Not all Germans are Nazis, yes everyone seems to know that but surprisingly I've seen posts on the escapist that imply that they don't know that not all Germans that fought in WW2 are Nazis.
im pretty sure that the same can be said for most 'first world' countries, but america seems to be getting all the blame. maybe its because america tries to fix everybody elses problems but sometimes cant. and then gets blamed for failure.moshineko said:Easy one! America is rich! We're rich and secure enough that we honestly, honestly forget that not more than one country away, people are having a great day if they don't starve to death, and won't even bother cutting off the mold on their bread because, hell, it's the only bread they'll see this month.brodie21 said:quick question, why all the hate against Americans?
Americans are miraculously lucky. Lucky that their ancestors invested so much to make their lives good, lucky that America has great natural resources, lucky that American Indians didn't have guns or an organized military, lucky that they can eat every day, sleep in a warm house, and that their biggest worry is how many people will be jerks that day.
And damn if everyone hates someone who is more successful then them for no good reason. It's not hate, it's really jealousy. Not that Americans are so wonderful that everyone wants to be them, but America has a lot of power, a lot of money, and a lot of influence, and people are jealous of that. Can't blame them, really. Wish we could make everyone as rich and happy as America, but if we can't, I'm damn glad to be on the winning side.
Serbian assassin - Gavrilo Princip.Aiden_the-Joker1 said:Really the cause was a Siberian assassin, France and Britain's ally, who killed Franz Ferdinand causing Austria-Hungary to retaliate, which made Russia attack them, German and Italy then came to their ally's defence which France into it. Germany then invaded Belgium to get to France. Which caused Britain to get involved. Many people look at WW2 as Germany getting revenge for the unfair peace treaty they were forced to sign. So you could say WW1 caused WW2. or you could just say Nazis are the embodiment of evil because they are the most racist and violent people you have heard of.
GrinningManiac said:I am and English history student, with a 90/100 A-level History in Nazi Germany
I completley concur, but would say that the reason there's so much german-hate and german-blame is for two reasons
1) Germany (not Germans, but the state) did AWFUL things in WW2 (not so much WW1) and rightly deserve all that hate. However, people are reknowned for their grudge-holding abilties, as well as bigotism, hence the ingrained belief that every German was in on the Final Solution (I.E. Deathcamps) and they all still do it today.
2) Propoganda at the time of WW1 and WW2 blamed both wars solely on Germany. WW2? Fair enough, but WW1 was, in a way, Austira/Serbia/Bosnia/Russia's fault, though everyone had been raring for a fight for about 40 years. Because of the propoganda, fierce anti-Germanism spread across France and Britain particularly. This feeling has been passed down, and still exists today
Therefore, it's a long-running and deep-cutting issue that will not resolve itself anytime son. The best we can do is educate and distinguish between German people and the German state
They also hate us because we are arrogant, try to solve everyone else's problems, and assume everyone is jelouse of us because we are rich. And by rich I mean some trillion dollers in debt.brodie21 said:im pretty sure that the same can be said for most 'first world' countries, but america seems to be getting all the blame. maybe its because america tries to fix everybody elses problems but sometimes cant. and then gets blamed for failure.moshineko said:Easy one! America is rich! We're rich and secure enough that we honestly, honestly forget that not more than one country away, people are having a great day if they don't starve to death, and won't even bother cutting off the mold on their bread because, hell, it's the only bread they'll see this month.brodie21 said:quick question, why all the hate against Americans?
Americans are miraculously lucky. Lucky that their ancestors invested so much to make their lives good, lucky that America has great natural resources, lucky that American Indians didn't have guns or an organized military, lucky that they can eat every day, sleep in a warm house, and that their biggest worry is how many people will be jerks that day.
And damn if everyone hates someone who is more successful then them for no good reason. It's not hate, it's really jealousy. Not that Americans are so wonderful that everyone wants to be them, but America has a lot of power, a lot of money, and a lot of influence, and people are jealous of that. Can't blame them, really. Wish we could make everyone as rich and happy as America, but if we can't, I'm damn glad to be on the winning side.
I suggest you read up on your history..or watch more of your Dr Who.GiantRedButton said:Nope he was not elected he tried to but failed. Ehich is prove that Hitler did not have the majority behind him. read up on your history.lostzombies.com said:But a majority of German's did democratically put Hitler into power by legal elections.caspertjuhh said:And most of all, it wasn't like all germans are nazi's.
/rant
Not knowing who started ww1 seems to be only an american problem, most brits etc know it actually.
In a doctor who episode the doctor actually tells people how it started.
Well thanks for that well informed counter there...Jester00 said:read a book.lostzombies.com said:But a majority of German's did democratically put Hitler into power by legal elections.
first: i think 90% of the germans hate nazis
second: hitler wasn't german![]()
I know of the Assassination, and the treaties. But it was all technical, it didn't seem like a real reason.HerrBobo said:Aside from all the technical stuff; the assassination, the treaties, ect (which I'm sure you know) one very important point is often left out; war, 1914 was still seen, by all the powers invovled as an acceptable means of foreign policy.Spummy said:And they're REALLY not responsible for WW1 from what I've seen. I've never been given a proper reason why that war started. Just looked like all the European powers wanted to have a fight over who had the biggest piece. (Anyone that could provide some historical insight with a good motivation would be nice)
er, the germans WERE solely responsible for those wars... they started them. both times. consistently.caspertjuhh said:I see a lot of german hate on these forums. I considered these forums to be relatively mature, yet I see so much historical fails.
It is indeed commom belief, that the Germans were responsible for both WW1 and 2.
I think it is very hypocrite to think ONLY the germans were responsible for those wars, and also very naive to think Germany was the only country in europe with jew hate around WW2. France was worse, but the lost, so they couldn't help it.
And most of all, it wasn't like all germans are nazi's. Better yet, almost all the country's they conquered had a lot of nazi-germany sympathisers.
And, no, I am not German, I am a Dutch history student.
/rant
How? The state of Israel was planned to be given 54% of Palestine by the UN, that alone is a little outragous but it's also aceptable. BUT the sionists took the landarea before the UN had made the greenlight for it. Now certein groups of palestinian citizents would start fighting back, resulting in giving the Israeli goverment a reason to start pushing the borders. (Taking other peapole's land, check! "la resistance", check!) after 60 years of occupation now the Palestinian goverment is non existent and most of the people live in closed in quarters, some are even shot at for training purposes! Israeli citizents throw poo at them in the streets because they are brainwashed by their goverment that "they bad". just like the germans with jews, and the americans with muslims in general.bladeofdarkness said:comparing the situation between Israel and the Palestinians to Nazi Germany shows complete ignorance regarding both Nazi Germany AND the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.Renamedsin said:Damnit! ninja'd! T_Ttomtom94 said:Hey, Godwin's Law!
OT: the Nazi party was a facistic bunch of sadistic bdsm-loving nutjobs. The German population circles majorly around the later. there is no question about the actions of the germans during WWII, but that is a thing of the past. We have learned, it will never happen again, I hope.
Exept that it is happening right now, by the Israeli towards the Palestinian people. and the nazis are growing back in Italy, Hungary and eastern europe in generall. Even in sweden. oh shi-
I think you are comparing soldiers lives with lives of innocent civilians. It may sound a bit cruel, but soldiers accept/sing up that they are going to die. That's why Pearl Harbor wasn't a war crime, and why bombing hiroshima and nagasaki was.brodie21 said:where are you from?AxCx said:I see you are from America.brodie21 said:dude, germany started world war two and continued fighting in world war one even after those who had started it had stopped fighting. they executed six million people of jewish descent and bombed the shit out of london.
hate against germans of world war 2 is justified
AMERICANS killed a good lot of people in Iraq and Vietnam. AMERICANS launched the first nuclear bomb. AMERICANS drag down the world economy.
Can you see why you are wrong yet?
i am pretty sure that we had a good reason for dropping a couple nukes on japan, say an estimated million casualties for a standard invasion? and, as for the iraq and vietnam thing, grow up, people die in war, i have friends who were there and saw it for themselves. dont blame america for all the woes of the world, because im pretty sure that your country isnt the model of civic virtue.
Haven't seen anyone blame them for it tbh, don't know where you've seen it.caspertjuhh said:I see a lot of german hate on these forums. I considered these forums to be relatively mature, yet I see so much historical fails.
It is indeed commom belief, that the Germans were responsible for both WW1 and 2.
I think it is very hypocrite to think ONLY the germans were responsible for those wars, and also very naive to think Germany was the only country in europe with jew hate around WW2. France was worse, but the lost, so they couldn't help it.
And most of all, it wasn't like all germans are nazi's. Better yet, almost all the country's they conquered had a lot of nazi-germany sympathisers.
And, no, I am not German, I am a Dutch history student.
/rant
The economic downfall was, to my understanding, some slavic country's fault. Can't remember which and I very much don't care, as for the nukes, they introduced the term "Mutually assured destruction", or as I like to call it "peace" into the world.caspertjuhh said:I think you are comparing soldiers lives with lives of innocent civilians. It may sound a bit cruel, but soldiers accept/sing up that they are going to die. That's why Pearl Harbor wasn't a war crime, and why bombing hiroshima and nagasaki was.brodie21 said:where are you from?AxCx said:I see you are from America.brodie21 said:dude, germany started world war two and continued fighting in world war one even after those who had started it had stopped fighting. they executed six million people of jewish descent and bombed the shit out of london.
hate against germans of world war 2 is justified
AMERICANS killed a good lot of people in Iraq and Vietnam. AMERICANS launched the first nuclear bomb. AMERICANS drag down the world economy.
Can you see why you are wrong yet?
i am pretty sure that we had a good reason for dropping a couple nukes on japan, say an estimated million casualties for a standard invasion? and, as for the iraq and vietnam thing, grow up, people die in war, i have friends who were there and saw it for themselves. dont blame america for all the woes of the world, because im pretty sure that your country isnt the model of civic virtue.
Actually Austria was quite responsible for both, since the assassinating of Austria's heir triggered a couple of chain reactions which led to a european war.caspertjuhh said:I see a lot of german hate on these forums. I considered these forums to be relatively mature, yet I see so much historical fails.
It is indeed commom belief, that the Germans were responsible for both WW1 and 2.
I think it is very hypocrite to think ONLY the germans were responsible for those wars, and also very naive to think Germany was the only country in europe with jew hate around WW2. France was worse, but the lost, so they couldn't help it.
And most of all, it wasn't like all germans are nazi's. Better yet, almost all the country's they conquered had a lot of nazi-germany sympathisers.
And, no, I am not German, I am a Dutch history student.
/rant
I think you need to look further than whatever magazine or blog you read that crap out of, would be happy to compare notes with you if you're open minded. If not, well not much point getting into it for me. I'll leave this though, neither side 'smells like a banquet of roses'.Renamedsin said:How? The state of Israel was planned to be given 54% of Palestine by the UN, that alone is a little outragous but it's also aceptable. BUT the sionists took the landarea before the UN had made the greenlight for it. Now certein groups of palestinian citizents would start fighting back, resulting in giving the Israeli goverment a reason to start pushing the borders. (Taking other peapole's land, check! "la resistance", check!) after 60 years of occupation now the Palestinian goverment is non existent and most of the people live in closed in quarters, some are even shot at for training purposes! Israeli citizents throw poo at them in the streets because they are brainwashed by their goverment that "they bad". just like the germans with jews, and the americans with muslims in general.bladeofdarkness said:comparing the situation between Israel and the Palestinians to Nazi Germany shows complete ignorance regarding both Nazi Germany AND the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.Renamedsin said:Damnit! ninja'd! T_Ttomtom94 said:Hey, Godwin's Law!
OT: the Nazi party was a facistic bunch of sadistic bdsm-loving nutjobs. The German population circles majorly around the later. there is no question about the actions of the germans during WWII, but that is a thing of the past. We have learned, it will never happen again, I hope.
Exept that it is happening right now, by the Israeli towards the Palestinian people. and the nazis are growing back in Italy, Hungary and eastern europe in generall. Even in sweden. oh shi-
Sir, my information is from a group of Palestinian politicians that visited my party last summer, and from several of my friends who was on the boats to Gaza. some of the people there was shot, at point blank range. thats executioning.Kurokami said:I think you need to look further than whatever magazine or blog you read that crap out of, would be happy to compare notes with you if you're open minded. If not, well not much point getting into it for me. I'll leave this though, neither side 'smells like a banquet of roses'.Renamedsin said:How? The state of Israel was planned to be given 54% of Palestine by the UN, that alone is a little outragous but it's also aceptable. BUT the sionists took the landarea before the UN had made the greenlight for it. Now certein groups of palestinian citizents would start fighting back, resulting in giving the Israeli goverment a reason to start pushing the borders. (Taking other peapole's land, check! "la resistance", check!) after 60 years of occupation now the Palestinian goverment is non existent and most of the people live in closed in quarters, some are even shot at for training purposes! Israeli citizents throw poo at them in the streets because they are brainwashed by their goverment that "they bad". just like the germans with jews, and the americans with muslims in general.bladeofdarkness said:comparing the situation between Israel and the Palestinians to Nazi Germany shows complete ignorance regarding both Nazi Germany AND the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.Renamedsin said:Damnit! ninja'd! T_Ttomtom94 said:Hey, Godwin's Law!
OT: the Nazi party was a facistic bunch of sadistic bdsm-loving nutjobs. The German population circles majorly around the later. there is no question about the actions of the germans during WWII, but that is a thing of the past. We have learned, it will never happen again, I hope.
Exept that it is happening right now, by the Israeli towards the Palestinian people. and the nazis are growing back in Italy, Hungary and eastern europe in generall. Even in sweden. oh shi-