Eh, hard to say. Brink seems to be in the great undecided area with gamers/reviewers atm, but I personally like it quite a bit, though that really isn't a stinker. original Asscreed is kinda the same deal, but again, wasn't really a stinker.
Resident Evil 5 was a pretty good co-op action game, and I actually had some fun with it, which is more than I can say for the other RE's. FF12? FF fans seemed to hate it, but, stupid story and horrible character design aside, the combat system reminded a lot of KotOR, and seeing as that's my all time favorite game, that is not a bad thing.