The "Report" Button and You (UPDATED 8/6/09)

Recommended Videos

ChromeAlchemist

New member
Aug 21, 2008
5,865
0
0
NoMoreSanity said:
ChromeAlchemist said:
NoMoreSanity said:
Pretty good guide, though I never understood what was so bad about "this" posts.
Like everyone says, it adds nothing to the discussion. Adding nothing to the discussion can cause it to degenerate. It's great that you agree, but perhaps add something to it, like why, or something similar. The tech team and mods agree.
But what if there's nothing really to add? I mean, I see people getting probations for "this" and I think that's just a little over-board. I mean saying this on every post isn't right, but no one does that, and doing it every once in a while shouldn't be punished.
Oh I understand sometimes there is nothing to add, but really if there is truly nothing you have to say, then I'm afraid perhaps you shouldn't post. Probations are really to warn them not to do it next time. At times I see it almost on par with lol posts.

Oh, and you know how the mods are with meme-esque posts, they don't like em.
 

Dorian

New member
Jan 16, 2009
5,712
0
0
Dear lord! That megapenguinx guy is a horrible user!

We need to ban him!

Good summery. Now I know what to do with the report profile button!
 

DigitalSushi

a gallardo? fine, I'll take it.
Dec 24, 2008
5,718
0
0
the thread is amazing, I actually laughed out loud, excellent explanation with funny pics, can't go wrong. This thread is what 4chan would be like if it grew up and got a fucking job.

Also, Alex P let slip to Max that posts aren't flagged up until "two" separate reports are made, so click like a furious being of furiousness like a fury filled crazy internet superhero when you see idiots that make you furious.

Probably changed since then, what with all the rookie Red Guards on the site, who may I say are doing an excellent job! *salutes LaCoil*
 

NotAPie

New member
Jan 19, 2009
2,095
0
0
Now I Know!
waiting for someone to finish it...
ugh fine.
We needed something like this for a long time.
 

megapenguinx

New member
Jan 8, 2009
3,865
0
0
xmetatr0nx said:
Well there is apparently an ignore feature now, can someone tell exactly how thats supposed to work? Also great guide dealy, you could have used a better picture for your troll though, :).
Ha, well I needed an example that wouldn't bash a specific user (even if they are a troll).
I'll need to get a few more things in there so you'll see a bit more of megapenguin-troll.

ColdStorage said:
the thread is amazing, I actually laughed out loud, excellent explanation with funny pics, can't go wrong. This thread is what 4chan would be like if it grew up and got a fucking job.
Funny you should say that considering my history. Although I recently jumped my ban over there and am back to my old ways on that site.
 

DazZ.

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2009
5,542
0
41
For an informational bit, I rather enjoyed that.

Reported so the mods can see how useful it is.
(That is how it works yeah?)
 

Frank_Sinatra_

Digs Giant Robots
Dec 30, 2008
2,306
0
0
3.141592654 said:
Perhaps it's the depression bringing out the cynic in me, but how far gone is this community if we need to point out what I define as common sense?

Edit: Look, I'm not dismissing this thread, I just think it shouldn't have been necessary in the first place.

The moderators say that not enough posts are being reported, so this guide might actually be useful.
Glefistus said:
Report button seemed kind of obvious in its use to me...
But people don't use the button enough. If people would just ignore trolls/potential flame threads and hit the report buttons they would go away faster. (If that made any sense)
Regarding one word posts. People please stop using them, I know you have brains in there and I know you can use them to make better opinions than "THIS."
 

megapenguinx

New member
Jan 8, 2009
3,865
0
0
D4zZ said:
For an informational bit, I rather enjoyed that.

Reported so the mods can see how useful it is.
(That is how it works yeah?)
Not exactly, but I did PM a few of them to show them the thread. I don't know if it's sticky worthy yet though (a few of you seem to think it is) because I think it might be missing something. So if it is, don't be shy to tell me.
 

similar.squirrel

New member
Mar 28, 2009
6,021
0
0
Don't think I've ever used the report button.
Perhaps I'm too nice.
Or I prefer to berate the offender via text. Which probably on exacerbates matters.

Edit: Waaait..You're just trying to get accepted into the ranks of the moderators, so you can quaff expensive prostitutes and make love to fine champagne for the rest of your life, aren't you?>,>
 

megapenguinx

New member
Jan 8, 2009
3,865
0
0
samaritan.squirrel said:
Edit: Waaait..You're just trying to get accepted into the ranks of the moderators, so you can quaff expensive prostitutes and make love to fine champagne for the rest of your life, aren't you?>,>
Ah if only that were true. But no I've been wanting to make a thread for a long time and I have a strange love for the report button. Plus no one seems to have covered the subject before.
 

Zombie_Fish

Opiner of Mottos
Mar 20, 2009
4,584
0
0
Couple other things you may want to mention:

It takes multiple reports to send a post off to a moderator. This is to help prevent accidental reports.
Whilst being anonymous to the mods, the system records who reports what so if you hit the report button twice for the same post, only one report will be recorded. This is to stop people just hitting the report button, refreshing and hitting it again to get the post sent off.
You can also report groups like you can users.

megapenguinx said:
Plus no one seems to have covered the subject before.
Kuliani made a thread all about it and posted it on every sub-forum on this site. It was stickied for a week before being taken down and deleted (I guess they just decided that a week was enough time to educate people about the report button).
 

Avatar Roku

New member
Jul 9, 2008
6,169
0
0
megapenguinx said:
[HEADING=2]Thread Necro[/HEADING]​

You come on the Escapist forums and look at the first page. Seeing nothing of interest you keep going back pages and pages until you finally find something you like. Normally this wouldn't be a problem, if the post hadn't been from last year.

The act of bringing back old threads is known as necro-ing, it's also regarded as thread spamming. Rule of thumb: if a thread hasn't been posted in in the last 30 days (one month), then don't post in it. It just puts unnecessary stress on the servers by keeping another thread alive beyond it's point of usefulness. Bumping your own thread is also an offense punishable by ban. So remember to always check the date before posting!
This one confused me. I thought Necroing was only really looked down upon on Warcry. Here, I thought the policy was Necroing is preferable to making a Repeat Thread, but only so long as you added to the discussion.
 

Zombie_Fish

Opiner of Mottos
Mar 20, 2009
4,584
0
0
orannis62 said:
This one confused me. I thought Necroing was only really looked down upon on Warcry. Here, I thought the policy was Necroing is prefereable to making a Repeat Thread, but only so long as you added to the discussion.
According to the forum guidelines, if the last post on a thread is a month or older, then make a new thread. Otherwise, as long as it adds discussion and the topic is still relevent to the times, then thread necroing is supported.
 

megapenguinx

New member
Jan 8, 2009
3,865
0
0
Zombie_Fish said:
Couple other things you may want to mention:

It takes multiple reports to send a post off to a moderator. This is to help prevent accidental reports.
Whilst being anonymous to the mods, the system records who reports what so if you hit the report button twice for the same post, only one report will be recorded. This is to stop people just hitting the report button, refreshing and hitting it again to get the post sent off.
You can also report groups like you can users.

megapenguinx said:
Plus no one seems to have covered the subject before.
Kuliani made a thread all about it and posted it on every sub-forum on this site. It was stickied for a week before being taken down and deleted (I guess they just decided that a week was enough time to educate people about the report button).
I saw that and actually drew some inspiration from it, along with Krunk's thread.
Problem is very few people saw it and with it being gone and with a flux in new members I figured a new thread on the topic was in order. One from the perspective of a user. I'm still debating adding in the 2 report thing since it might discourage people into thinking that their report won't matter. As for the groups, good point out, looks like I'll be messing around with the Twitter group in a bit.

orannis62 said:
This one confused me. I thought Necroing was only really looked down upon on Warcry. Here, I thought the policy was Necroing is preferable to making a Repeat Thread, but only so long as you added to the discussion.
It's not very welcome by the staff because it puts strain on the servers and prevent older threads from being systematically deleted. The guidelines read:
Kuliani said:
Thread Necroing and Thread Duping: We know that our forums have a very high volume of traffic and sometimes you will end up wanting to talk about subjects that are being discussed elsewhere on the forums. To keep thread spam to a minimum, we ask that you try not to start threads in the same board on exactly the same topic as another thread that's already active that day. We reserve the right to combine, merge, or delete redundant threads where we see this happen. We will ban for thread spamming in a persistent, abusive, or exploitative manner.

If you want to have a discussion on a topic that's been the subject of a past thread, you should generally join in that thread if it's a live discussion. If that thread has been inactive for a month or more, its good etiquette to start a new thread and link to the old thread if you want to provide it as background information, and we discourage arbitrary bumping. We will ban for thread bumping if and when it is conducted in a persistent, abusive, or exploitative manner.
 

CptCamoPants

New member
Jan 3, 2009
198
0
0
megapenguinx said:
[HEADING=2]Polls[/HEADING]​

I love being a statistic as much as the next guy, but most of the time polls aren't implemented correctly. Polls should be unbiased and should not include pointless options. Also if you use a poll, there is no need to include "Poll" in your title as it's added immediately. If you see a thread with an unbiased poll, you can bet that the thread itself will be unbiased and it's best to report the thread starter for abusing the poll option.
Could you explain the last sentence, please?
 

megapenguinx

New member
Jan 8, 2009
3,865
0
0
CptCamoPants said:
megapenguinx said:
[HEADING=2]Polls[/HEADING]​

I love being a statistic as much as the next guy, but most of the time polls aren't implemented correctly. Polls should be unbiased and should not include pointless options. Also if you use a poll, there is no need to include "Poll" in your title as it's added immediately. If you see a thread with an unbiased poll, you can bet that the thread itself will be unbiased and it's best to report the thread starter for abusing the poll option.
Could you explain the last sentence, please?
Wow sorry about that, it should be biased poll. I should never work tired, thanks for pointing it out and I'll edit it.
 

teisjm

New member
Mar 3, 2009
3,561
0
0
megapenguinx said:
[HEADING=1]A Guide To The Report Button[/HEADING]​

...
[HEADING=2]Thread Necro[/HEADING]​
You come on the Escapist forums and look at the first page. Seeing nothing of interest you keep going back pages and pages until you finally find something you like. Normally this wouldn't be a problem, if the post hadn't been from last year.

The act of bringing back old threads is known as necro-ing, it's also regarded as thread spamming. Rule of thumb: if a thread hasn't been posted in in the last 30 days (one month), then don't post in it. It just puts unnecessary stress on the servers by keeping another thread alive beyond it's point of usefulness. Bumping your own thread is also an offense punishable by ban. So remember to always check the date before posting!

[HEADING=2]Repeat Threads[/HEADING]​
When a huge news story breaks, we all want a bit of the glory that comes with being the first to bring major news to the Escapist. That being said, you should always check to see if someone else beat you to it. Another thing that happens is sometimes we want to post a thread, but can't really think of anything to post about. That's when we end up with repeats:

Before making new thread you should always search for a little bit to make sure it hasn't been done in the past month. Now I know that the search bar on this site is terrible, and the tech team is always working on improving it. For now here's a trick you can use: Go to google, type in the keywords of your thread followed by the word "escapist". If your thread doesn't pop up in the first 3 pages, consider yourself in the clear. I mean talking about the same thing over and over isn't the most exciting thing in the world right? Take note: If you repost a thread you made earlier because it didn't get replies you will be moderated. If someone thinks your topic is interesting, they will contribute. No need to make a new one to add to the clutter.

...
I'm a little confused now, aren't people supposed to necro threads instead of reposting them? otherwise you might as well say: "If we've talked about it before, and not in the past month don't ever talk about it again, try and you'll get suspended/probatet for necroing or repeating"

Is it just me or does this seen weird, IMO you should add whatever you haev to say to a thread, even if it's old. There might be a hwole bunch of people who didn't notice the thread while it was active who would like a chance to see it and migth have things to say as well.
 

Kuchinawa212

New member
Apr 23, 2009
5,408
0
0
Thanks man, I'll use the report button now. I was always afraid I'd report for the wrong reason I'd get banned instead