dscross said:
I still think it's a matter of opinion.
Um, yes? That's kind of a given. Of course it's just my opinion.
Other game series have stuck to the same formula for decades and no-one called them old and tired.
-Assassin's Creed
-Call of Duty
-Pokemon
-StarCraft
Off the top of my head, all of these series have been accused of sticking to formula too much. That some series escape such accusations doesn't invalidate those who have been accused. And in the space of C: V to Zero, I remember a complaint forming that the RE series was starting to feel rote.
More importantly, RE3 and CV were developed at exactly the same time and were only released a year apart so if you love RE3, there's absolutely no reason you can't think the same about CV.
There's no reason I "can't" think the same. I can think of just about anything. I can certainly "think" that C: V is as good as RE3, I just don't agree.
Just because you don't like as much doesn't necessarily mean it's not good as RE3.
Which is just down to opinion. It's my opinion that RE3 is better than C: V. Doesn't change that it's just opinion.
It's more because it was released on the Dreamcast that it got didn't get as much praise as RE3, in my opinion. It didn't get the same exposure at the time so a lot of people don't have the same nostalgia for it.
It later got released on the PS2 as well, which got the definitive edition in Code: Veronica X. The PS2 is one of the bestselling consoles of all time, and of course, a sequel to the PS1.
C: V got plenty of exposure.
Also, I'm not sure if RE3 got more praise than C: V. I think now, most people seem to hold RE3 in higher regard than C: V, but at the time, most people were pretty hyped. Off the top of my head, I'm reminded of Majora's Mask, only in reverse, where it took awhile for it to become a favourite in the Legend of Zelda series. In contrast, I've generally found that C: V seems to have fallen out of favour over time. Difference being that I never personally held it that high to begin worth. Enjoyable overall, sure, but with RE2/3 preceeding it, and Remake coming after it...yeah.