Kenbo Slice said:
Yeah horror movies aren't what they used to be. I have the same feelings as you for PA, I saw it in theaters and at the end I was like "What the hell did I just watch?" Hell even I could've made that same exact movie. The most recent American horror movie I enjoyed was Dead Silence, of course it wasn't the best horror movie ever, but it had some pretty creepy parts.
The guy above me is right, asian horror is the best. I just watched Audition the other day, damn...that was intense.
See, I love Asian horror, but I don't find it to be scary at all, just good. Audition wasn't scary, though intense is definitely a good word to use for it.
And I really liked PA, mainly because it followed several of the premises set up by Asian and horror: focus on the character's relationships relative to the events, don't show much, give false leads (be it in dialogue or music) so that you don't know if a build-up is going to give you something (I find this to be the most important, if every build-up leads to a payoff, you expect one, if they don't you can't properly prepare). As for "I could've made that exact same movie," yeah, anyone could have, it was a really simple film, but no one else did. It's nice to see someone playing around with the genre and trying things out, even if looking back on it, it looks really simple and obvious.
EDIE: Forgot to include my take on the genre. Yeah, nothing is scary anymore. I don't find old ones scary either, but at least they had a psychological aspect, a lot of the ones today are just mindless. That being said, I still really enjoy them, just for a different set of reasons. Along with East Asia, the Brits seem to handle the genre pretty well.