Looking back over this thread, it seems obvious that everyone has a few seemingly shallow reasons to hate games (or anything), and everyone hates some of other peoples shallow reasons for hating things, and also everyone hates other peoples just-as-shallow-reasons for NOT hating things and defending them. It's chaos, chaos is what it is, and I'll jump right in.
- It never occured to me that you could hate the Paladin class because they are religious, but now that some people mentioned it (and thought it was stupid), I can see the reasoning behind this. Everyone brings in their preferences and dislikes into games, and especially so when it is an RPG. Defend Paladins on this all you want, chances are that other people have RPG experiences that are not only unlike yours, but that you would also be unable to duplicate. To further add to the confusion, I personally always enjoyed being a Paladin, because I enjoy being the morally superior knight in shining armor. But this only works within the framework of games (so far), where morally incontestable choices mostly exist, not because they are realistic, but because they can be fun. In such a world, I see the devotion that a Paladin has to his God as an original strength of his character, rather than being derived from religion. In real life, my reasoning would likely be the exact opposite, and I'd interpret a too strong sense of religious righteousness as a personal weakness, only pretending to be a strength.
- I can relate to the problems that some people have with FF IX. Personally, I am racist towards Freya, for no other reason that that she is a humanoid rat. This might actually have been intended by the developers, since the human aggressors in this game hate them too and slaughter them for it, and I see what you did there and all, but I can't get over it. Freya is a fucking rat, and having to play as her and being forced to have her in my party, actively takes away from my enjoyment of the game.
- Also in FF IX, I can't stand Zidane. This is even more of a problem, since he is the main character of the game, or let's say he is as main as it gets. He is a cheeky little bastard, and I can't stand the way he aggressively flirts with the Princess, and in fact every girl he encounters. I assume that if the game came out today, this would be a somewhat bigger problem with many people, so maybe I am not so shallow. In any case, I can't relate to him at all.
- I enjoyed Wind Waker a lot, but my cousin refuses to even test it out, because he doesn't like the art style. This used to infuriate me, but I have since come to accept his opinion as valid. If graphics and especially art style didn't matter at all, then we might as well play the game even though the textures failed to load. Graphics and art style, like music, make for a lot of the atmosphere of a game. Like a painting, a game can be appealing or repelling based on its visuals alone, before story or gameplay have any say in the matter. If you look at it and don't like it, that is all the (good) reason you need to deny it your time and your money.
Nowadays, I dismiss FF based on its art style alone. It is everything I hate about japanese popculture, and I fully agree with another user on here who called the japanese out on growing up not into adults, but big repressed children. The amount of angst in their stories and characters, it's insufferable.