10 year old girl Rapes 4 year old boy

[Headsprouter]

Hmmm. It seems this is being sensationalised. By the sound of things she just got a bit too curious and fondled the 4 year-old, some busy-body saw it and decided that it was much worse than it really was. A 10 year old girl is barely even sexually aware in the same way adults are, if not at all.

She also had two fingers up his anus... so no.

Right, that changes things a lot. I just watched the video, assuming it would sum up what was going on, but it was likely for daytime television, so that part wasn't mentioned.

Given that, I'm still not sure. Though I am sure she needs to be punished by her mother, but I don't think the authorities need to be this involved. She was certainly mean to the little boy and took advantage of his size and innocence, for which punishment of some kind goes without saying.

As long as the little boy got out of this unharmed and no future kids get harmed.

 

[Amir Kondori]

What the fuck does she need to be punished for? People don't like to admit it but how many people reading this have played "doctor" when you were a kid? Unless that kid was unhappy about what was happening and wanted it to stop then it is completely NORMAL play among children.

I can't believe they are trying to prosecute. I can't believe there is a jury that will convict this girl.

 

[Amir Kondori]

The worlds gone mad if a little kid playing doctor with another little kid is being charged with aggravated rape, End of story

Well.. she did shove two fingers up a 4-year-old boys anus... by the legal definition of rape, that makes it rape.
Now, if she'd done it in the UK in stead of the US, she wouldn't have been charged with rape, since UK laws define rape to be penetration by "the man's penis".
Meaning legally, only men can perpetrate rape in the UK.

Your post is the only source I can find for that accusation. Care to back it up with a source?

 

[Colour Scientist]

But you know he's a boy, he can't get raped. (sarcasm)

Not one single person has suggested that.

 

[rasputin0009]

I wouldn't doubt that the girl was sexually abused by someone else in her life. Could have even happened just recently before this. An investigation from child services wouldn't be all that bad an idea. A better idea than calling the fucking police.

Off-topic, the mods are getting real horny (not an insult to the mods, just an expression) off this thread. I saw like 5 suspensions/warnings on the first page alone.

 

[Jamieson 90]

The fact she's a sexually aware 10 year old girl and he's a 4 year old toddler means it's an exertion of power and predatory behavior by default. But you know he's a boy, he can't get raped. (sarcasm)

I know and I pointed out this too and I think it's a real problem that we (in general) trivialize anything that happens to men and boys, like I said can you imagine the hysteria if it was "10 year old boy rapes 4 year old girl?" Yeah it really does pay to swap the sexes in situations like this.

 

[Carpenter]

Misleading title is misleading...



What do you do to a curious little girl? Charge her with sexual assault is what you do! That's sure to alleviate the issue with the least amount of stress on the child.

I'm not saying what she did was right, she should certainly be punished, but it should be in way she can understand and one that doesn't scar her for life.

We both know if the genders were reversed, you people would be calling for the boy to be in prison or in some kind of asylum for future rapists.

We are not talking about a curious girl. Ten year olds are past the point of understanding that they are not supposed to do that.

 

[Donzacuceron]

I wouldn't doubt that the girl was sexually abused by someone else in her life. Could have even happened just recently before this. An investigation from child services wouldn't be all that bad an idea. A better idea than calling the fucking police.

Off-topic, the mods are getting real horny (not an insult to the mods, just an expression) off this thread. I saw like 5 suspensions/warnings on the first page alone.

The question here is not why, the crime was committed or where she learned this behavior. The question is ?did she do it?? If there is enough proof to charge her of committing the crime, the question is ?should she be charges as an adult or a juvenile?. If tried as a juvenile, the punishment should be appropriate to the punishment prescribed by law. The question should NEVER be ?should we turn our head because of her age?? Rape is rape and there is NEVER a justification. If convicted, she must pay for the crime.
An investigation may find her parents or someone else should also be charged with committing other crimes. If so they should also be arrested and charged.

 

[Carpenter]

But you know he's a boy, he can't get raped. (sarcasm)

Not one single person has suggested that.

Not on this thread, but yes that ideology is pretty common now.

 

[JoJo]

You people are utterly wrong about this, and I speak from experience. I was abused by a boy who was eleven at the time, myself a couple of years younger and I can tell you it has scarred me for life. The memories of the incident will stay with me forever, It was accompanied by threats, violence and force over several months. For you to dismiss it as 'playng doctor' only demonstrates your ignorance. It is deeply offensive to see you all act so dismissively without any of the facts and personally, I think she deserves to be punished. If you think her crying is some tragedy, you have no idea of the impact this episode could have on the boy. Don't presume to know the lasting effect because I assure you, it has the potential to be very damaging. To a certain extent I would say that what happened to me will hurt me for the rest of my life.

The bolded part is why this case may be different to yours, and indeed if you think she deserves to be punished, you are judging without facts just as much as your perceived opposition did. There's no reason to think that this event was accompanied by threats or violence, or that the girl had malicious intentions and we shouldn't project such things onto this case.

 

[Carpenter]

I wouldn't doubt that the girl was sexually abused by someone else in her life. Could have even happened just recently before this. An investigation from child services wouldn't be all that bad an idea. A better idea than calling the fucking police.

Off-topic, the mods are getting real horny (not an insult to the mods, just an expression) off this thread. I saw like 5 suspensions/warnings on the first page alone.

Again if this was a boy nobody would be saying "oh he's probably the one being abused, let's look into this" and that's the problem I have with this.

It's like when a female adult admits to having sex with young students. Nobody calls it rape (it is) and people do nothing but make excuses for her. It's sick.

Someone should just go kill all of them.

 

[Daystar Clarion]

Misleading title is misleading...



What do you do to a curious little girl? Charge her with sexual assault is what you do! That's sure to alleviate the issue with the least amount of stress on the child.

I'm not saying what she did was right, she should certainly be punished, but it should be in way she can understand and one that doesn't scar her for life.

We both know if the genders were reversed, you people would be calling for the boy to be in prison or in some kind of asylum for future rapists.

We are not talking about a curious girl. Ten year olds are past the point of understanding that they are not supposed to do that.

I'm so glad you know what I'm thinking more than I do myself.

That will sure take the sting out of having to do anything, ever.

Oh look, there's some pigs flying over a rainbow made from the distilled dreams of small children and puppies, I wonder what happens when I follow it! What's this? Half Life 3? Man, this day is turning out to be the best day ever!

 

[Daystar Clarion]

Misleading title is misleading...



What do you do to a curious little girl? Charge her with sexual assault is what you do! That's sure to alleviate the issue with the least amount of stress on the child.

I'm not saying what she did was right, she should certainly be punished, but it should be in way she can understand and one that doesn't scar her for life.

We both know if the genders were reversed, you people would be calling for the boy to be in prison or in some kind of asylum for future rapists.

We are not talking about a curious girl. Ten year olds are past the point of understanding that they are not supposed to do that.

I'm so glad you know what I'm thinking more than I do myself.

That will sure take the sting out of having to do anything, ever.

Oh look, there's some pigs flying over a rainbow made from the distilled dreams of small children and puppies, I wonder what happens when I follow it! What's this? Half Life 3? Man, this day is turning out to be the best day ever!

You're right, that was an unfair assumption.

Just like it would be unfair to assume that you wouldn't be making childish stupid jokes if this was a thread about a news story of a woman or a girl being raped.

It would be an unfair assumption, although a true one. No I don't know what you are thinking, I just know how you are acting. There's a world of difference. Maybe while you are so obsessed with your video games that you bring half life 3 up in response to a story about sexual abuse, you can do some research and educate yourself.

Ouch, nice ad hominem, is there a point you're trying to get across? Other than the fact you can't do it without demeaning others I mean?

 

[Amir Kondori]

Misleading title is misleading...



What do you do to a curious little girl? Charge her with sexual assault is what you do! That's sure to alleviate the issue with the least amount of stress on the child.

I'm not saying what she did was right, she should certainly be punished, but it should be in way she can understand and one that doesn't scar her for life.

We both know if the genders were reversed, you people would be calling for the boy to be in prison or in some kind of asylum for future rapists.

We are not talking about a curious girl. Ten year olds are past the point of understanding that they are not supposed to do that.

I'm so glad you know what I'm thinking more than I do myself.

That will sure take the sting out of having to do anything, ever.

Oh look, there's some pigs flying over a rainbow made from the distilled dreams of small children and puppies, I wonder what happens when I follow it! What's this? Half Life 3? Man, this day is turning out to be the best day ever!

You're right, that was an unfair assumption.

Just like it would be unfair to assume that you wouldn't be making childish stupid jokes if this was a thread about a news story of a woman or a girl being raped.

It would be an unfair assumption, although a true one. No I don't know what you are thinking, I just know how you are acting. There's a world of difference. Maybe while you are so obsessed with your video games that you bring half life 3 up in response to a story about sexual abuse, you can do some research and educate yourself.

Chill out with the personal stuff. Keep it to the facts and how you feel.

 

[Carpenter]

Misleading title is misleading...



What do you do to a curious little girl? Charge her with sexual assault is what you do! That's sure to alleviate the issue with the least amount of stress on the child.

I'm not saying what she did was right, she should certainly be punished, but it should be in way she can understand and one that doesn't scar her for life.

We both know if the genders were reversed, you people would be calling for the boy to be in prison or in some kind of asylum for future rapists.

We are not talking about a curious girl. Ten year olds are past the point of understanding that they are not supposed to do that.

I'm so glad you know what I'm thinking more than I do myself.

That will sure take the sting out of having to do anything, ever.

Oh look, there's some pigs flying over a rainbow made from the distilled dreams of small children and puppies, I wonder what happens when I follow it! What's this? Half Life 3? Man, this day is turning out to be the best day ever!

You're right, that was an unfair assumption.

Just like it would be unfair to assume that you wouldn't be making childish stupid jokes if this was a thread about a news story of a woman or a girl being raped.

It would be an unfair assumption, although a true one. No I don't know what you are thinking, I just know how you are acting. There's a world of difference. Maybe while you are so obsessed with your video games that you bring half life 3 up in response to a story about sexual abuse, you can do some research and educate yourself.

Chill out with the personal stuff. Keep it to the facts and how you feel.

ok, I feel he wouldn't be defending this if it was a girl that was raped and a boy that did it. I feel like this whole society is proving itself worthy of a massive cleansing.

Is that better?

 

[Carpenter]

Misleading title is misleading...



What do you do to a curious little girl? Charge her with sexual assault is what you do! That's sure to alleviate the issue with the least amount of stress on the child.

I'm not saying what she did was right, she should certainly be punished, but it should be in way she can understand and one that doesn't scar her for life.

We both know if the genders were reversed, you people would be calling for the boy to be in prison or in some kind of asylum for future rapists.

We are not talking about a curious girl. Ten year olds are past the point of understanding that they are not supposed to do that.

I'm so glad you know what I'm thinking more than I do myself.

That will sure take the sting out of having to do anything, ever.

Oh look, there's some pigs flying over a rainbow made from the distilled dreams of small children and puppies, I wonder what happens when I follow it! What's this? Half Life 3? Man, this day is turning out to be the best day ever!

You're right, that was an unfair assumption.

Just like it would be unfair to assume that you wouldn't be making childish stupid jokes if this was a thread about a news story of a woman or a girl being raped.

It would be an unfair assumption, although a true one. No I don't know what you are thinking, I just know how you are acting. There's a world of difference. Maybe while you are so obsessed with your video games that you bring half life 3 up in response to a story about sexual abuse, you can do some research and educate yourself.

Ouch, nice ad hominem, is there a point you're trying to get across? Other than the fact you can't do it without demeaning others I mean?

I can easily do it without demeaning you, it's just that you are making that part too easy.

You said this is just a curious girl. My point was that ten year olds are to the point where they can consciously understand that it's wrong to take advantage of smaller kids. We are talking about a very big age difference. You are presenting it as if it's a harmless game kids play.

He was four, she was ten. She was taking advantage of him, it should be dealt with instead of just letting it go and letting her develop knowing that society thinks it's ok.

 

[SanguiniusMagnificum]

Aaah... the Good Ol' US of A, setting a fine example for the rest of the world since 1776....

 

[Amir Kondori]

Misleading title is misleading...



What do you do to a curious little girl? Charge her with sexual assault is what you do! That's sure to alleviate the issue with the least amount of stress on the child.

I'm not saying what she did was right, she should certainly be punished, but it should be in way she can understand and one that doesn't scar her for life.

We both know if the genders were reversed, you people would be calling for the boy to be in prison or in some kind of asylum for future rapists.

We are not talking about a curious girl. Ten year olds are past the point of understanding that they are not supposed to do that.

I'm so glad you know what I'm thinking more than I do myself.

That will sure take the sting out of having to do anything, ever.

Oh look, there's some pigs flying over a rainbow made from the distilled dreams of small children and puppies, I wonder what happens when I follow it! What's this? Half Life 3? Man, this day is turning out to be the best day ever!

You're right, that was an unfair assumption.

Just like it would be unfair to assume that you wouldn't be making childish stupid jokes if this was a thread about a news story of a woman or a girl being raped.

It would be an unfair assumption, although a true one. No I don't know what you are thinking, I just know how you are acting. There's a world of difference. Maybe while you are so obsessed with your video games that you bring half life 3 up in response to a story about sexual abuse, you can do some research and educate yourself.

Chill out with the personal stuff. Keep it to the facts and how you feel.

ok, I feel he wouldn't be defending this if it was a girl that was raped and a boy that did it. I feel like this whole society is proving itself worthy of a massive cleansing.

Is that better?

It's not better. You are letting your personal anger get the better of you and taking it out on Daystar by putting words in his mouth and ascribing actions and thoughts to him that he has denied. It is a low blow and not ok.

Also, I've reported your posts.

 

[Daystar Clarion]

Misleading title is misleading...



What do you do to a curious little girl? Charge her with sexual assault is what you do! That's sure to alleviate the issue with the least amount of stress on the child.

I'm not saying what she did was right, she should certainly be punished, but it should be in way she can understand and one that doesn't scar her for life.

We both know if the genders were reversed, you people would be calling for the boy to be in prison or in some kind of asylum for future rapists.

We are not talking about a curious girl. Ten year olds are past the point of understanding that they are not supposed to do that.

I'm so glad you know what I'm thinking more than I do myself.

That will sure take the sting out of having to do anything, ever.

Oh look, there's some pigs flying over a rainbow made from the distilled dreams of small children and puppies, I wonder what happens when I follow it! What's this? Half Life 3? Man, this day is turning out to be the best day ever!

You're right, that was an unfair assumption.

Just like it would be unfair to assume that you wouldn't be making childish stupid jokes if this was a thread about a news story of a woman or a girl being raped.

It would be an unfair assumption, although a true one. No I don't know what you are thinking, I just know how you are acting. There's a world of difference. Maybe while you are so obsessed with your video games that you bring half life 3 up in response to a story about sexual abuse, you can do some research and educate yourself.

Ouch, nice ad hominem, is there a point you're trying to get across? Other than the fact you can't do it without demeaning others I mean?

I can easily do it without demeaning you, it's just that you are making that part too easy.

Can't help yourself can you? You're water off a duck's back, it just says more about you.

You said this is just a curious girl. My point was that ten year olds are to the point where they can consciously understand that it's wrong to take advantage of smaller kids. We are talking about a very big age difference. You are presenting it as if it's a harmless game kids play.

And you know every 10 year old girl in the entire world? Interesting, interesting.

He was four, she was ten. She was taking advantage of him, it should be dealt with instead of just letting it go and letting her develop knowing that society thinks it's ok.

I'm so glad your powers of omnipotence come handy, why are you still here? Go! For the good of the city!