shadow skill said:
So what happens when your 360 falls outside of the three year extension? Your free repair is suddenly not so free. My own 360 just barely qualified for the extension had it failed about a month from now I would have been shit out of luck. With a good chance that the next console they send to me will fail as well. I'm supposed to be okay with this? A fundamentally flawed design which causes the product to fail by a ridiculous amount; which leads people to go through four and five units? Sending the machine back for weeks at a time instead of actually using the machine? Living with the fear that the machine will die if it is actually used?
If Microsoft was serious about addressing the flawed design of the 360 they would have recalled the product. What they did do is more like a food company leaving beef on the market that is contaminated with some bacteria the gives people mild diarrhea; offering to pay the medical bills of those afflicted instead of pulling the bad products and getting the problem fixed once and for all.
I'll keep this as short as possible. I know there's no point in arguing, and while you do make valid arguments, I just can't help but sense a slight bit of problem with the above statement. Even on this site, Microsoft put $1billion dollars into the repair of the 360's. Now, even to a successful corporation, a billion dollars is nothing to laugh at. They offer to fix the problem.
Now, if you want to make the argument that a company doesn't care, why not look at Sony as well? You don't see me being bitter that I had to PAY MONEY WHEN MY PS3 BROKE BECAUSE OF THE FIRMWARE UPDATE. Did Sony fix it for free? Hell no. I paid for it. And as a kick in my butt, I basically had to pay for my console to be fixed because of a system update. (Hehe, kind of ironic.)
But, did I say, "Sony's a terrible company and deserves to burn in the fires of the 3rd circle of hell!"? No, I didn't. I was kind of upset, but would I give up my console for that? Nope.
I'm trying to say, a console with a problem doesn't mean I'll give it up. If I did, I'd give up PC's because they got bugs, or Wii's because the controllers don't register, or my 360 and PS3 for breaking.
I will agree with you on a few points though. It sucks that Microsoft can't recall all of it's consoles, but at least they have put a large chuck of money (and refunded people who paid) towards fixed the RRoD problem. Also, since Microsoft has realized the problem, they've made the new systems more RRoD proof.
But, I think some of your other statements were rather strange. Why would I live in fear that my console would die? It's been fine. It messed up on me once and I got it fixed. If it messed up again (I doubt it), then I'll just get it fixed again. Same goes for my PS3.
Also, I've only been through two units. My first one I bought while I lived overseas, it wouldn't work in the US because of the power cords and regional stuff. My second 360 is the one I've had fixed, once. I have no fear. If it breaks, what would I do you may wonder? Probably go outside and interact with people. Or I could just play on my computer, Wii or PS3. And if my PS3 breaks while my 360's away, I'll just play Wii, or my monopoly board game.
Never live in fear. Especially of something so small and seemingly meaningless (a console).