Black and white 2
The original has a permanent residence in my awesome game shelf. It was original and fun. Its only really bad quality was its lack of replay ability. A sequel would have had so much to offer, new miracles, new creatures, and a better skirmish mode so that the game wold be replayable.However, the second game got rid of everything good about the first game, and replaced it with concentrated pig dung. IT was a horrendously easy street planning simulator. You just placed houses, and your people would build them, and than other cities would just move to you and you won. There was no challenge and there was no charm. You could no longer control creature combat and training your creature was retardidly easy. Your armies got annihilated as soon as they left your territory, and if you were invaded, you literally shook your fist at the enemy troops and they all died. It was pathetic.
The second game sapped all of the potential out of what could have been one of the best game series of all time.