CantFaketheFunk said:
And isn't that technically what every undead is? They've always had the exact same classes as Humans - minus the Paladins - and when you roll your level 1, isn't that interpreted as "oh hey, welcome back from being dead. Hope you remember what you used to be!"
Why can't there be Paladins that died and were resurrected, and then came back as Forsaken?
*Dons wizard hat and robe.*
According to Warcraft Lore undead and forsaken cannot actually channel the light, and the only reason they do so in the game is for the obvious balance reasons. Indeed there are multiple NPC in the early forsaken area which resent the light for 'abandoning' them in their times of need. In that same vein the Forsaken do not largely follow the light anymore, but instead worship 'the shadow' in the form of the forsaken's Cult of the Forgotten Shadow.
It's also worth noting that Paladins were immune to the plague, the only way for one to become undead was to be killed by the undead proper and then re-animated by a powerful necromancer. That's why they are so few and so sought after by the Lich King as servants.
There are a few examples of undead finding ways to use the light, but most take on more... nefarious methods such as the blood elves and their attempts to force the light towards their side through draining a being infused with the stuff
(Torturing a god, slightly evil!). Similarly I don't believe Leonid actually uses any paladin's abilities, although his alignment remains to the paladins.
The only proven example that I know of for a Paladin to keep his power beyond death is Sir Zeliek, and he's a particularly special case since his mind is still his own and it's only his body which is being controlled, like a puppets, by the Lich King. That's why he begs you to flee and thanks you right before he's been killed.
I should also note that the order of the Paladin was specifically created for purpose of fighting the Horde after they slaughtered the priests of Northshire abbey
(Human starting area, go figure.) and the bishop created a new order to defend against something like that ever happening again. Paladins were also almost single-handedly responsible for the victory of the second war against the Orcs. So it's a bit of a slap in the face, lore wise, for Horde to be getting Paladin. Blood Elves had an excuse, what with the mentioned torturing of divine beings... but Tauren? Tauren are druidic, they didn't even have priests, that makes about as much sense as a gnome priest...
oh wait, they get those now too? Nevermind...