Yes they are. (Kidding!)
In all seriousness, I agree that people should not consider themselves to be superior to another for any reason, but I have some comments to make regarding your post.
C2Ultima said:
If you honestly think that you are superior to someone because they don't like the same things you do, you are truly pathetic, and have no business forcing your opinions on other people as if they were objective facts.
I'm gonna have to call bullshit there. There is nothing, I repeat, NOTHING that forfeits someone's right to express their opinion, no matter how biased, arrogant, or elitist that opinion may be. Freedom of speech brings with it the freedom to express the opinion, "I am better than you for whatever arbitrary reason I decide," as dickish as that opinion might be. Now, that attitude may forfeit the CREDIBILITY of their opinion, but that freedom is theirs nonetheless.
C2Ultima said:
That's like arguing that people who like ball point pens are superior to people who like mechanical pencils. It makes no sense.
While a person's choice of writing implement doesn't grant that person any kind of superiority either way, mechanical pencils themselves are infinitely superior to ball point pens. That's just objective truth.
C2Ultima said:
In fact, this doesn't just happen with Skyrim, this happens with a lot of other games as well.
And here's where I may seem to contradict what I said in the beginning, so just bear with me.
Some games require more critical thinking and intelligence to play than others. As a general rule, RPGs like Skyrim require more critical intelligence to play than FPSs like Call of Duty. Not that this makes Call of Duty BAD; it just makes it a game that revolves more around reaction time and physical reflexes, as opposed to higher order thinking.
Also, some people are just more intelligent than others. Therefore, there is such a thing as "intellectual superiority." That's just a fact. And, in the end, I'd be willing to bet that people with higher intelligence are more drawn to games like Skyrim.
While liking Skyrim and disliking Call of Duty doesn't in and of itself create an inherent superiority, there is some manner of truth to calling Skyrim the "smarter" game, or the "smart man's game" when compared to Call of Duty.
Don't get me wrong, anyone who goes around pompously flaunting their superiority is an asshat. At the same time, I think that there may be at least a kernel of truth to the idea that Skyrim's fanbase may have a greater percentage of intellectually superior players.