Should muslim women remove their veil in stores?

Recommended Videos

Billybarbara

New member
Jan 11, 2009
69
0
0
well I have to take my hud down when I go into a shop and I know its a religon but its still the same princeiple
 

cuddly_tomato

New member
Nov 12, 2008
3,404
0
0
Eclectic Dreck said:
cuddly_tomato said:
J-Man said:
I find bherkas (is that how its spelt?) an infringement on human liberties, and certainly one of the most sexist things around today. Women are forced by law to wear them in most ME countries (Iran, Saudia Arabia etc), and as more egalitarianist western countries, we should condemn their use.
Here in the UK, girls are are forced by law to wear skirts no matter how cold it is outside and no matter how creepy their teachers are.

But there is a difference isn't there, this is jolly ole' England, and thus above reproach. Johnny Foreigner can take his customs and culture and F*** off.

*rolls eyes*
Condemning someone for their cultural differences is fairly silly. I don't agree with the laws and conventions of many places but I also know that such things exist for a reason. People often fail to grasp the fact that people from other places have a different outlook on life. In the US we don't even blink when someone trashes the pope, badmouths the president and draws caricatures of famous historical figures. In other places, such ideas are so alien that we seem like the evil savages.
That was my point. :) I was being sarcastic with my "above reproach" comment.

Wouldukindly said:
A very good point, I am also a fan of secular government, but my problem is with this belief that religion is so dangerous that it must be sealed up and repressed. I'm an atheist, but I completely disagree with this as being inhuman rather then helpful to society. What I'm saying is that people can walk around outside, practicing their faith, and not end up going on a 'death to everyone who doesn't believe what I believe' rant.
Glad there are some reasonable atheists about. I find people trying to shove religion down my throats as abhorrent as people ordering me not to believe in something, or labelling me "mentally ill" if I do. Atheism has now reached the stage where it has almost become an organised religion in itself, and seeks to usurp other religions and replace them with it's own because it "is the only truth"....

Oh how ironic.
 

Lyiat

New member
Dec 10, 2008
405
0
0
Abedeus said:
Fronken said:
In not rascist, i just think its stupid as hell.
Sorry, you are. If you say a religion is stupid as hell (or any part of it) you are an intolerant racist.
Actually, he's not. He just hates the religion in and of itself. Doesn't mean he hates middle-eastern people. He's a religioniest... Oh, whatever. ><; Raciest would be hating someone on account of race, not religion. You can still be white and be Muslim, after all.

That said, every religion, belief, and, yes, race has their own stupid custom. Either we deal with it, or make everyone act universally the same. Which sounds better?

"Anyone who trades liberty for security deserves neither liberty nor security. "
~ Ben Franklin
 

Jandau

Smug Platypus
Dec 19, 2008
5,034
0
0
hypothetical fact said:
http://www.news.com.au/business/story/0,27753,24916230-5017672,00.html
I find it appropriate for muslim women to remove their veils as they enter the store and put them back on when they leave.
The veil isn't a fashion statement, it's a piece clothing proscribed by their faith. So no, they shouldn't have to remove it. If they have to remove their veils, YOU should have to strip naked to prove you aren't concealing a weapon, since that would be a security risk as well...

Seriously, how do people come up with this stuff...
 

cuddly_tomato

New member
Nov 12, 2008
3,404
0
0
Codgo said:
cuddly_tomato said:
Atheism has now reached the stage where it has almost become an organised religion in itself, and seeks to usurp other religions and replace them with it's own because it "is the only truth"....

Oh how ironic.
No, not really. Bigots with faith just like to put people into little boxes like that.
Of course there is...

"This is the revolution and the evolution beyond the plague,
open your eyes and march into the future,
stand tall on this new ground,
a place purged of ancient ritual and dogma,
this is the Atheist Empire."

http://www.atheistempire.com/

Incidentally, I never said all atheists. In fact that post specifically cited the fundamentalist atheist as being different from the reasonable atheist. Anyone who is intolerant of anothers beliefs is a bigot, not someone who simply doesn't want their own beliefs to be ridiculed or prejudiced by others.

Also - quoting one small part of a post to make it sound different than what it originally said is bad form.
 

cobra_ky

New member
Nov 20, 2008
1,643
0
0
SirSchmoopy said:
Sorry but if my Religion was to carry a butcher knife with me everywhere I go, I would understand if department stores told me I had to leave it before I came in.

The one who is being intolerant is when people think that there Religion out rules everyone else. The department stores have a policy about hiding peoples faces. It's not a "bogus" policy, it's perfectly reasonable and you can't just cry about it if it conflicts with your religion.


So if you want to participate in a society that accepts multiple religions and backgrounds then you have to also be prepared to accept other peoples rules. If you don't like it, don't shop at stores where this policy is in effect.
again, many Sikhs carry knives around all the time.

what happens when it's EVERY store's policy? you can't shop anywhere without sacrificing your religious beliefs. this is a silly argument anyway, since you can easily enforce the policy while still respecting religious belief.
 

J-Man

New member
Nov 2, 2008
591
0
0
cuddly_tomato said:
J-Man said:
I find bherkas (is that how its spelt?) an infringement on human liberties, and certainly one of the most sexist things around today. Women are forced by law to wear them in most ME countries (Iran, Saudia Arabia etc), and as more egalitarianist western countries, we should condemn their use.
Here in the UK, girls are are forced by law to wear skirts no matter how cold it is outside and no matter how creepy their teachers are.

But there is a difference isn't there, this is jolly ole' England, and thus above reproach. Johnny Foreigner can take his customs and culture and F*** off.

*rolls eyes*
Incorrect. By law state schools cannot enforce an uniform. If you go to a private school you accept the conditions.
 

Jandau

Smug Platypus
Dec 19, 2008
5,034
0
0
Mazty said:
Jandau said:
The veil isn't a fashion statement, it's a piece clothing proscribed by their faith. So no, they shouldn't have to remove it. If they have to remove their veils, YOU should have to strip naked to prove you aren't concealing a weapon, since that would be a security risk as well...
Actually doesn't that mean they should strip down to the buff as well? =S
I think what you mean is if they have to remove their veils, other people shouldn't be allowed to wear similar clothing.
Oh wait, we're not allowed to wear hoodies in shops. It's only fair/just/right if they abide by the rules everyone else is adhering to. When you start making exceptions, that's when racism and bigotry begin.
The difference is, your hoodie is your fashion choice. Is there any overriding reason for you to NEED to wear a hood over your head?

Well, to them the IS an important overriding reason why they have to wear the veil. I don't see WHY in the world would you force people into such a position over a VEIL...

But I guess I have too much common sense...
 

CrafterMan

New member
Aug 3, 2008
920
0
0
Dele said:
Not just muslim women, all women and male alike. Delusional fantasies should be no excuse for security..


Tattaglia said:
No. It's their religion. Deal with it.
No it's not. It's a branch of Islam and the whole "book says you gotta wear veil" is a highly controversial part of Koran. Besides it is also part of Christianity and Judaism to kill people and do deeds that are illegal by modern standards, so why should one religion be prefered over another?
Thankyou! I was waiting for the rebuttal for that.
 

roblikestoskate

New member
Oct 16, 2008
262
0
0
a muslim woman should not be forced to remove her veil when entering the store, but the store should be allowed to set and enforce policies that satisfy their security needs and deny service to customers not willing to comply with those policies. This way, both parties get to exercise their freedom and in the worst case, the woman simply chooses not to shop there.

by handling it this way, businesses are presented with a financial incentive to rethink and innovate towards security practices and policies that accomodate the muslim veil.
 

LewsTherin

New member
Jun 22, 2008
2,443
0
0
This is silly. Wouldn't it be EASIER to pick someone out of a crowd if they are stealing something while wearing full hijab?

+1 to ignorance and intolerance.