Am I the Only Person who Hates Edward Cullen?

Recommended Videos

Lunar Shadow

New member
Dec 9, 2008
653
0
0
PedroSteckecilo said:
LewsTherin said:
Radelaide said:
I hated Lord of the Rings. I couldn't get past the first chapter because of the utter crap spluttered across the papers of that book.
Why.....*twitch*

*foams at mouth*

/faint
I suppose this isn't a good time to say that I really don't like the Drizzt books is it?
I will admit they aren't the best out there but they are rather good. Not the height of literature but it's a pulp fantasy series. At least it doesn't try to be something it's not. You do have to admit Salvatore is really good at writing fight sequences.
 

PedroSteckecilo

Mexican Fugitive
Feb 7, 2008
6,732
0
0
Yes, Salvatore does good fights and his work is very readable. I just sort of "grew out" of him when I hit 15 or 16.
 

SovietSecrets

iDrink, iSmoke, iPill
Nov 16, 2008
3,975
0
0
This thread restores my faith in humanity...thank god not everyone likes the crap that is called Twilight. Everyone i see at my school wont shut the hell up about this book, getting sick of hearing about the one of the worst books ever written.
 

dalek sec

Leader of the Cult of Skaro
Jul 20, 2008
10,237
0
0
At this rate I'm willing to call the Wraith from Stargate Atlantis as semi vampires because they atleast fit the profile. They're scary, they see humans has food, love sucking the life out of helpless humans and best part is they don't fall in love with them!
 

a7r0p05

Senior Member
Dec 10, 2008
256
0
21
I read the book (I borrowed it from a friend, thank God, didn't want to spend money on that crap) and it was o.k. but then as soon as he sparkled...f*ck that. It continued to go downhill from there.

This basically sums it up:
http://tinyurl.com/6lg9sv
 

sarahvait

New member
Nov 6, 2008
441
0
0
Liminal Dusk said:
Bunyip Andler said:
(For the sake of perspective, I'm a bisexual male who prefers females. Also, for the simplicity's sake, whenever I say "guys" or "girls" I mean straight ones.)

Out of all the things in Twilight, you're bagging on Edward?

Edward's designed to be a fantasy. He's gorgeous, sparkles and is a hopeless romantic who falls in a love with a plain jane book-reader. And he's undead. Being undead is always sexy. It's the epitome of badassery, which is something almost every girl looks for in her fantasies. (not in boyfriends, fantasies. Important distinction)

He is extremely dreamy. He has amazing beautiful eyes. That's the point. The reason why you (and I at first) get upset when girls fawn over him is jealousy. Just like you hated that really cute guy all the girls obsessed over in middle school.

When I try to explain this to guys, I use pornstars as an analogy. They're designed to be fantasies. Just like Edward, the idea of it is completely retarded. There are extremely few girls out there who geniunely enjoy sex with random strangers, moaning the whole time, trying their best to please the man while doing nothing more than rubbing themselves to pleasure themselves.
I don't dislike the actor when I say this, so ignore that straight off. I don't even DISLIKE the character, mainly because disliking imaginary people is very useless. What I dislike is Meyer's writing. The character IS supposed to be a fantasy, but part of criticism is to criticize based on the knowledge of what the person was trying to convey. I agree that was her goal, but my dislike of it is in that it wasn't a worthwhile character. The entire romance seems overly fantastic and unrealistic, more like a pornographic romance novel than an actual intellectual one. In the real world, relationships don't work like this and then work out. A book crawling with teenage angst should NOT be glorifying the way that Bella handles her relationship(s), and by making a fantasy of a male lead, she has lost any conceivable connection the reader could have to the man, because he's NOT REAL in any sense of the word. Maybe that's the intention of using Vampires, but here I don't believe that either, because of how she implements it in other characters.

To me, it sounds like a teenage girl's vampire fanfic that somehow caught on to novel popularity because of its direct-to-drama storytelling and supernatural overtones. Neither of which is acceptable.
Thank you! That's exactly what I was thinking the books were like. They're exactly like those romance novels I used to flip through in Wal-Mart when I was bored, only without all the sex to spice things up. And Edward is a clone-copy of every single guy in those books.
 

Duke Machine

New member
Aug 27, 2008
113
0
0
Well I'm a guy, I liked the book, it was good, not the best literature in the world, but still not bad. The movie I loathed however, 1/4 of the way through I was wondering how long it'd be till it was over.
 

Jamanticus

New member
Sep 7, 2008
1,213
0
0
LewsTherin said:
Lunar Shadow said:
I would hazard the guess that the amount of venom towards Twilight is so great, that the haters can't let it go, hence the amount of threads. That or the fact that the piece of shit is so popular that it's fucking everywhere and people need to reassure they aren't the only sane person left.

As for the dude above, your avatar is win. If you want a decent fantasy story look up the Legend of Drizzt series, or even Clerics Quintet. Actually fuck it, just read some damn FR books.
I've read all/most of Mr. Salvatore's books, hence the avatar.
I've only read the Drizzt and Cleric Quintet series....And the Sellsword one.......

Okay, I've read a decent amount.

He's a rather talented author, Salvatore. He may not always hit the mark with his books, but he tries new things (see 'The Spine of the World'), he goes out on limbs, he at least matures in his writing. From what I've read of Meyer (little), I've not noticed any evolving style or striving for something better......

And to all those who say Twilight and Harry Potter are better than the Lord of the Rings, I say, 'Bah!'

.....I would say a lot more. I mean a LOT.........But I won't. Needless to say, the high fantasy of Lord of the Rings is several orders of magnitude different than the young adult fiction that is the Rowling and Meyer books, but Lord of the Rings is infinitely better. Infinitely
 

Berethond

New member
Nov 8, 2008
6,474
0
0
dalek sec said:
At this rate I'm willing to call the Wraith from Stargate Atlantis as semi vampires because they atleast fit the profile. They're scary, they see humans has food, love sucking the life out of helpless humans and best part is they don't fall in love with them!
Well, actually, that one time they made that one human with the retro-virus he fell in love with that girl(I can't spell her name).
 

knottingam

New member
Dec 10, 2008
113
0
0
handofpwn said:
flare09 said:
Ya and I just hate Twilight all together. A fuck load of girls at my school were reading the books, finished them. Then when the movie came out, another fuck load of girls started reading them, and the ones that finished the books already read them again.

It really pisses me off that bad ass vampires were never as cool as these homo-licious let's stop a car with my hand and no one will notice tards.
At least twilight is spreading literacy among today's youth.
But does it really count if the material is so god-awful that it barely counts as literature?
 

ZombieFace

New member
Dec 16, 2008
254
0
0
Mr0llivand3r said:
Seriously.

It's like everywhere you look there's jargon about how Edward Cullen is "like, soooooo dreamy, and, like, sooooooooooo sexy." I read the book before the film came out to see what people were so excited about. The story was barely tolerable before the film.

FUCK Twilight.

Sorry to burst your bubble ladies, but vampires aren't real. and if they were real i'm sure they would prefer to rape and kill you instead of doing what Edward Cullen would do which is save you from his girly-boy vampires and wear make-up like the pansy he is.

no offense to the actor, because he does a great job with ACTING and i give him all the respect in the world for being cast in such a coveted role.

but shut up about Edward Cullen and his "super-sexy eyes" and "totally hot vampire-ness" you pathetic prepubescent adolescent fangirls.


so please tell me that i'm not the only person who is sick of this Twilight bullshit.

and please, if you disagree with me, reply to this thread with a long drawn out essay about how Twilight is well written and the film was well made and then tell me how i'm just jealous that i'm not a vampire like Edward Cullen as your eyes glisten with hopeful longing for a fictional romance character. because then that would only validate your pointless embarrassing existence.
Excuse my french, but You sir are a fucking genius.
 

JakalMc

New member
Nov 26, 2008
173
0
0
Aardvark said:
I've somehow managed to miss this whole twilight thing. I haven't seen it, heard anything about it or listened to people talk about it. The only information I have is from twilight hate threads on this very forum. This is a weird new experience for me, being amongst people who despise something so utterly, yet continue to bring it up. I've never been an unbiased observer before (Though by the very act of posting, I'm giving up said status now), so it's fascinating to see you all wallow in your own hatred like this.
This.

I hadn't heard of it at all until the movie came out and hatred spewed forth from every corner of this website. I can't judge it yet but from the sounds of it I'll probably end up hating it too...
 

knottingam

New member
Dec 10, 2008
113
0
0
I don't just hate Edward Cullen, I hate the entire Twilight series. Not just on its own non-merits (what little I've read of the books was enough to make me suffer a relapse of my pyromaniacal tendencies), but because of what it does to teenage girls, particularly my sister--and, as a consequence, what it has done to me.

I had the great misfortune to be at a Borders on the night of the release of the final book. Before this, Twilight was a non-entity to me: I was vaguely aware of its existence, and knew that it was some kind of chick literature. Anyway, I was at Borders to drop off my sister for the release event, where she was meeting her friends, and I decided that I might as well stay and browse around for a bit.
Near the magazines section, there was a large cluster of people, mostly teenage girls, in the center of which were two girls with microphones, saying things that didn't make sense to me, and whose every statement was followed by a squeal from the crowd. I asked a passersby what was going on, and she enthusiastically told me that it was a debate about whether Isabel would choose Edward or Jacob. My response to her excitement was a confused "Huh?" Needless to say, this did not pique my interest, so I went away to the sci-fi section and tried to ignore the screaming of the crowd.
As it grew closer to midnight, I half-noticed that the place was steadily growing more crowded with teenage girls, a good number of whom were dressed up as characters from the book. My rabid-fangirl danger sense was fully alert now, but the books overpowered my urge to leave.
By 11:58, the place was packed wall-to-wall with girls, and I realized that I had been a fool not to leave earlier, when I had had the chance. There was now absolutely no way out from where I was, but I tried to push through the crowd nonetheless. Finally, I heard an announcer somewhere begin a countdown, which caused me to inwardly groan with despair and outwardly brace for impact.
I ducked my head and covered my ears, and when the countdown reached zero...it was like a sonic detonator had gone off in the place. After a few seconds, though, the screaming was replaced by a dull, distant roar. I lifted my head and looked around, only to see that the girls were still screaming--but I could barely hear them! I snapped my hands next to my ears to be sure, and there was no doubting that I had gone almost completely deaf.
I got outside as quickly as I could (which still took five minutes or so), and by then my hearing had partially returned. To this day I'm sure that my hearing isn't quite as sharp as it was before than night.
 

knottingam

New member
Dec 10, 2008
113
0
0
Jamanticus said:
And to all those who say Twilight and Harry Potter are better than the Lord of the Rings, I say, 'Bah!'

.....I would say a lot more. I mean a LOT.........But I won't. Needless to say, the high fantasy of Lord of the Rings is several orders of magnitude different than the young adult fiction that is the Rowling and Meyer books, but Lord of the Rings is infinitely better. Infinitely
People actually say that? And here I thought that literary ignorance couldn't sink any lower...

To borrow a phrase, anyone who says such a thing in all seriousness needs be added to a government de-population list.
 

knottingam

New member
Dec 10, 2008
113
0
0
a7r0p05 said:
I read the book (I borrowed it from a friend, thank God, didn't want to spend money on that crap) and it was o.k. but then as soon as he sparkled...f*ck that. It continued to go downhill from there.

This basically sums it up:
http://tinyurl.com/6lg9sv
Epic win!
 

chronobreak

New member
Sep 6, 2008
1,865
0
0
This whole thing is about Ed Cullen being attractive, getting the girls to dote on him, and the nerds are left in the dust. Everyone knows it's a bad movie, yeah, but if you don't like it, don't watch it. Trust me, you're not being the savior of your generation by critizing the movie, you're just another voice amongst your peers who knows what's up.

We can't all be Ed Cullen dude, I'm sorry. But, he sells tickets. Most things that are a pop culture phenomenon are like that. No substance. And that's pretty much it.
 

Zadred Darkflame

New member
Dec 15, 2008
8
0
0
I had a girl I was interested in who begged me to read the books. I torrented them, got to page 14 of the first, and deleted them from my hard drive. I'd get more literary enjoyment out of reading R.L. Stine.

Jules Verne, Cervantes or Francois Rabelais anyone? Or how about Egil's Saga which is purportedly by Snorri Sturluson. Real literature. I really want a T-shirt that says Edward Cullen can suck my dick.