I cannot comment on the sheer size of both games fanbases, and of course this would not be possible since there is no single definition of a fan.Bigeyez said:Except that this thread isn't to discuss why I like a certain game better then the other. It was to discuss "Halo hate". We've both gone really off topic and into a pointless discussion which is wasting both our time.Moccamonster said:You can go ahead and blurt out your opinion, but without any reasoning behind it, there is no sense in posting it in a forum, since the entire point of a forum is to discuss viewpoints, ideas etc.
And come on...the Halo fanbase IS bigger then Half-Life's. Just like Mickey Mouse's or Barbie's or Pokemon's fanbase is bigger. You can't honestly think HL has a bigger fanbase then Halo do you?
Regarding all the other stuff you said I can't really say anything. Like I said before you have your opinions and thats it. I'm still not exactly sure why the hell we're even argueing when I already said I'm not even trying to persuade anyone to agree with me, I'm simply stating my opinion.
However, what i see with the HL-fanbase is a lot more devotion. The sheer amount and quality of mods, maps, skins etc within the community is simple amazing, though this is obviously attributed to HL being a PC game more then anything else(meaning this comment only applies to the PC versions).
And while you are right that this futile discussion is quite frankly a waste of both your and my time, i guess this is just my desperation in finding out what pushes certain people to hold Halo 3 as a breakthrough in the genre and gaming as a whole.