't think one can really judge a suicide.
BTW I hate suicides that aren't stlyish like for example swallowing a handful of sleeping pills, because your boyfriend left you as opposed to, I don't know, shooting yourself in the head, so that the enemy can't torture you and get to know your secrets or stuff.. yeah, um, anyway remember:
It's your suicide, have fun with it.
Any suicide that didn't involve robbing a bank is a waste in my eyes.

But anyway, I'm inclined to say depends. Can't say cowardice, cowardice is reserved for those who are sound of mind, and if you are prepared to take your life then you most certainly aren't so...depends.

Housebroken Lunatic said:
Kurokami said:
You have only so long to live, you have an eternity to be dead, why not make the most of what you got? (shallow argument, but works for me)
I don't know if you'd like to hear this but that argument can be reversed. If we're all going to be dead for eternity anyway, what's the point in living at all? Why cling to something and actually learn to enjoy it when you know that it will all be taken away forever pretty soon? (I say "soon" because in comparison to be dead for eternity, a lifetime is pretty short) Why not just end it all immediately and be done with it?
Because most people say "dead for eternity" because they don't know what lies beyond. Some people commit suicide to chance life after death, which is quite the gamble.

But still, IMO if you still have your health, I can't justify you hanging from the noose. Some might give me an example, but say I was crossing a bridge and you were about to jump, and you told me why, would I say "Yeah, you're right, I guess you should jump"? Fuck no.
 

Dom Uk

New member
Jul 9, 2009
110
0
0
I chose it depends purely because I don't think it's a black and white subject.
Since some people are better at coping with problems than others it's obvious that at some point, people who can't cope very well will feel overwhelmed by their problems and look at suicide as a viable alternative, whereas people better suited to coping may be able to just shrug the same problem off as if it were nothing.
 

Housebroken Lunatic

New member
Sep 12, 2009
2,544
0
0
Kurokami said:
Dunno if you believe in an afterlife, but to me my life is the longest thing in the world, I'll never experience something longer, will I? you can say that a tree is older then me, but what do I know, to me it only exists so long as I know it.

Now suppose I know you, and with that view you kill yourself, you would have ended, your existence meaningless (as is everyone's) but in my mind is all that matters, if we were close you'd be a prick who didn't care enough about me or anyone else who cared about him/her to go on living, in my perception you'll be worse then non existent and my perception is everything. (as is yours for you, etcetc)
Nope. I don't believe in an afterlife. Mostly because of scientific facts I have pieced together. Now I can't say for certain that an afterlife doesn't exist, but the probability of it is very small. After all,we're just biological machines, driven by energy, and while energy can't be created or destroyed but merely converted, the bioelectric energy driving my brain and therefor drive my awareness will sooner or later forever be turned into thermal energy. There's not much room for an awareness in temperature alone.

But the part were you say I'd be a prick for killing myself If we were real close, that begs another question. Who do you live for? I mean really, we're all living for ourselves, not for anyone else, why should it be any different with our deaths?

It's not that any one of us really asked to be born, it was forced upon us. We didn't really ask to be liked by others either or missed when we're gone, but we are anyway (well most of us at least).

If we all basically live for ourselves, shouldn't we die for ourselves as well?
 

Housebroken Lunatic

New member
Sep 12, 2009
2,544
0
0
ChromeAlchemist said:
Because most people say "dead for eternity" because they don't know what lies beyond. Some people commit suicide to chance life after death, which is quite the gamble.

But still, IMO if you still have your health, I can't justify you hanging from the noose. Some might give me an example, but say I was crossing a bridge and you were about to jump, and you told me why, would I say "Yeah, you're right, I guess you should jump"? Fuck no.
Hehe, then I guess you're a more idealistic person than I am.

If I was walking across a bridge and saw someone ready to jump, I'd just say:

"Well jump then motherf*cker! Die with some dignity and prove to me that you're not just another whiny b*tch whose craving attention!"

... Or rather I'd ask them if I can have the money in their wallet first. (it's not like they're gonna need it where they are going now is it?)
 

Housebroken Lunatic

New member
Sep 12, 2009
2,544
0
0
AvsJoe said:
Way ahead of you. I believe in the basics of my religion, the foundations if you will. But I don't care for the specifics. I just stick to: If it benefits society or doesn't harm anyone besides yourself, go nuts!
Good for you! : )
 

GrinningManiac

New member
Jun 11, 2009
4,090
0
0
Selfish. Think of the grief you will cause everyone who knows you.

A nerdy annecdote: Life's a game on "hard" settings, and you're the coward who quits, leaving your team one man down and alone, you sap
 

Kurokami

New member
Feb 23, 2009
2,352
0
0
Housebroken Lunatic said:
Kurokami said:
Dunno if you believe in an afterlife, but to me my life is the longest thing in the world, I'll never experience something longer, will I? you can say that a tree is older then me, but what do I know, to me it only exists so long as I know it.

Now suppose I know you, and with that view you kill yourself, you would have ended, your existence meaningless (as is everyone's) but in my mind is all that matters, if we were close you'd be a prick who didn't care enough about me or anyone else who cared about him/her to go on living, in my perception you'll be worse then non existent and my perception is everything. (as is yours for you, etcetc)
Nope. I don't believe in an afterlife. Mostly because of scientific facts I have pieced together. Now I can't say for certain that an afterlife doesn't exist, but the probability of it is very small. After all,we're just biological machines, driven by energy, and while energy can't be created or destroyed but merely converted, the bioelectric energy driving my brain and therefor drive my awareness will sooner or later forever be turned into thermal energy. There's not much room for an awareness in temperature alone.

But the part were you say I'd be a prick for killing myself If we were real close, that begs another question. Who do you live for? I mean really, we're all living for ourselves, not for anyone else, why should it be any different with our deaths?

It's not that any one of us really asked to be born, it was forced upon us. We didn't really ask to be liked by others either or missed when we're gone, but we are anyway (well most of us at least).

If we all basically live for ourselves, shouldn't we die for ourselves as well?
Yes, but that's not what I'm answering, see in the scenario I produced your opinion wasn't answered for, clearly you had a reason to suicide but when your life ends you no longer exist, your loved ones on the other hand are the ones who perceive your death. They're the ones that get to judge it and they're the ones who have to live through with it, because of that its selfish. So I'm not saying people don't have the right to suicide, I'm saying in my perception its cowardly and stupid.

Reading we're biological machines its kinda depressing knowing that we don't actually have as much control over our bodies or even our minds, in the end its all just conditioning and in the end there's nothing. huh... this may be my last post. (j/k, xD)