Why Do All Girls Think They're Fat?

Recommended Videos

annoyinglizardvoice

New member
Apr 29, 2009
1,024
0
0
The media and the gewneral arseholeness of teenagers are both factors, but I believe ignorance also has some effect. A lot of the people I've heard call themselves fat don't really know what a healthy size actually is and think BMI is acurate.
If a girl I know says she's fat, my response is usually to flash my belly at her and say something like "you're not carrying one of those, therefore you're not fat". It seems to work (people will gain a healthier and more reallistic view of themselves just to avoid havig to see my belly again :) ).
 

MelodyMan

New member
Jan 2, 2009
54
0
0
quiet_samurai said:
Because they want you to tell them they're not. It's either for self serving reasons, getting attention, or fishing for a compliment. Tell them they're not, unless you want to start a fight or something, or if they deserve it.
fish for a complement and you'll catch a shark
 

Blow_Pop

Supreme Evil Overlord
Jan 21, 2009
4,863
0
0
LassLisa said:
Well, I thought I was fat for the better part of a decade because women in magazines have no flab. None. No cellulite, no pooch, no hint of a love handle. So, even if I'm skinny when I look in the mirror, I must still have weight to lose because my skin hangs a bit loose and flabby in some places. It didn't help that my mother (two sizes smaller than me) was almost constantly on a diet. Notice that, if you listen to the media, all women everywhere are on diets or "watching what they eat"; this means that girls who aren't are going to be very quiet so they don't stand out. And they're going to think this means they're 'weird'... so even if they love their bodies just like they are, hell, you can't just SAY that! If I say that I love my body, I'm afraid someone else (who doesn't think you're allowed to like your body unless you're airbrushed) will respond with "WHAT? But you're so chubby!"... so then I got out of high school and got to pick some GREAT female friends who don't have crazy diet issues. Yay! So now I don't have to feel like something is wrong with me for eating a whole bowl of chocolate mousse, or a slice of cheesecake, or whatever. (But society still talks about dieting as moral - it's almost the only thing someone is going to be referring to if they talk about being "good" or "bad").
I want to make note that I am on the best diet ever. Its called the see food diet. I see food, I eat it :)
 

NoNameMcgee

New member
Feb 24, 2009
2,104
0
0
Occasionally I think I'm fat... and I'm pretty skinny. Don't know what brings it on exactly, but I just look down at myself if I'm sitting and notice how my skin rolls together and think "OMFG I HAVE SO MUCH FLAB." But I'm extremely conscious about my looks and constantly trying to look my best, so I kind of freak out from that kind of stuff.

I'm a guy though. But I think I know how some of these girls feel. I've always been quite girly so perhaps this is just another feminine quality of mine. I keep my cool out of the house though and keep my confident image going, even though I'm never really 100% happy with my looks.
 

case_orange

New member
Mar 24, 2010
52
0
0
Well, if they're American girls, then they probably are.

2/3s of USAians qualify as overweight; almost a full 1/3 of those overweight ones qualify as obese.

Assuming then that those statistics affect men and women equally -- that is, there is no gender skewing -- then yeah, most of them *are* fat. And I'm willing to bet the ones who ain't are self-conscious about falling into that trap. Especially given the women portrayed in the media.
 

Kelbear

New member
Aug 31, 2007
344
0
0
Fishing for compliments. They want you to say:

1) "No, you're not fat." Response: "Naw, you're just trying to make me feel better"
2)

It has nothing to do with weight and everything to do with how they want you to make them feel. What you say is barely even relevant to /how/ you say it.
 

IrirshTerrorist

New member
Jul 25, 2009
555
0
0
space_oddity said:
Because slightly more than half of all the women in the world are, and voice their disgruntlement aloud, and the the other less-than-half want to fit in, because the fat ones might eat them otherwise.
... maybe if the thin half eat the fat half we'll have half the women but they'll all be just the right size...

(I apologise to the author of this thread because he specified a serious discussion, but I just couldn't help bring it down to my humour level)
 

Dexiro

New member
Dec 23, 2009
2,977
0
0
I always thought it was blown out of proportion and that none of my female friends were like that.

Until... one day they arrived at college with this calorie book stressing about how everything is making them fat.
They sounded like they were almost about to bloody cry yelling "OMG TOAST HAS 2 CALORIES, WHY IS EVERYTHING SO FATTENING". I doubt they even know what calories are or how much constitutes as fattening.
Somewhere around 1500 calories is the daily MINIMUM for women. These people seem to think that eating that much will instantly make them obese.

So yeah it's worse than i thought. There isn't many girls i know now that don't think they're fat.
 

Riobux

New member
Apr 15, 2009
1,955
0
0
ProfessorLayton said:
My question is why are teenage girls like that? I want serious discussion here, not "Because you touch yourself at night."

I really think that it's the media. Constantly being shown touched up pictures of models can make people start comparing themselves to other people and are always looking for the negatives. What do you think?
Honestly, I'm going through a similar issue myself with a girl I like where she is out-right determined that she is ugly and fat and so on. I've tried all sorts to convince her she's beautiful and while she is technically obese, she is fine the way she is. I then sort of shrugged my shoulders, told her to not go below 8 stone in weight if she does lose weight and I'd be there if she needs help.

Honestly, it's probably due to media and the built in concept society that everyone must be thin. Granted, this is due to health because if you're over-weight then you have a greater risk of death, but there are people who go over the top. However, because they're splashed across media for one reason or another, girls not only seek to become that thin, they bully others who aren't as thin to make up for the insecurity that they're not thin enough to fall over in a strong wind.

I think it boils down to insecurity though. We all have insecurities about our selves. Let it be that we think we're dumb, or that we can't write good stories, or that we're absolutely ugly as hell. It's that for all the people who think they're ugly as hell (and that's the most popular one since society is increasingly materialistic), they find that losing weight is the easiest thing to do. No matter what people say to them, like people love them the way they are and they really don't want them to change, they're still trapped into a depressive view of themselves. I think girls tend to be more vain than boys because the media and stereotypes portray that girls should be pretty. However, since there's no such thing as "pretty" in an objective sense, they look subjectively at other people and attempt to copy characteristics they like about them. Which, because the easiness of losing weight compared to other things, involves copying weight. So they're not happy being "husky" or large, but still the correct weight, they must be thin. They must be on the lower scale of the correct weight and if they dip into under-weight, why should they care?

Honestly, it's reasons like this why I'm interested in things like conformity, just because without the need to conform we may be better off. Sure conformity is a requirement to an extent, but it's materialistic conformity that should just jump off a cliff. The conformity that makes us buy certain types of clothes or certain types of goods for our apartment not because they're practical but just because they look good. Conformity makes some people throw up into a toilet daily just so they can conform easier. Conformity makes some people spend £30,000+ just so they can have a different nose or a different lips, who cares if they look generally worse afterwards. Conformity makes people slice their wrists open on a daily basis because they are frustrated on being unable to conform completely and slicing themselves is the most conformist way to relieve themselves from the pains of life.
 

Kenni-chan

New member
Nov 1, 2009
173
0
0
I think it's just a girl thing....But after I started gaming I don't really give a fuck now, as long as I don't have an ass the size of the boomer's I'm happy.

But I blame the media so much emphisis on skinny girls and naturally thin people just isn't good for the undeveloped sence of perception young girls have
 

Andantil

New member
May 10, 2009
575
0
0
I wouldn't say that "all" girls do, but more do than they should. In America it's because most girls ARE fat, for girls who aren't see the reason for other places.

In other nations it's because of the unrealistic standard of beauty presented by the media. Mainly by America.
 

Shannon Baber

New member
Mar 3, 2010
54
0
0
I'd have to agree with everybody that said the media/models. I know personally I've grown up with a older sister who has always been prettier/smaller than me, it can be rough to live with :/


G1eet said:
To all the girls out there- if I think you're fat, I'll tell you. But I'm generally a nice guy, so I'll still be nice to you.

But you'd have to be queen of the sea cows for me to say something.
Bhahahahaha queen of the sea cows

Wow I just scrolled up and noticed how awesome Riobux's post, well done :D
 

Juicebox Ltd.

New member
Apr 14, 2010
8
0
0
I went swimming earlier today and I hit the sauna afterwards... I met a nice girl there and we started talking about the General Election (Yes, Politics, being the enthralling Casanova that I am), and for no apparent reason after the conversation had died out she embarked on a rant on how she needs to swim more often because she felt too fat.

Now what am I to say in this scenario? "Yes my dear, you are" or attempt to reassure her?, I went for the latter option, but she kept saying that "I was just saying that" and "the mirror doesn't lie" etc. The exact same story goes for my two sisters...both elder than me, who seem convinced they are fat despite barely tipping 11 stone on the scales. So the mystery to me is why do they seem so unwilling to listen to anyone else? Has the pressure bestowed by modern media upon the average woman to look good caused such brainwashing effects? Or does it tie in with societies never ending strive to be perfect? Or perhaps those numerous size zero models shamelessly ?setting the standard? as it where?

I personally go with all of the above, there simply is no convincing a woman otherwise.
(At least in my experiences)