high_castle said:
MaxTheReaper said:
Not having sex isn't bad - it's just a different choice than what the majority picks.
Do I think kids should be taught about sex? Yes. I do. I took health class - it's completely inadequate.
*snip*
Actually, while personally I identified many of the elements presented in that book as what one could be considered 'bad': the rampant conformity, the way 'outsiders' were treated, and the generally unpleasant nature of status and place in that society.
The sex and drugs thing? No, hedonism is only such an awful thing as we imagine it to be because of the awful consequences. In real life, you get STD's, you get pregnant, you get other people pregnant, there's violence, you can die from overdosing on drugs or will otherwise get messed up.
In the book there are almost none of these things, no conflict, no STDs, no deadly drugs (though arguably the general sedated state of the populace is a negative). Their society was a purely hedonistic one, however, what I got from it was that that kind of society was bad for
us, not that it was bad for the earth as depicted in the story. It worked for them, most of them...and in the end those people who didn't fit in, the characters who rallied against it -still- lost and the status quo was upheld. There's not really a happy ending there.