The War Z releases. Receives immediate hate and accusations of fraud.

Recommended Videos

Ethan Bewley

New member
Jun 25, 2012
15
0
0
honestly, I thought that WarZ was the standalone version of DayZ I've heard so much about. Seems like too much of a coincidence that these games are so similar and that they came out fairly close together.
We can all just wait for the standalone of DayZ to get our Zombie mumorpuguh fixings.
 

BloatedGuppy

New member
Feb 3, 2010
9,572
0
0
Watched TB's video of the game play. Wow. That's...quite something.

I was pretty intrigued by Day Z in spite of its many well articulated failings, being a rough hewn mod, and despite really enjoying video footage of it decided to give it a pass until it was a little more polished. This makes Day Z look like a AAA blockbuster polished to a mirror sheen.

Shady, shady, shady business selling this for money, let alone asking for microtransactions. The developers should be ashamed.
 

Darks63

New member
Mar 8, 2010
1,562
0
0
Tohuvabohu said:
Sepko said:
I've been doing some digging into this myself. This does not look good.

Just a cursory glance through the steam forums shows a massive amount of complaints - plus a chosen few defending the game. (This alone is not unusual in the steam forums.)

But unlike the usual steam forum shitstorm in which a few very loud people rage about absolutely nothing, these complaints are serious. Something is incredibly wrong here. Like, disastrously wrong.

And now TB just recently put up a video about it if you want to see how bad it truly is for yourself:


40 whole minutes. The video is full of embarrassing visual and gameplay bugs. Here's a few quotes that sums the vid up.

"Everything I see is nothing short of shockingly bad."
"The game is clearly not 'finished', if it is, it's one of the worst games I've ever played."
"Astonishingly boring."

There's microtransactions in this game. You can buy items that can only be used once, you lose them when you die, the game spawns you into servers in one spot, with dozens of other people at the same time who all kill each other upon spawning, and the game is full of spawn-camping and apparently already awash with aimbotters.

^And this is a top seller on steam, folks!
Somewhat off topic have to thank you for this vid looks like you netted tb another sub:)

OT: As soon as i saw it was a mmo i ran the other way so i luckily didnt get ripped off
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
I don;t really see how Steam is to blame for this... I mean sure WarZ is a bad game and they lied about it and should be ashamed... but really I don;t see how this pertains to steam... from what I understand they don;t really push a release date or anything... and it's not really their job to test the game before it's put out, other than yes, it actually functions on some level... and it's not like steam hasn;t put out bad or unfinished games before... and usually for more... so I don;t see how this is anyone else's fault than the devs...
 

ohnoitsabear

New member
Feb 15, 2011
1,236
0
0
Sacman said:
I don;t really see how Steam is to blame for this... I mean sure WarZ is a bad game and they lied about it and should be ashamed... but really I don;t see how this pertains to steam... from what I understand they don;t really push a release date or anything... and it's not really their job to test the game before it's put out, other than yes, it actually functions on some level... and it's not like steam hasn;t put out bad or unfinished games before... and usually for more... so I don;t see how this is anyone else's fault than the devs...
The problem isn't that War Z is shit. The problem is that the steam store page advertised many features for the game that weren't in the game, and Valve did absolutely nothing to try to verify that the steam store page accurately described the game. Because Valve does approve every game that goes on Steam, and because it is an advertisement on their store for a product that they're selling, they are partially, if not wholly responsible for anything on the store page for a game.

Plus, there's the whole issue of something like this being allowed on Steam, but other, good games like Space Pirates and Zombies being denied for unknown reasons. It really raises a lot of questions about the approval process for games, which is a mystery to everybody outside of Valve. It would be very nice, both for developers and consumers, to know what standards a game has to meet to be allowed on Steam, and to have some transparency in the approval process.
 

InsanityRequiem

New member
Nov 9, 2009
700
0
0
Sacman said:
I don;t really see how Steam is to blame for this... I mean sure WarZ is a bad game and they lied about it and should be ashamed... but really I don;t see how this pertains to steam... from what I understand they don;t really push a release date or anything... and it's not really their job to test the game before it's put out, other than yes, it actually functions on some level... and it's not like steam hasn;t put out bad or unfinished games before... and usually for more... so I don;t see how this is anyone else's fault than the devs...
Compare it to the iOS store and Apple. For a game(buy or free to play) to be placed on the iOS store, Apple goes through each and every possible listing to make sure it works/completed, has all the features that the game makers says it has, and that there is nothing inappropriate/against Apple policy in said game. War Z is an unfinished, bug-ridden mess of a game without even half of what the description says it has(which is blatant false advertisement, and that's a crime), and the game makers are actively banning and blacklisting the buyers who are lodging formal complaints against the game. Valve(Since Steam belongs to them) did absolutely no quality control, just uploading the game straight away since the game makers has a game already on the Steam service.

When Apple is doing a better job at quality control than your service, you're doing something wrong. And I am currently using an Apple computer!
 

Rednog

New member
Nov 3, 2008
3,567
0
0
Sacman said:
I don;t really see how Steam is to blame for this... I mean sure WarZ is a bad game and they lied about it and should be ashamed... but really I don;t see how this pertains to steam... from what I understand they don;t really push a release date or anything... and it's not really their job to test the game before it's put out, other than yes, it actually functions on some level... and it's not like steam hasn;t put out bad or unfinished games before... and usually for more... so I don;t see how this is anyone else's fault than the devs...
Steam gets flack for it because their policy is generally one of "once we have your money it's not our problem anymore". And steam actually has allowed publishers to release games that didn't work at all, see Rage on release, or Dead Island not being able to launch at all for some people, I forget the name but there was multiplayer only game on steam that had no access to server for like a month or two after release. Hell there are games on steam that don't even work well with the steam interface/overlay and you have to find a community workaround to launch it outside steam (Far Cry 1, some Tom Clancy Games). And in cases like these steam should offer refunds because when people complain developers just shrug their shoulders and say "sorry it's out of our hands, steam controls it".
If I go into a retail store and I buy an item I'm allowed to return it or if I feel that the information on the box was misleading. And it's also sad that the biggest digital distributor gets so much praise/cash when it's competition like gog or Desura actually do take it upon themselves to make sure that the products they distribute actually work. Considering they take a 30% cut of the profits they really should be doing more.
 

Smolderin

New member
Feb 5, 2012
448
0
0
Woo wee...what a crap storm this has turned out to be eh? From what I have heard so far, this game doesn't have chance in hell with all the bad press it's been receiving. The steam forums, reddit, and even Youtube is all fired up over this game and I can see why. Here is to hoping Valve learns something from this entire ordeal and actually checks the game before putting it up on sale...or at least learns that their consumer base aren't idiots who can't tell what a bad game is.
 

Nieroshai

New member
Aug 20, 2009
2,940
0
0
Bertylicious said:
Rastien said:
My wig... this really is appauling!

They should go work for EA they would be welcomed with open arms for the cash haul on this steaming heap of dog turd!

Check List:
Unfinished Game being sold as complete (more like beta)
Lying about content on the steam page (1 up on peter monoleux)
Free to play model using a £15 entry fee
Fake 'screen shots' used to sell the game

Welcome aboard EA go make us some money fine sirs.


I played Day Z abit and i actually liked the looks of this game, glad to hear i didn't buy it. The promises made about this game are a work of fiction at best and plain downright fraudulent at worst.
What DID Petey Molyneux/Moloneux/Molonoxologist lie about? Everyone seems well narced off with him.
He hyped up all the Fable games by mentioning features they never had and bent the truth until it nearly snapped to sell the games. Then there's Milo, the fully interactive AI he used to demo the Kinect, that turned out to be completely scripted, and the Kinect couldn't do half the things the Milo demo showed.
 

TheRussian

New member
May 8, 2011
502
0
0
Maxtro said:
Did people really think that paying $13 was going to get them a complete and finished new game?
There are 2,226 games on Steam that are under $10.
What are you saying, that 2,226 games are incomplete and unfinished?

On the subject, I'm not surprised. Every single thing I read about this game prior to launch made me very uneasy and mistrustful.
The sad part is that people paid money for it.
 

shrimpcel

New member
Sep 5, 2011
234
0
0
Surely I am not the only one here to think that most of the players are to blame? Perhaps I can understand someone who buys a random game at the store and is disappointed by it. But these people bought it off Steam, which means that they have some sort of Internet connection and the will to use it. It only takes 5 minutes to go on Wikipedia, Youtube, IGN or Metacritic and check what's what.
 

Smolderin

New member
Feb 5, 2012
448
0
0
You know its bad when people want to start online petitions to take the game off steam.

https://www.change.org/petitions/valve-take-the-war-z-off-of-steam#share

I voted by the way. Steam really should monitor what games get put into the shop instead of seeing those blasted dollar signs all the time.
 

Something Amyss

Aswyng and Amyss
Dec 3, 2008
24,759
0
0
kman123 said:
I've noticed Steam isn't so high and mighty now, ey?
This legitimately surprised me. I was expecing a lot of defense for why Steam should have no part and "free market."
 

devotedsniper

New member
Dec 28, 2010
752
0
0
I unfortunately was stupid enough to buy this from steam without doing any research. I was bored and i saw it for £10 with all it's features listed, no where did it mention it was a beta....oh wait it isn't it's apparently a foundation release whatever that is..

It's buggy, glitchy, terrible frankenstein of a game, you don't even get say a knife to defend yourself to begin with, i brought a bat with nails on it (brought the edition that came with abit of cash) and after 20 hits the zombie was still trying to eat me.

I've asked steam for a refund since i brought it under the assumption it had all the key features which were listed (they have since changed the store description), hopefully i'll get my money back. Not to mention there very unprofessional, forum mods are deleting threads which have anything bad to say about the game, and the guy in my next links claim that it was us, the steam users who didn't read the description properly.

http://forums.thewarz.com/showthread.php?79251-Steam-purchase-page-issues

I would also like to direct you to an interview from the same guy, there is also an image of the original description for those who did not see it;

http://uk.pc.gamespy.com/pc/the-war-z/1226980p1.html

I must say i'm quite annoyed steam even let them post the original description, do they not check the games they sell?
 

dyre

New member
Mar 30, 2011
2,178
0
0
Rawne1980 said:
getoffmycloud said:
But by using your argument I can say a free to play game like tribes ascend isn't free to play because you have to buy a PC to play it.
No, that's not even the same train of though.

DayZ cannot be played without ArmA 2 because it is an ArmA 2 mod. Quite a lot of people bought ArmA 2 just to play DayZ.

Saying "well you can't play any F2P game without a PC" is way off. We're talking games and that's bringing in hardware and being slightly pedantic.
Both of you are completely off track from the original argument anyway. The poster who sparked this pointlessly heated argument claimed that
Maxtro said:
Did people really think that paying $13 was going to get them a complete and finished new game?
As the post implies, the real argument is that a developer who isn't getting paid a lot for their game isn't going to bother making a good game. Regardless of the prerequisite purchases necessary to play DayZ, the devs were just a bunch of modders, so unless they're getting part of those Arma2 sales, DayZ is in effect a game that was developed "for free"
 

chozo_hybrid

What is a man? A miserable little pile of secrets.
Jul 15, 2009
3,479
14
43
Raising the respawn time to four hours per character and then making a pay to respawn button is a fucking dick move, and for a game you do buy. If it was F2P maybe, but no way when you already put money down on it. So glad I decided to see how it was received.

As for those blaming Steam itself, they were probably mislead as well. Time will tell how this turns out. I never played DayZ, maybe I should get Arma 2 just to give it a shot.

Smolderin said:
You know its bad when people want to start online petitions to take the game off steam.

https://www.change.org/petitions/valve-take-the-war-z-off-of-steam#share

I voted by the way. Steam really should monitor what games get put into the shop instead of seeing those blasted dollar signs all the time.
To be fair, they were probably mislead as well, but we'll see how they react to it now.
 

Rastien

Pro Misinformationalist
Jun 22, 2011
1,221
0
0
Bertylicious said:
Rastien said:
My wig... this really is appauling!

They should go work for EA they would be welcomed with open arms for the cash haul on this steaming heap of dog turd!

Check List:
Unfinished Game being sold as complete (more like beta)
Lying about content on the steam page (1 up on peter monoleux)
Free to play model using a £15 entry fee
Fake 'screen shots' used to sell the game

Welcome aboard EA go make us some money fine sirs.


I played Day Z abit and i actually liked the looks of this game, glad to hear i didn't buy it. The promises made about this game are a work of fiction at best and plain downright fraudulent at worst.
What DID Petey Molyneux/Moloneux/Molonoxologist lie about? Everyone seems well narced off with him.
Basically he greatly exaggerated to flat out lied about features in his games specifically fable if you google about him a bit you will find out specifically what he said :) but yeah he has a habit of bigging up his games massively he even contacted Yahtzee in regards to... fable 2? i think? saying he believed it would be up to his high standard as mentioned in one of the videos.
 

Flippincrazy

New member
Jul 4, 2010
154
0
0
Welp, it looks like Steam ballsed this one up rather royally. It happens from time to time. In their defense thought, they were probably just as equally misled as us. Whilst the more cynical side of me criticizes the idle masses who do not read into the purchase that they are making, just as is sensible to do with any online purchase, the more sensible side agrees that the fault ultimately lies with the false advertising on the Steam store page and the trust that Steam has built up in its users.

What can Steam do about it? Hopefully, they'll learn from their mistake here. In the short term, general refunds for those who bought the game under false pretenses along with the immediate removal or at the very least editing of the War Z store page would be their best course of action. Legal action against the developers of War Z might even be a possibility, it'd be good to see such a blatant rip off of a game ground into the dirt where it belongs.

On the brighter side, the public response to this might make those in control of Steam think of introducing some form of quality control measures to ensure that the risk of this happening again is minimized.
 

Solo-Wing

Wanna have a bad time?
Dec 15, 2010
3,642
0
0
The mods seem quite retarded as well.


That message is being used for everyone that is banned appearently. And the people being banned is anybody willing to share their opinion in anyway about the game.

Also they want you to pay over-the-top amounts of money for in-game credits that you end up losing when you die, with 4 hour respawn time that they want you to pay off. Fuck. Off.

Valve needs to remove this game and refund everyone to get the PR back for steam. Also they need to crack down on Quality Control. I mean yeah there are boring indie games that are pretty ugly like Bad Rats but at least they are not Scams Nor broken. Just... Ugly really.


Hell what really worries me is that since they made this to beat Day-Z to the punch, people will be warded off from the much better game just because of this one. And the worst possible scenario: Valve refuses to let Day-Z on Steam because of War-Z.
 

Easton Dark

New member
Jan 2, 2011
2,366
0
0
Ethan Bewley said:
honestly, I thought that WarZ was the standalone version of DayZ I've heard so much about. Seems like too much of a coincidence that these games are so similar and that they came out fairly close together.
We can all just wait for the standalone of DayZ to get our Zombie mumorpuguh fixings.
Oh gosh, I feel sorry for people like you were who thought this was the DayZ standalone and bought it because of that.

Jeez they must be angry right now.

Always research your products, kids.