Not fanboy:
Sony had the best presentation. I'll explain later.
A friend of mine has said:
stillkillbilly3: playstation has won me
Microsoft had the second best. Would have been better if some of the exclusives had some weight to them. Alan Wake was the most impressive to me there. Halo ODST seemed like it lacked sound as a whole. Some other things were neat. The webcam they showed was neat, but a bit too geared towards a casual player.
Nintendo has the worst. It was just boring. Awful. Bad. The two new marios and the metroid are the only things that interest me. I'm interested more in Nintendo products than Microsoft products, but this is only because I'm not a fan of the series available on Microsoft. However, if I were, I would be excited for the lineup of games coming out for the 360.
Fanboy:
Sony's conference was the best by leaps and bounds. The very start was great, showing off Uncharted 2 and MAG, both of which made me go from "Yay" to "HOLY CRAP!" I'm indifferent to the PSP stuff, although it has convinced me to get a PSP Go. Don't really care about the PS2, that was more of a "10 year life span, like we said" thing, which seems to be right.
The FF14 was a huge announce, but I was let down by it being online. However, I think it will be my first console MMO.
The camera stuff was neat. It was a mix of unscripted and scripted. It was purely a tech demo, and an impressive one at that. They were not trying to overly wow us with presentations of things that are one or two time plays, they showed actual application of these things in real game settings.
The thing that sold me on it wasn't the fact that it exists ~ Microsoft has something kind of similar. It was the fact that they didn't show anything other than what actually existed. It didn't seem like an empty promise of some tech that mothers would use but instead something that I, a gamer, would really enjoy doing.
The unrehearsed nature of the demo made it seem more like how it would actually be if you used it, and that made it very, very appealing to me because it didn't seem out of the place. Above anything else, I could see myself holding those goofy looking wands and swinging a sword around, or playing an RTS.
What about that racing game where you create your own stuff? That was awesome stuff!
GT5 was a pretty moot point. Great, it's coming. I'm excited for it. When is it coming? GoW3 was impressive and a general release date is neat.
Overall, I was impressed more with what Sony offered than anything else. My inner fanboy was going insane during the entire presentation. The main thing, though, is that I felt PUMPED to go play a Playstation game and go buy a Sony product. Both Microsoft and Nintendo didn't really get that for me.
That's not a good thing for them, I mean, they want me to buy their products, but I'm fine with where I'm at now anyway. I feel no buyers remorse and I'm actually proud to be an early PS3 adopter.
Is that a good summary of how I felt about the presentation?