Shouldn't someone be out lobbying for a change then? Not pointing any fingers for letting the poor chickens suffer.ThrobbingEgo said:This is not the extreme. This is the norm. It's not a cushy life: it's short and traumatic. This is why meat is cheap.
People do. There have been protests for decades. There's just such a demand for meat, and the agriculture lobby's huge.Cuniculus said:Shouldn't someone be out lobbying for a change then? Not pointing any fingers for letting the poor chickens suffer.ThrobbingEgo said:This is not the extreme. This is the norm. It's not a cushy life: it's short and traumatic. This is why meat is cheap.
Well then that actually makes me think, because obviously it's horrible the way you describe it... but I've seen footage of chicken farms and never even heard of this (please realize I'm not calling you a liar, just saying). The demand for meat is high? So, basically, human beings will tolerate any injustice if it fills their needs? Sounds morbid.ThrobbingEgo said:People do. There have been protests for decades. There's just such a demand for meat, and the agriculture lobby's huge.Cuniculus said:Shouldn't someone be out lobbying for a change then? Not pointing any fingers for letting the poor chickens suffer.ThrobbingEgo said:This is not the extreme. This is the norm. It's not a cushy life: it's short and traumatic. This is why meat is cheap.
Changes happen in baby steps.
It's not the most positive picture of us, no. If you have the time, look for a copy of Animal Liberation by Peter Singer, preferably the more recent second edition. I don't agree with everything the man says philosophically, but he does an accurate depiction of factory farming.Cuniculus said:Well then that actually makes me think, because obviously it's horrible the way you describe it... but I've seen footage of chicken farms and never even heard of this (please realize I'm not calling you a liar, just saying). The demand for meat is high? So, basically, human beings will tolerate any injustice if it fills their needs? Sounds morbid.ThrobbingEgo said:People do. There have been protests for decades. There's just such a demand for meat, and the agriculture lobby's huge.Cuniculus said:Shouldn't someone be out lobbying for a change then? Not pointing any fingers for letting the poor chickens suffer.ThrobbingEgo said:This is not the extreme. This is the norm. It's not a cushy life: it's short and traumatic. This is why meat is cheap.
Changes happen in baby steps.
P.S. Will be having chicken for dinner, despite their terrible treatment.
Meh, not impressed. Designed to disgust huh? Who the hell is this supposed to be against anyway? They said that you'd never even look at an ear of corn the same way again. What the hell is this supposed to accomplish? Make no one eat anything?Cheeze_Pavilion said:Heh, and then there's this:
http://www.theroot.com/views/you-ll-never-eat-chicken-mcnuggets-again
Damn you sir. Now I have to look through every last one of Oscar Wilde's works until I find this quote.Cpt. Red said:Isn't it "Quod Erat Demonstrandum"?Fondant said:You eat fish. Ergo, you are not a vegeterian. Quad Error Demonstrandum.
You just don't eat other types of meat. Eating fish precludes vegeterianism.
Thanks, but no thanks. I'm not really interested in learning about how my food is made. I know disgusting things happen, but hell. Even if the animals were treated perfectly, the farmer could just take a piss in your orange juice before he sends it out anyway.ThrobbingEgo said:It's not the most positive picture of us, no. If you have the time, look for a copy of Animal Liberation by Peter Singer, preferably the more recent second edition. I don't agree with everything the man says philosophicly, but he does an accurate depiction of factory farming.
I'm not totally against eating meat - I'm not a vegetarian - but I don't like the way the animals are treated.
Maddox fan, I take it?Cuniculus said:Thanks, but no thanks. I'm not really interested in learning about how my food is made. I know disgusting things happen, but hell. Even if the animals were treated perfectly, the farmer could just take a piss in your orange juice before he sends it out anyway.ThrobbingEgo said:It's not the most positive picture of us, no. If you have the time, look for a copy of Animal Liberation by Peter Singer, preferably the more recent second edition. I don't agree with everything the man says philosophicly, but he does an accurate depiction of factory farming.
I'm not totally against eating meat - I'm not a vegetarian - but I don't like the way the animals are treated.
On the subject of animal treatment, yeah, I can agree that they shouldn't be treated badly, but obviously it isn't changing. Even trying our best we still can't 100% stop animal cruelty. Even harvesting grain kills thousands of animals a day.
I'd disagree with it anyway, because hypocrisy only says bad things about you - not the argument. For fans of Latin, Ad Hominem Tu Quoque.Cheeze_Pavilion said:It's a Latin phrase meaning 'the things which was to be demonstrated being proven' roughly--Wilde may have been punning on it by changing 'quod' to 'quad'.Fondant said:Damn you sir. Now I have to look through every last one of Oscar Wilde's works until I find this quote.Cpt. Red said:Isn't it "Quod Erat Demonstrandum"?Fondant said:You eat fish. Ergo, you are not a vegeterian. Quad Error Demonstrandum.
You just don't eat other types of meat. Eating fish precludes vegeterianism.
I won't deny that I am indeed a fan, but I hope you'll believe me when I say that I knew the stats before reading that particular post.ThrobbingEgo said:Maddox fan, I take it?Cuniculus said:Thanks, but no thanks. I'm not really interested in learning about how my food is made. I know disgusting things happen, but hell. Even if the animals were treated perfectly, the farmer could just take a piss in your orange juice before he sends it out anyway.ThrobbingEgo said:It's not the most positive picture of us, no. If you have the time, look for a copy of Animal Liberation by Peter Singer, preferably the more recent second edition. I don't agree with everything the man says philosophicly, but he does an accurate depiction of factory farming.
I'm not totally against eating meat - I'm not a vegetarian - but I don't like the way the animals are treated.
On the subject of animal treatment, yeah, I can agree that they shouldn't be treated badly, but obviously it isn't changing. Even trying our best we still can't 100% stop animal cruelty. Even harvesting grain kills thousands of animals a day.
One could argue there's a big difference between making an animal suffer for it's entire short life, or instantly crushing it with a grain combine inadvertantly. You're not tearing off their beaks, keeping them in the dark, letting their feet fuse to the mesh of their shared, cramped cage. It's kind of a big difference.
But it's really besides the point isn't it? Just because other bad things happen, it doesn't make it any less wrong.Cuniculus said:I won't deny that I am indeed a fan, but I hope you'll believe me when I say that I knew the stats before reading that particular post.ThrobbingEgo said:Maddox fan, I take it?Cuniculus said:Thanks, but no thanks. I'm not really interested in learning about how my food is made. I know disgusting things happen, but hell. Even if the animals were treated perfectly, the farmer could just take a piss in your orange juice before he sends it out anyway.ThrobbingEgo said:It's not the most positive picture of us, no. If you have the time, look for a copy of Animal Liberation by Peter Singer, preferably the more recent second edition. I don't agree with everything the man says philosophicly, but he does an accurate depiction of factory farming.
I'm not totally against eating meat - I'm not a vegetarian - but I don't like the way the animals are treated.
On the subject of animal treatment, yeah, I can agree that they shouldn't be treated badly, but obviously it isn't changing. Even trying our best we still can't 100% stop animal cruelty. Even harvesting grain kills thousands of animals a day.
One could argue there's a big difference between making an animal suffer for it's entire short life, or instantly crushing it with a grain combine inadvertantly. You're not tearing off their beaks, keeping them in the dark, letting their feet fuse to the mesh of their shared, cramped cage. It's kind of a big difference.
In the words of other people I hate, "A life is a life."
I just said I didn't agree with it. I just said I'm not going to stop eating meat because of it. Or.. you know, do anything about it as a matter of fact. Maybe the chickens could start a union.ThrobbingEgo said:But it's really besides the point isn't it? Just because other bad things happen, it doesn't make it any less wrong.Cuniculus said:In the words of other people I hate, "A life is a life."