Poll: what was wrong with halo?

Recommended Videos

Zac Smith

New member
Apr 25, 2010
672
0
0
I like Halo yes, but I think most would agree that the series has since gone stagnant. I think Bungie should have retired the series after Halo 3, and should've have moved on from there. Now it just seems they are trying to blood out of a stone
 

The Apothecarry

New member
Mar 6, 2011
1,051
0
0
The Halo series always had a fantastic story (save for Halo 3) and balamced multiplayer. Bungie has managed to keep Halo's multiplayer fairly fresh by offering something new or tweaked with each game.

I will admit that making the sniper rifle an anti-vehicle weapon wasn't the best move.
 

marscentral

Where's the Kaboom?
Dec 26, 2009
218
0
0
I personally love the Halo games. I've never really been able to get into fps's, except Timesplitters, but I got Halo from CE. I've had some great laughs playing with my friends on it and I enjoyed the story.
 

ReaperzXIII

New member
Jan 3, 2010
569
0
0
elvor0 said:
sravankb said:
Also, I gotta ask something - why do so many people consider Master Chief to be a bland character, while Gordon Freeman doesn't receive anywhere near that amount of criticism? Mind you, I like both the Half-Life and Halo franchises, but this is something I've never understood. Not trying to incite a flame-war here; I'm genuinely asking.
I think it's because Freeman is a silent protagonist, so he just has no spoken personality, but a lot of his back story is derived from other characters or the environment.

Master Chief on the other hand has a personality of sorts,but it's got almost nothing to it at all, we have his back story, but he only says stuff like "what do we do?" "We're going over here now", he has no personality at all, yet he speaks occasionally, and the only stuff we get is stuff that doesn't really reveal who he is as a character, like we have no hint of what he is like as a person if you know what I mean.
In the books Master Chief has a personality, a strong leader that cares about his team after realizing he can't solo everything, arrogant etc... its just in the game they tend not to give him a a massive personality.

Also I like Halo, I find it fun, it brings a different sort of appeal to the table after playing realistic shooters like Battlefield and CoD also I find the campaign quite fun to do especially on Legendary. I haven't completed Half Life 2 yet but so far I find Halo more fun the Half Life.
 

GrizzlerBorno

New member
Sep 2, 2010
2,295
0
0
People hate on Halo because they think the Singleplayer is important. It isn't. The important thing about Halo is the community it has spawned. No one outside of this community can ever truly enjoy Halo.

And just to clarify, I haven't played any Halo games except wombat devolved, cause I don't have an Xbox. So no, I don't understand Halo because I'm not part of the community.
 

Woodsey

New member
Aug 9, 2009
14,553
0
0
"People are always telling me why they hate halo but I want to know why"

Well... err... they've told you?

Anyway, its just very average. The epitome of it in fact. And its done the same as CoD, where people now regard that standard of writing as "good".


sravankb said:
Also, I gotta ask something - why do so many people consider Master Chief to be a bland character, while Gordon Freeman doesn't receive anywhere near that amount of criticism? Mind you, I like both the Half-Life and Halo franchises, but this is something I've never understood. Not trying to incite a flame-war here; I'm genuinely asking.
Because Freeman is silent, and is meant to be a place-holder for you. The Master Chief is a character however, he's just exceptionally dull and generic.
 

Moromillas

New member
May 25, 2010
328
0
0
I liked playing Halo, I especially liked the co-op split-screen. What I didn't like was how it "modernized" the FPS industry into regenerating health and other features which I consider to "dumbing down." It's good, but it's no quake 1 or 2.
 

Thaius

New member
Mar 5, 2008
3,862
0
0
I've mostly seen two reasons: fans (because apparently if stupid people like something that means it's automatically bad) and popularity (because apparently if a lot of people like something it's automatically bad). Both are terrible reasons fit for idiots. Outside of that there are reasons of preference, but I've even seen few of those that actually have real backing behind them. It's not a perfect series, but it's a great shooter series with a fantastic sci-fi war story, enjoyable multiplayer, and some of the greatest music ever written for a video game.
 

TheIronRuler

New member
Mar 18, 2011
4,283
0
0
I played the first one on my PC and reached halfway only to find myself screaming at the monitor.
The second one was for vista, and the rest I didn't care because of the second.
This went by me almost unnoticed.
Perhaps because this turns to many xbox players it became so popular?
I'm a PC user exclusively, and.... I didn't enjoy halo 1.
 

Vrex360

Badass Alien
Mar 2, 2009
8,379
0
0
I honestly don't think there's anything here really hate worthy. Halo might not be the greatest thing since sliced bread but I doubt it's as bad as the incredibly angry haters would have you believe.
As it stands Halo is a solid series with good, well functioning gameplay, a well balanced online multiplayer component, a pretty cool and intriquete backstory, some freaking amazing music and it hits home for me due to nostalgia and charm and happy memories playing it.

I love Halo, it might not deserve to be hailed as the greatest endevour of human existence but it also deserves way more credit then it gets. We've already had the thread about how Halo doesn't do most of the things people blame it for so I won't repeat it, I'll just say that Halo is a game series that I love. The main trilogy in particular while not perfect is still a proud addition to my collection and all the content in Halo: Reach continues to keep me busy, forging, fire fighting, customizing and online playing like mad.

Just because it's a big AAA game doesn't mean it should be despised because of it.
 

Jezzascmezza

New member
Aug 18, 2009
2,500
0
0
In my opinion, not much at all was wrong with Halo.
I don't want to start a fight here, but I'd say a lot of the people who "hate" Halo so much are the people who haven't even played it before.
 

Belluavir

New member
Mar 20, 2011
29
0
0
Never played Halo and probably never will, I just dislike the jock dickhead culture surrounding it. I don't like being told how "epic" it is or how they feel sorry for me for not getting it.
 

sexbutler

New member
Nov 18, 2010
98
0
0
Theres nothing wrong with it. Theres just nothing particularly good about it either, save the multiplayer. And thats why its so popular, because the good co-op managed to corner the mouth-breathing casual gamer market.
 

Ladette

New member
Feb 4, 2011
983
0
0
I hate "realistic" shooters that aren't Counter Strike, so I love Halo.

I consider Combat Evolved to be one of the last "Great" shooters and I very much enjoyed 2, 3, and Reach. I love the setting, the weapons, the fast paced gameplay, and the easy to control vehicles. If I had to choose between Halo and Unreal Tournament as a series it'd be a really tough call.
 

AndrewF022

New member
Jan 23, 2010
378
0
0
Halo is great, the singleplayer is a little meh, but was still action packed and at least exciting enough for a playthrough or two, it is a little easy, but the higher difficulties do offer quite a challenge.

The multiplayer is flat out awesome though, it's still the best 4-player splitscreen game since Goldeneye on the N64 in my mind. With tons of extras like theatre mode and Forge, theres something for everyone.. except those who suck at shooters in general or just plain don't like them at all.
 

elvor0

New member
Sep 8, 2008
2,320
0
0
ReaperzXIII said:
elvor0 said:
sravankb said:
Also, I gotta ask something - why do so many people consider Master Chief to be a bland character, while Gordon Freeman doesn't receive anywhere near that amount of criticism? Mind you, I like both the Half-Life and Halo franchises, but this is something I've never understood. Not trying to incite a flame-war here; I'm genuinely asking.
I think it's because Freeman is a silent protagonist, so he just has no spoken personality, but a lot of his back story is derived from other characters or the environment.

Master Chief on the other hand has a personality of sorts,but it's got almost nothing to it at all, we have his back story, but he only says stuff like "what do we do?" "We're going over here now", he has no personality at all, yet he speaks occasionally, and the only stuff we get is stuff that doesn't really reveal who he is as a character, like we have no hint of what he is like as a person if you know what I mean.
In the books Master Chief has a personality, a strong leader that cares about his team after realizing he can't solo everything, arrogant etc... its just in the game they tend not to give him a a massive personality.

Also I like Halo, I find it fun, it brings a different sort of appeal to the table after playing realistic shooters like Battlefield and CoD also I find the campaign quite fun to do especially on Legendary. I haven't completed Half Life 2 yet but so far I find Halo more fun the Half Life.
Mm, I've read one of the books and he's a bit more fleshed out there, which is a shame, because they could've bought it over to the game and it would've made him interesting as a character. However really we're going by games and even with the books existing, the books shouldn't need to be there in order to give a personality to a video game character, all of it should be present in the game. I enjoy playing the games, but I just feel that if they gave him remnants of a character in the game they should've gone the whole hog and given him a proper persona. Although that may have been a life saver on his part, the rest of the characters in Halo are rubbish >< Ironically the only character I feel was actually decent in Halo was Cortana, who in universe was the ARTIFICIAL intelligence.
 

88chaz88

New member
Jul 23, 2010
236
0
0
It was console exclusive (for a while).

Seriously, this is probably the biggest reason for all the complaints. PC gamers somehow got offended by being denied an fps and found every conceivable reason to hate it, despite it being no worse than any other fps around at the time (and much better than a large majority of them).

Now the series is stagnated and the online community is less than reputable, but I still believe most of the complaints stem from PC gamers being shut out.