But you do understand that you're saying this in a thread in which someone is supposed to argue what Bush did right? It seems to imply that you actually DO think torture is right.Seekster said:I know, im not saying water boarding is right, im just saying that in this case I really dont mind it.ButtonedDownParadox said:Definition for 'principle' according to Merriam-Webster:
1 a: a comprehensive and fundamental law, doctrine, or assumption b (1): a rule or code of conduct (2): habitual devotion to right
Also what you say of U.S. military training may have been true. Why do I say that? Because during World War II the Japanese would waterboard American P.O.W.s for intel. Would you like to know what was done to the people who would order that? They were tried and executed by America for war crimes according to the Geneva Convention.
I don't generally support torture but against a guy like the one we were talking about I wouldn't have a problem with it. I agree its still wrong since it is technically torture but that doesn't change the way I feel about this particular instance. And besides sometimes you DO get valid info from harsh treatment of prisoners or even through torture (though like I said I don't usually advocate torture) and so that's a bonus.ButtonedDownParadox said:But you do understand that you're saying this in a thread in which someone is supposed to argue what Bush did right? It seems to imply that you actually DO think torture is right.Seekster said:I know, im not saying water boarding is right, im just saying that in this case I really dont mind it.ButtonedDownParadox said:Definition for 'principle' according to Merriam-Webster:
1 a: a comprehensive and fundamental law, doctrine, or assumption b (1): a rule or code of conduct (2): habitual devotion to right
Also what you say of U.S. military training may have been true. Why do I say that? Because during World War II the Japanese would waterboard American P.O.W.s for intel. Would you like to know what was done to the people who would order that? They were tried and executed by America for war crimes according to the Geneva Convention.
Never mind your argument that the man on the receiving end of the torture did wrong. I mean if you just want to overlook the concept of principle then whatever. How about the fact that torture is at best ineffective? Even the damn CIA were telling the people who signed off on all of this that torture is ineffective. And yet it still went through.
Nicely donearbane said:Ignore everything from "of" to the period at the end, and it makes more sense. >![]()
I second that.Labyrinth said:Oh, I admire him. Truly. No other man could possibly have done such a fine job to ensure that Obama got elected in the last election. It was a superb performance.